Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

Seaham Colliery Inquest, 13th April 1881 (cont.).

(The Coroner.) Is there any further evidence to call?

(Mr. A. Jones.) No.

(The Coroner.) Then, Mr. Foreman and gentlemen, I do not propose myself to detain you for any length of time with any observations. I consider it quite unnecessary to go over the voluminous depositions that have been made, for this reason, that no criminal charge can be sustained against any one, nor has there ever been any carelessness exhibited in the management and conduct, so far as the depositions have shown, nor is carelessness even suggested. As far as I can make out, everything that the present Act of Parliament mentions or speaks of has been complied with in this pit. For some time past we have been travelling about endeavouring to find if anything can be suggested for the future, rather than anything as to what is past, so as to prevent such a terrible occurrence as this recurring. There is little evidence of gas in the working places, but you must remember that the whole fixing of the sites of the explosion are in the intake, and there is only one witness who speaks as to any gas being found either in the returns or in the intake. That was the witness Spence, and that was five or six years previously to this occurrence, in a return about 50 or 60 yards from the furnace. That is the only gas that is spoken of throughout the whole of the evidence in the intakes or returns, and the witness stated that that was remedied after some expenditure, and that no gas has since been seen.

Now, with reference to the point at which the explosion is suggested to have occurred, there are two suppositions. One set of witnesses, eminent engineers, place the site at the Polka way end, and say that it might have occurred from a sudden outburst of gas. Mr. Armstrong is a witness who has had the greatest experience, being the oldest man among them, and having seen more of explosions than any other witness. He puts it as a sudden outburst of gas from some gullets near a slip dyke; and perhaps it would be as well to give Mr. Armstrong's statement upon it as far as I can give it you. He says there is a great preponderance of evidence that the seat of the explosion was at the Polka way end, and did not occur at Brown's shot, or at the bottom of the main coal staple. He goes on to say the blast swept over the stones where Brown had fired his shot, and he saw no indications that the explosion was in the neighbourhood of Brown's shot. He was supported by Messrs. Stratton, Hall, Richard Foster of South Hetton, Mr. Lindsay Wood, and Mr. Baker Foster. Mr. Stratton and Mr. Richard Foster, who, I believe, were the viewers who made the earliest examination of the pit, were not quite so strong in their evidence as to the locality of the explosion as the rest of the witnesses. They would not carry it further than to say they thought there was a preponderance of indications as to the explosion having taken place at the Polka way end. Some questions were put to these witnesses, and their opinions were confirmed by the views of the rest of the gentlemen who took the Polka way end as the site of the explosion. Mr. Wood was asked the reasons for the increased signs of fire shown about the stone drift and in the neighbourhood of the stone drift, and the reason he gave generally was that it was in the neighbourhood of the fresh air, and the explosion coming in contact with the fresh air he would naturally expect greater signs of burning.

The other suggestion was, that the explosion occurred at the stone drift, either at Brown's or Venner's shot. I need not go into the evidence, because you have heard Mr. Forman, whose view is so. You have heard it supported afterwards by Mr. Atkinson's evidence. The report of the mine inspectors is already fresh in your minds, and you cannot have forgotten the evidence that they gave. I would therefore ask you to compare the evidence of the eminent engineers on the one side with reference to the Polka way end, and the evidence of the other witnesses with reference to the ignition point being at the stone drift.

If the evidence, to which I am satisfied during this long inquiry you have given every attention, convinces you that the explosion occurred at the Polka way end, then, probably, you would at once say it was an accidental explosion, and you would not need to go any further within the matter. But if, on the other hand, you arrive at the conclusion that the shot-firing was the cause, or you cannot determine and are not satisfied that either the one or the other was the locality at which the ignition point of the explosion occurred, then I would ask you to consider the further point, and for that I will refer you to Professor Abel's report, and the valuable experiments he has made with reference to coal dust. I shall read one or two portions of it, so that it may bring it again to your minds. He says: "The proportion of fire-damp required to bring dust in a mine into operation as a rapidly burning or an exploding agent even upon a small scale and with the application of a small source of heat or flame is below the smallest amount which can be detected in the air of the mine even by the most experienced observer with the means at present in use as has been already demonstrated by the experiments of Mr. Galloway. Indeed with dusts of highly sensitive or dangerous character under those conditions and very possibly with dusts not more so than the least sensitive of the Seaham samples in the presence of a source of considerable heat and flame such as a blown-out shot or an overcharged hole would constitute a small proportion of fire-damp, the possible existence of which in the mine might not be in the least suspected, may serve as the inciting cause to the development of an explosion of coal-dust." Then further on, in examination, Mr. Wright puts this question: "I gather from your evidence that in your judgment there is danger enough in any mine which gives off inflammable gas owing to the presence of coal-dust to make it a reasonable and necessary and proper precaution in the future to water or remove the dust?" The answer was, "There is no doubt if the dust can be removed or laid it would be an important addition to the safety or diminution of the danger of blasting." That is so far as shot-firing goes in the neighbourhood of any large accumulation of dust. It would not be right of me to leave that point without at the same time calling your attention to Mr. Wood's evidence upon firing shots at the point where that ignition point is placed. Mr. Wood considered that there would be no greater danger in firing shots at this curve where Brown's shot was fired than if it was fired on the outside of the rocks near your own harbour. Now, you must remember that Professor Abel's experiments are confirmed to some extent by Mr. Wood's experiments, made at Harton. Mr. Wood admitted that the experiments were similar, but had not gone to the same extent as Professor Abel's. These are only matters for your consideration if you think the point of ignition was the shot firing, or you are not satisfied which points it occurred at.

I think I have called your attention to every point that is necessary, and to make it more plain to you I think I had better put it in the form of questions; and now in leaving you to consider your verdict the questions I would put to you are simply these :—

1. Does the evidence satisfy you that the explosion occurred at the Polka way end, from either a sudden outburst of gas or from any other cause?

2. If you say "no" to that first question, does it satisfy you that it occurred from shot-firing in the stone drift alluded to?

3. If you say "no" to the first question and "yes" to the second, or you are not satisfied either way, then I go on to the third question — Is shot-firing in stone, as at present carried out, in your opinion safe, or does it require further safeguards or restrictions?

4. Then, fourthly, after Professor Abel's comprehensive report on coal-dust and its probable connection with explosions, is it in your opinion necessary for the safety of men in mines either to water or remove it?

If you will consider these questions and answer them, I think we will have your verdict.

At 1.45 the jury retired, and after an interval of an hour they returned into Court.

(The Coroner addressing the jury): Well, gentlemen, have you agreed upon your verdict?

(The Foreman, Mr. Richardson): We have, sir. We have come to the conclusion that we are all agreed that an explosion took place, causing the deaths of James Brown and others, at Seaham Colliery, on the 8th of September; but as to the seat of that explosion we have not been able to determine. As to the other questions of the firing of shots and clearing away coal dust, we think that it may be safely left in the hands of the managers.

(Mr. Edge.) Mr. Coroner, before we separate, I think we may be allowed to say a word or two.

(Mr. Jones.) Before my learned friend addresses you upon that, I should like to say one word upon a question upon which there is a great deal of feeling, and that is, with regard to the opening of the Maudlin seam. Of course, upon the opening of that seam there will have to be a fresh inquest. I suppose I may say that now, although probably after the very exhaustive examination which had taken place, it will be nothing more than a mere formal inquiry into the death of the men who are found in the Maudlin seam. Still, at the same time, the fact of this inquest having been closed presses upon us the necessity of obtaining something like an assurance as to the probable length of time that will elapse before it is opened. Now, sir, of course I hope I will not be understood in any way to reflect upon the conduct in this matter of the mining engineers who have undertaken the responsibility of deciding when it should or should not be opened; but at the same time I am sure they will appreciate the strong feeling there is — I won't say on the part of the men only — but the strong feeling out the part of the public generally, that as soon as possible the bodies which are in the pit should be recovered and receive a decent burial.

I do not suppose that I can do more than ask for an assurance, and I am sure my request will be supported by you, sir, when I ask that the most energetic measures should be adopted for the purpose of recovering these bodies. I do not think that I can add anything to that, except to invite at the present moment some expression of opinion from those who are responsible for the working of the mine. I do not know — it is said, perhaps I might also say this, that there is some project — whether it is founded in an idle rumour or not I am not in a position to say — of once more entering the Maudlin seam, not through its recent ordinary passage, but by means of some staple being sunk. I do not know whether that is founded on fact, or whether it is a mere idle rumour. I should be glad if an assurance to the contrary were given; but at the same time if this be so it would be an indefinite postponement of the opening of the seam for the purpose of the recovery of the bodies. I think that I am echoing the sentiments of every person in this Court when I say that we should view with the greatest grief the fact that any unnecessary delay should take place in the opening of the Maudlin seam.

(Mr. Edge.) On that point I may say that Lord Londonderry has placed himself entirely in the hands of the most independent body of gentlemen — the board of direction — in this matter. It is in Lord Londonderry's private interest that the Maudlin seam should be opened as soon as possible, and as soon as possible he will be glad to do it. But he rightly has placed himself in the hands of independent gentlemen, and as soon as these gentlemen consider it in the interest of the men, that it is safe for the men, the Maudlin seam shall be opened. I do not think I can say anything further. At present, in their judgment — I am not in a position to say whether it is a correct one — but in their judgment it would be unsafe to open the Maudlin seam. It might lead to the destruction of the lives of the explorers, and it might also lead to a great deal of further damage ; but the public may rest certain that when it is safe to have the Maudlin seam opened the Maudlin seam shall be opened. That is a matter which is in the hands of gentlemen of large experience.

(The Coroner.) I suppose that will satisfy you, Mr. Jones? I myself said before that I shall open an inquiry for the purpose of seeing what is behind that closed portion of the Maudlin as soon as it is opened. During the time that we have been enquiring into this matter, I have refrained from giving a direct order, or any direction, that the Maudlin should be opened, because it was a responsibility such as I would not take upon myself after the strong evidence of eminent engineers in reference to it. I think you will have to leave it in that position. I cannot open the Maudlin; but as soon as it is opened, I shall open a fresh inquiry to see what is behind the present sealed-up portion. I cannot carry it further myself.

(Mr. Jones.) No, sir. I am bound to receive the direct assurance thus publicly made, that upon the first occasion when it is deemed safe the Maudlin seam shall be opened for the purpose of recovering the bodies of the dead.

(Mr. Edge.) The men are satisfied on that point. If I might be allowed to say in the presence of yourself, sir, I should say probably if you were not here something stronger — but I have certainly, on behalf of those who instruct me, and also strongly on my behalf; and on behalf of M. R. S. Wright, who is not able to remain, to say that we are all greatly indebted to you for the experience you have brought to bear upon this inquiry, for the patience you have shown in the course of the inquiry in listening to the evidence, and for the time you have devoted to the inquiry, and to discover, if possible, what was the origin of the disaster which unfortunately took place on the 8th of September last. I do hope that, so far as you are concerned, that those who have the means will recognize in this protracted inquiry that you ought to receive some encouragement for the time and energy you have devoted to the public service. I have to thank the Jury for the very great patience they have displayed in listening to all the evidence, and I have, on behalf of Lord Londonderry, to return his most sincere thanks to the gentlemen who constitute the board of direction, to the Government Inspector (Mr. Bell), and to Mr. Atkinson, the Assistant Inspector, for the great assistance that they afforded him, and those employed by him subsequent to the date of this disaster — the assistance which was rendered voluntarily, the assistance which was rendered at great personal inconvenience to persons who rendered it, an assistance without which it would have been difficult for Lord Londonderry, and those whom he employs, to have acted in this matter as they have done. I must say that Lord Londonderry feels that he is under a deep sense of obligation to those whom I have mentioned — an obligation which he wishes me now to express, and I think this is a fitting moment for me to put it before you.

(Mr. Jones.) On behalf of the National Miners' Association, and on behalf of the Durham Miners' Union, I beg most cordially to endorse in every particular the expression of opinion which has fallen from my learned friend's lips as to the courtesy, care, industry, and, if I may be permitted to say so, the ability which you have displayed during this inquiry. Sir, this inquiry has partaken not merely of the nature of an inquest; it has gone much further. It has assumed the character of a Government investigation into the cause of one of the most grievous calamities that has taken place in connection with mining in this country. It has, therefore, entailed upon you a much larger amount of labour and a much larger expenditure of time than would otherwise have been entailed upon you if it had been confined to the nature of an ordinary inquest. And, sir, I can only say that, in my opinion, and in the opinion of those gentlemen by whom I am instructed, that it would be not merely a graceful thing on the part of those who are in authority, but it would be an absolutely essential thing upon their part, that some recognition of that care and that industry, intelligence, and kindness which you have displayed should receive a proper and adequate recognition, whatever form that recognition might take. Sir, I beg to thank you in the most hearty manner for the kindness which you have displayed towards me personally and those whom I represent I beg also to return my thanks to the Government Inspector, Mr. Bell, and the Assistant Inspector, Mr. Atkinson, for the kindness and assistance which they have rendered to me, although, perhaps, there was no demand which could reasonably be made upon them for that assistance, but still they have freely and willingly tendered it. I do not think I ought to pass over this occasion without saying that I am indebted to my friend Mr. Edge, and those whom he represents, for the kindness and courtesy which I have at their hands received during the whole of this inquiry, and I think I am only, in saying so, echoing the feelings of those whom I represent. I do not know that I can add anything to what has fallen from the lips of my friend Mr. Edge. In conclusion, I can only say that one of the most pleasing characteristics of this inquiry has been that kindness and conciliatory spirit that has been manifested throughout the whole of the proceedings, for which we are to no small extent indebted to your (the Coroner's) kindness and consideration. I omitted to say this. As to the Jury, I have been in the position of having my back to them the whole of the time, but still, from those scant opportunities which have been afforded me in recognizing their part in this matter, I have seen that they have bestowed the most careful consideration upon the evidence which has been submitted to them, and I for one, considering the difficulties which surround this inquiry, know what an amount of almost insuperable difficulty they must have had in arriving at any other than the verdict which they seem to have most reasonably, on the whole, to have arrived at to-day.

(The Foreman of the Jury.) We cordially agree with the recommendation of Counsel on both sides that the Coroner should receive some acknowledgment for his able services.

(The Coroner.) Mr. Edge and Mr. Jones, I have to thank you very much for the remarks that you thought it your duty to make, and the handsome manner in which you have spoken of my conduct during this lengthened inquiry. As far as I am myself concerned, I have done nothing but my duty, and I have tried to carry on the investigation to such an extent, and in such a way, as to arrive at the cause of this terrible explosion, if it were possible to do so. I have to thank everyone connected with this inquiry, especially the professional gentlemen, Mr. Edge, and Mr. Jones, and Mr. Wright, from London, all of whom have given able assistance in the investigation, and without whose assistance I would have felt myself, I should say, incompetent to carry it to the conclusion that it has been brought to. I may also say that the assistance that has been rendered by the mining inspectors in reference to the inquiry has been invaluable, and I must thank the whole of them for this — namely, the altogether total absence of any unseemly disturbance or quarrel. It is the first time that I have been at such a lengthened inquiry that I have found that some altercation or dispute has not arisen between the parties representing the different sides. That is due to the conciliatory spirit and the firm determination which appeared to animate everyone connected with the inquiry to ascertain the real and true cause, if possible, of the explosion. On behalf of the jury I think they ought to have special thanks. I thank them for the great amount of time which they have employed — time, too, that is not remunerated in any way. If it be in my power to see my way to ask for any special grant to the jury for the immense loss of time, and consequently loss of business transactions, that you must have naturally incurred from the time that you have been connected with this inquiry, I certainly shall attempt it if I do not succeed. That is as far as I can say upon that point. I am much obliged to you, gentlemen, for the remarks which you have made.

The inquest was thus brought to a close.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print