1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
Seaham Colliery Inquest, 13th April 1881 (cont.).
Mr. John Forman sworn.
7,862. (Mr. Jones.) You are president of the Durham Miners' Association? — I am.
7,863. And I believe you have occupied that position for the past nine or ten year's? — I think so — about that time.
7,864. Prior to that your had large experience as a miner? — All my life.
7,865. And I believe you are acquainted with the Durham coalfields especially? — In some measure.
7,866. On the 8th of September you heard of the explosion having taken place, and you went down the pit at midnight? — I did, in company with Mr. Stratton and other gentlemen — mining engineers.
7,867. I believe that you went down by No. 3 shaft, and you proceeded to No. 3 Hutton? — We went to the Maudlin engine plane through what should be the separation doors. There was a brattice hanging at the time. The door has been blown away.
7,868. In what direction were those doors blown? — I did not see the doors, but I suppose Mr. Stratton said that they went towards No. 3 up-cast shaft.
7,869. As soon as your got on to the engine-plane No. 3, did you discover a fall? — A large fall to the right in the direction of the Maudlin engine; that is, going west.
7,870. And I believe you passed along to where Brown was lying? — I did, and saw him. He was pointed out at the moment of passing.
7,871. And you passed along the engine-plane close over the fall? — We went down the engine- plane, which had very much fallen, and went a considerable distance in, over falls. The gallery was completely choked. You could get no further; in fact, it was entirely blocked up with falls.
7,872. Up to how far did your go down the engine-plane? — I am not prepared to say, but not far from where the travelling-road is. But we went a considerable distance down ; we were obliged to return back.
7,873. Then you returned and went around the curve? — We went around the curve.
7,874. Did you find any difficulty in going around the curve? — Not the slightest ; all was as clear as this room.
7,875. (The Coroner.) That is, towards the Maudlin? — Yes; the curve in the Maudlin.
7,876. (Mr. Jones.) Well, then you got from the curve to the Maudlin travelling-way? — Then we went down the travelling-way.
7,877. What was the condition there? — The timbers were all blown out and blown in-bye — in the direction in-bye.
7,878. Where the engine-plane and the travelling-way met you found a very large fall? — Yes.
7,879. Could you pass over that? — Yes: we got over it.
7,880. You proceeded up the Maudlin travelling-way? — We proceeded down the engine-plane.
7,881. What did you find then? — We came to places which were nearly closed. There was a baulk lying on an angle, and a small seam of coal had been tapped again; but at the end of the baulk there was a small aperture, but we pushed the coals through, and there was a small seam of goaf which had fallen on this baulk, and we pushed the coal and got through, and we found it more open after that.
7,882. How far did you proceed in-bye? — To what is called the Maudlin staples, on the right.
7,883. Were there any more falls? — Yes, more or less all the way.
7,884. Now, what stopped you in your course along the Maudlin travelling way? — In going into the Maudlin staples I went on to the end on the right side, and I became affected with choke-damp, and coming out I found myself very giddy and had a tendency to fall back over. I requested the manager of Kibblesworth Colliery to stand by me, which he did, and we all retreated back, and different gentlemen were affected. Mr. Stratton was very much affected, and I was obliged to go out of the pit.
7,885. Did you go straight out of the pit? — Yes.
7,886. Passing from the curve on your way out of the pit, perhaps as you were so ill you would not have noticed the condition between the curve and No. 1 pit? — In returning I noticed nothing; I was too ill.
7,887. On the Saturday following you went down the pit again? — Yes.
7,888. Upon that occasion did you make a careful examination of the different parts of the pit? — Yes, we came to the conclusion then that no more lives could be saved.
7,889. You went down, of course, in the ordinary way, down No. 3 pit and along the Maudlin engine plane, till you came to the same place that you got at before Brown's body was found? — Yes.
7,890. Well now, what was the condition of that Maudlin Engine plane between Brown's body and Simpson's? — Well, there did not seem to be any effects at all perceptible, and things seemed to be extremely quiet there. The drilling gear was standing by the side; they had set the drilling gear; the pricker and drills and stemmer were there, but there did not seem to be any particular force exerted there to my mind, and the timber was just ordinary timber — I believe about six inches, but it was ordinary timber — and there was not the slightest portion of timber disturbed in any direction that I could see.
7,891. Further on, what were the first indications that you saw of force? — At the end of the curve, a little further on.
7,892. You mean No. 3 end of the curve? — No. 1 end of the curve, and I proceeded to No. 3 shaft travelling road as at the commencement of the curve.
7,893. I mean in the neighbourhood of Simpson's body, did you see any indications of force? — Very slight.
7,894. (Mr. Wright.) Is this coming out of the Maudlin engine plane down to the curve? — Yes.
7,895. (Mr. Jones.) From the whole distance there, where your first enter the Maudlin engine way down to the curve, you saw no indications of force? — Very small indeed, if any.
7,896. In the curve? — None whatever in the curve that I saw.
7,897. Now, at the end of the curve No. 1 what did you first see? — A few yards away from the Maudlin way down to No. 1 pit there was a large fall, there was a huge baulk and a very large stone lying upon one end of it.
7,898. Just at the junction? — A little further on towards No. 1 shaft.
7,899. You say there was a large fall? — Yes.
7,900. Did you see a baulk of timber there? — A very large one.
7,901. In what position was that lying? — It was lying at an angle, but rather across the road, but at an angle. It seemed as if one end of it was driven towards No. 1 shaft.
7,902. As if the end had been driven to No. 1 shaft? — Yes.
7,903. Now, did you notice the props which supported the timber? — I noticed the props behind that fall in going down to No. 1 shaft — the indications were all driven towards No. 1 shaft.
(Mr. Wright.) Do you mean that the indications were out-bye or in-bye.
7,904. (Mr. Jones.) (To Witness.) The indications were towards No. 1 shaft? — Yes, I may state that it was a common opinion. I never heard two opinions about it.
7,905. Now, passing on up to the shaft, did you come upon other indications in the same direction? — There was a set of tubs standing, and there was standing there a corfe of coals to load.
7,906. That was the Maudlin side of the No. 1 shaft? — Yes. Now, these tubs are covered with coal dust in any times; they have stood for days, and I used to look upon them, and I am sure the coal dust was four inches thick. There were two large battens blown down from the timbers, and I perceived that a batten similar to them was more to the Maudlin side; and I suspected that these battens had come from that and had been thrown in a southerly direction; and they were covered with dust four inches thick. I thought that these tubs were without dust, but they were four inches thick with dust. The one next the Maudlin side had been blown off the top. Supposing the explosion to have come out of the Maudlin it had blown a deal out, and the corves were blown forward to No. 1 shaft — pushed forward by the force.
7,907. Did you find the coals further on? — They were on the tubs and pushed forward.
7,908. You have no other indications to which you wish to draw attention in the No. 1 shaft. Getting up No. 1 shaft you passed No. 1 Hutton plane? — I did.
7,909. Well now, what was the first object that met with your observation there? — I saw that though the tubs had the tops blown off they were standing in the dock or dish.
7,910. That was close, I suppose, to the shaft — Not there — a few yards away from the shaft. I cannot say how many.
7,911. In No. 1? — Yes.
7,912. You noticed, you say, that they were blown? — The tops were blown off the frames.
7,913. In what direction did the tops lie? — The night that I went with Mr. Corbett, he pointed out where a lot of timber was, and there were deals and pieces of iron. I suspect that a portion of this had been blown in-bye; at any rate I fancy so.
7,914. Did you see the tubs? — Yes, I saw them, but I did not pull them out. I suspected that they were part of the tub tops. It was merely a surmise.
7,915. At any rate, this debris, whatever it was, was further in-bye than the frames and the wheels of the shaft? — I expect so.
7,916. Well, did you see the frames and wheels of the tubs? — I did.
7,917. Were they more out-bye than the debris? — Yes, I think so; and they seemed to be blown in a southerly direction. They seemed to be blown out as though they had been blown in a southerly direction.
7,918. Well now, did you pass on and come to some other tubs? — I suppose there was a man there, I know there was a pony lying dead.
7,919. Was that before you reached the other tubs? — I observed this pony lying dead. I think that there were two tubs. I am speaking from memory, because I never thought that there would have been two opinions about it. If I had I would have noted it.
7,920. You saw the pony lying. Now passing beyond the pony did you come to the tubs? — Before we came to the pony we came to the tubs. The tubs were on end as if the force was coming south.
7,921. Were they tipped on their end from north to south in-bye? — Yes.
7,922. You saw that they were resting? — They seemed as if the force had put them on end.
7,923. The exterior of the tubs was lying in-bye? — The tubs were tilted.
7,924. Was the bottom of the tub towards No. 1 shaft, or rather, was the interior of the tub towards it? — The end that was tilted up was towards No. 1 shaft — the higher end.
7,925. Were these tubs empty? — I suppose this man had been cleaning the engine plane up and had put coals in the tubs.
7,926. There were some coals in the tubs? — I did not see into any.
7,927. There were no coals in the tubs? — I did not see any coals in the tubs.
7,928. Did you see any coals lying beyond the tubs? — Yes.
7,929. A heap of coals? — They were scattered about 30 yards. Speaking to Mr. Crozier, I said, "My friend, she has had a sweep down," and he measured 30 yards of coal scattered in-bye — over about 30 yards, if I remember rightly.
7,930. What condition did you find the crossing in? — Broken.
7,931. Leaving the returns open? — Certainly.
7,932. Well now, at the crossing, did you come to any conclusion as to the direction in which the force had travelled? — It is quite true that the bricks were driven in, and that there were traces of hay blown out-bye.
7,933. There were pieces of hay blown out-bye? — The broken was blown in-bye.
7,934. Of the crossing? — Yes.
7,935. And bricks also? — And bricks also.
7,936. Going beyond the crossing, did you find hay lying scattered? — Yes.
7,937. That is going in-bye? — Yes.
7,938. Now the next point that you reached would be the stables? — Yes.
7,939. What did you find there? — The hay board was pointed out to me. I don't know how many bundles were in this circular place, and I was told that the hay was all burnt.
7,940. Part of it was burnt? — Yes; the frames of the hay board.
7,941. Was there hay lying about there in the neighbourhood of the stables? — Yes, it was scattered all the way, more or less.
7,942. Now, going beyond the stables, did you find the hay lying? — It was still scattered further in-bye. I might say that I requested the man with me to measure the distance that we could see the hay, and he measured 80 yards in the narrow travelling road.
7,943. You found the hay lying down the travelling way? — Yes; 80 yards down here.
7,944. You found the hay lying between the stables and the junction of the travelling way with the engine plane and also some distance down the engine plane? — A considerable distance beyond.
7,945. Did you go down that travelling way? — Yes, I had been down the travelling way.
7,946. What indication did you see there? — Well, there were not many indications that I saw. There was one particular thing, there was a sort of box or tub or kibble blown a considerable distance in. It was a sort of an old cistern or something of that sort, some sort of wooden thing, blown into three or four pieces.
7,947. What was the size of it? — It might be perhaps a yard diameter, thirty-six inches.
7,948. How far did you find that down the travelling way? — A considerable distance from the stables down the travelling way.
7,949. Had that been thrown out-bye or in-bye? — I think in-bye.
7,950. Did you return and go down the engine plane? — I went down the engine plane.
7,951. Before you came to the Polka way, what indications did you find down the engine plane? — Beyond the stables and coming in-bye over, we found that where there had been any timber blown it was in-bye over; and then we came to a very large fall.
7,952. You noticed the props? — Yes.
7,953. And did they appear to you to bear indications of having been blown in-bye over? — Yes.
7,954. Then all the indications, I take it, that you saw after leaving the crossings were in-bye? — In-bye over.
7,955. Then you went as far as the place where it is suggested by Mr. Edge that the explosion took place? — I went over the fall — over the top of it.
7,956. And I suppose that, passing that place, you found all the indications? — it is common ground — inbye? — That is so.
7,957. Now I will just take you back shortly to No. 3. First let me direct your attention to the staple bottom. Now, what condition was the staple bottom in? — All wrecked.
7,958. Now, proceeding from the staple bottom, what were the indications of force? — In what direction?
7,959. Proceeding from the staple bottom out-bye to the Maudlin, what were the indications? — I might say that if we start from Venner's shot, the indications that I saw were all to the staple bottom, the indications from Venner's shot by the old west way were all in-bye unto No. 3. This is common ground. Articles almost a ton weight were there — we all admit that.
7,960. Now, out-bye Venner's shot, what were the indications? — Now as to out-bye over from Venner's shot, I might mention a circumstance which perhaps has not been mentioned here. There are sheaves that the rope runs on, and there is a large circular plate keeps these sheaves on the rope out of the way for the rope to run around these sheaves. Now, one of these sheaves away from Venner's shot and this circular plate was doubled and bent to the staple, and on the other side it was doubled and bent in the direction of the Maudlin engine. There is an upright hanging. I perceived in the way from Venner's shot the sheaves were bent in the direction of Venner's bottom and out-bye — they were bent out-bye, so that the explosion seemed to have originated there, and the force had gone out-bye and in-bye up the old west way.
7,961. Summarising what you say, it comes to this, that to the west of Venner's shot they were bent inbye? — Yes.
7,962. And to the east of Venner's shot they were bent out-bye? — Yes.
7,963. And what other indications did you see going east of Venner's shot? — In examining the timber it seemed to be all blown out-bye.
7,964. You found the props blown out-bye? — All the timbers were blown out-bye. When we came to within a few yards of the Maudlin engine, where the coals go down from the Hutton seam down into the No. 3 pit, there were a lot of tubs standing, and all was confusion. The things were bent and sent in every direction that you could almost imagine.
7,965. (Mr. Wright.) Coming east from the Maudlin, crossing on the west way, in the direction of the Maudlin engine? — The tubs were blown in almost all directions.
7,966. (Mr. Jones.) Then going on from that point, what were the indications? — Well, down to the Maudlin engine all was confusion, down to the fall that I have mentioned.
7,967. Then going on beyond the Maudlin engine on to the curve all was quiet? — Apparently.
7,968. But travelling over that distance were there any indications at all that struck your attention one way or the other? — There were slight indications from Brown's shot that the force, if anything, had gone west.
7,969. It had gone in-bye? — Yes.
7,970. Now, coming to the other side of Brown's shot, what were the indications? — There was very little indication in the stone drift — none whatever that I saw.
7,971. None whatever? — Not in the drift.
7,972. Well, now, coming down to the curve towards No. 1, are there any other indications beyond those you have already specified to which you wish to draw attention? — I think not.
7,973. Now as to the indications of fire, just briefly summarising, what conclusions do you draw? — Well, the greatest indication of fire that I perceived was the separation door of the upcast 3 shaft. The baulks of timber were very much charred.
7,974. Perhaps you had better point that out on the plan? — (The Witness, pointing.) It is just over the Maudlin engine plane into what is called the dish, down to the upcast shaft. There is a fall of the baulk. There was a baulk on the edge of the fall very much charred, and there was an immense flame (pointing). Here is the separation door going into the No. 3 upcast shaft. The door is just nearly beneath.
7,975. At the separation door going into the No. 3 shaft you there find great indications of burning? — Yes, the most that I have seen of any in a mine.
7,976. What other indications did you see in No. 3? — Well, there were slight indications above the kibble bottom in the cabin.
7,977. Was that the burning timber? — I think that the cabin had got on fire, but I did not see much burnt of it. There were slight indications of burning when I went up.
7,978. Generally in No. 3 engine plane, did you see indications of fire? — Not generally, certainly not.
7,979. What other indications did you see? — I cannot remember particular indications of fire.
7,980. Now, coming down the curve towards No. 1 and 2 shafts, did you see any indications of fire there? — None whatever. I heard that Brown was found burnt.
But you did not see anything yourself.
7,981. (The Coroner.) That is the Brown where the shot was fired, not the other Brown? — Where the shot was fired, the refuge hole.
7,982. (Mr. Jones.) Now, down No. 1, did you see any indications of fire down No. 1 pit? — I don't remember seeing any indications of fire — not the slightest.
7,983. If there had been I assume that you would have observed them? — Certainly; I think so.
7,984. You were making a careful examination at the time? — I would not say extremely careful, but I looked at the general indications. I never thought there were two opinions as to which way it went.
7,983. Did you come to any conclusion as to the direction in reference to the Maudlin seam itself; that is to say, as to the indications down the travelling way and the engine plane? — I think the force of the explosion had gone down the travelling way.
7,986. (The Coroner.) And into the Maudlin? — Yes.
7,987. (Mr. Jones.) As to the engine plane, what did you see there? — It went down the curve.
7,988. It had gone down? — Yes.
7,989. Then it had gone, as far as you could judge the indications, both in-bye of the engine plane and in-bye of the travelling way of the Maudlin? — Yes.
7,990. Having thus gone over the pit, what conclusion have you come to as to the seat of the explosion? — Well, I suppose I will have an opinion as well as other people. My opinion is that both these shots were fired simultaneously, almost simultaneously, and both Venner's shot and Brown and Simpson's shot contributed to the explosion. They were both contributories of the explosion, judging from what I saw.
7,991. In what way — we want it in detail? — We will take Venner's shot; all the indications seem to me to show that that was the seat of the explosion in that direction. Things were blown out both out-bye and in-bye from that point. Now I am quite satisfied that there was any amount of dust; I don't say that there was not any gas; I don't say that it was a pure coal dust explosion there; but whatever it might be, gas or coal dust, or whatever it might be, I say that that shot contributed to explode that portion of the mine. Now I take the concurrent explosion, that is to say, the other contributory charge, Brown's shot — Brown and Simpson's — and we found the two Venners. The father and son are widely separated.
7,992. Do you mean on the other side of the shot? — Well, young Venner, I suppose, was found right out-bye, as if blown in that direction. Old Venner went in another direction, in-bye of the shot.
7,993. Would the men themselves leave their shot while being fired in that way? — Decidedly, that would be my own opinion.
7,994. (Mr. Wright.) Were they found in a refuge? — No, not there; young Venner was lying on the engine plane. Now we will go to Brown's shot. Now, in my opinion, Brown and Simpson had left their shot after igniting the catch. They had left their shot — Simpson was exactly in the place that a man would have been in under the circumstances, that is, the distance from the shot, about 40 yards from the shot. I did not measure it myself, but Mr. Turnbull measured it, and Simpson was nearly about the same distance, and he had gone into a refuge hole. Now I confirm in my opinion what Mr. Stratton said when he was asked the question whether this shot would not have been simultaneous with the explosion. I think that the shot and the explosion were together, because the men were knocked down exactly at the time that the shot had gone off, separated at the distance that the men would be when the men were firing the shot, because we must understand that this was a travelling road between the two pits, and the order was to warn everyone that a shot was going to be fired, and to keep them off until the shot exploded. These men were knocked down exactly at the spot that they would have been in under that order.
7,995. Then you believe the shots were fired as nearly as possible contemporaneously? — Yes.
(The Coroner.) He has fixed Venner's shot.
7,996. (Mr. A. Jones.) Just let me ask you; you inspected the place where Venner's shot had been fired? — I did.
7,997. What indications did that afford of having been cleared away? — There was some doubt as to whether Venner fired a shot or not, and I was requested to go back with Mr. Turnbull to examine the place more particularly. I did go back, and we found the indication of the shot at the top of the circle, where the hole had been drilled, I think 15 in. or 16 in., if my memory serves me right. The shot had been fired ; we saw immediately that that was the fact.
7,998. As to its being cleared away? — I said to the man that was with me, "Will you go into the stowboard and examine the stones in there?" He went in and said they were similar to those in the other place, and from my own examination I came to the conclusion that no stone had been lifted after Venner's shot had been fired.
7,999. That is a certain conclusion at which you arrived in your own mind? — Yes, there was no mark of any shovel being used or anything of the kind.
8,000. Nor did you see any stone removed away from it? — No.
8,001. Did you notice any indications as to whether the shot had been a completed shot — whether it had done its work? — It was a very good shot.
8,002. Now, passing to Brown's shot; was that shot also completed? — Yes.
8,003. Was that all cleared away? — No, I think not.
8,004. You examined it? — I am certain about it.
8,005. I think you have already stated that you found dust in considerable quantities in that neighbourhood? — From my examination of the pit there must have been a large quantity of coal dust before the explosion ; I might say I measured dust in the curve myself in the presence of the man with me, and it was from six to eight inches thick. A specimen of that dust was sent to Professor Abel — all along the curve, I do not say it was along the travelling road. On each side of the road the dust lay from six to eight inches thick. I examined the timbers; they were loaded with very fine dust, and my opinion was that before the explosion every projection in the stone drift, every piece of projection that would hold dust, was covered with it; and I have a further opinion that the dust that accumulated there would form, if you will allow me so to term it, a little avalanche; that is to say, when it became top-heavy it would fall on the floor of the mine and other dust would follow on there; and that had gone on for years.
8,006. (The Coroner.) There would be a very large deposit of dust? — Yes.
8,007. (Mr. A. Jones.) Was that dust in a very dry state? — Yes.
8,008. Do you know the temperature of the mine? — I believe 66; I am not certain.
8,009. (The Coroner.) Professor Abel says that coal dust alone he did not think would cause an explosion; where is your gas? — I have an idea that we can find the gas — not as gas. I had the honour to be with Professor Abel when these experiments were made, and I think I drew his attention to the apparatus, the square area of which was scarcely a foot. The square area of this gallery is more than 60 feet, and my opinion is that coal dust is inflammable, and it might fill that gallery with a steady flame. I think the large degree of heat of high intensity would develop very large masses of coal gas in sufficient quantity to explode the coal dust, and cause the explosion. I am of course under correction, but that is my opinion.
8,010. (The Coroner.) You say you think there could be a presence of 2½ per cent, of gas not detectable? — Developed from the coal dust by extensive heat.
8,011. (Mr. A. Jones.) You believe the fire of the coal dust might be ancillary to the explosion subsequently taking place? — It would develop as much gas as would be required to cause an explosion.
8,012. You have heard Mr. Lindsay Wood's evidence as to the back lash from the No. 1 and No. 2 shaft, did you notice what condition that shaft was in? — I never saw the shaft ; I never was down the shaft.
8,013. Did you notice at the bottom of the shaft as to its being choked? — There is no doubt there was considerable debris in it.
8,014. (The Coroner.) Considerable blocking, that is, allowed on all hands? — I could not say to what extent.
8,015. (Mr. A. Jones.) How do you account for the fact of these out-bye indications in No. 1? — At what part?
8,016. The hay and the bricks?
(The Coroner.) As to the burning of the hay, it is some time since it was thought that it did not indicate either one thing or the other; previous witnesses admitted that it could not be taken as any strong indication after an explosion of this terrific extent.
8,017. (Mr. A. Jones.) It is not the burning, it is the fact of the hay lying out-bye? — I say I think the explosion went in-bye.
8,017a. Assume that the explosion came from No. 1 shaft in-bye, the moment it struck this very crossing what is the consequence? — There was a tremendous pressure on the return; the force going in that direction would increase that pressure, and the whole pressure on the returns, together with the force of the explosion, would be made into a partial vacuum. The regulators at the stables would be under the same circumstances, and would be blown out. Instead of the air passing in it would come out, and necessarily all the light particles, such as bricks and hay, would be blown back into what they call a partial vacuum.
8,018. From the regulators at the stables and the crossing being broken you would account for the hay being brought back? — Yes, the pressure on the returns would be such as to induce a partial vacuum the moment the explosion passed.
8,019. We have heard with reference to these gullets in the Polka way? — I must candidly say that that theory is to my mind untenable, and I will give you two reasons. I examined this fall very minutely, and I am of opinion that it happened after the explosion took place, for this reason, it is well known to mining engineers that a fall cannot take place as long as the resistance of the timber is more than sufficient to support the strata. If it is not sufficient, it must smash the timber down and break it. My opinion is, the explosion passed before it took place and blew the timber out for this reason. I have pointed out that the baulks were blown out clear of the fall, and they were lying on the middle of the engine plane.
8,020. In-bye? — The timber was blown out, and after the timber was blown out they must have come away.
8,021. Were the baulks crushed at all? — Not the slightest, there was no bulge nor anything in it which showed to me that that fall had taken place after the explosion had passed.
8,022. There were no signs to your mind of the timber having been broken or injured by the fall? — Nor even strained, the timber was fully competent to do its work and to remain there for years.
8,023. (Mr. Wright.) The evidence you have given in that respect seems to me to be very valuable. I want to ask you, as a practical miner, are you prepared to say that there are no serious difficulties in the way of removing or watering the dust? — I am prepared to say it; I will give you the reason. I was down a pit lately, and the man was working at his place, but, though close to him, I could scarcely see him for coal dust ; I was almost choked myself.
8,024 (The Coroner.) That would be in a working place? — Not an intake or return.
8,025. (Mr. Wright.) I am talking about main intakes or returns. Do you think it a practical thing to call upon mine owners to keep the dust swept away or watered? — Yes.
8,026. Would it be an unfair thing to call upon colliery proprietors to deal with it in some way? — I think not. I think you had better have a thousand watering machines than let the dust accumulate in that way.
8,027. You are aware that there are some mines in which there are great practical difficulties in watering the floors — it makes them swell? — I do not think that extent of water would. There is no doubt on what we call Sagger floors it has that effect ; but I do not think the quantity used would be sufficient.
8,028. (Mr. Edge.) I also am much obliged to you for the way in which you have given your evidence. I only want to ask you one or two questions. As I understand you, you account for the position in which the two Venners were found, and Brown and Simpson, on the supposition that they were going right and left of their respective shots, in order to warn people that a shot was about to be fired? — They had left the shots.
8,029. Instead of going together to the refuge hole? — They are not allowed to go together.
8,030. They were to prevent people passing along? — Yes.
8,031. If that were so, can you account for the fact that Rawling's body was found in the stow-hole, immediately opposite Venner's shot? — I should have gone into the stow-hole with impunity, and allowed Venner to fire a shot for the very reason that there was no danger whatever.
8,032. Was not Rawling's body found within about 20 yards of Venner's shot in a direct line with the shot? — Not a direct line.
8,033. Almost a direct line? — Almost; but still it is not.
8,034. If you put a stick into where Venner's shot was, would not it point to the stow-hole? — I think not.
8,035. Your idea is that Brown's shot was simultaneous with the explosion? — I fancy so.
8,036. Do you know where Simpson's body was found? — Yes.
8,037. Can you account for Simpson being in that position unless he was blown from the opposite side of the drift? He was found on the north side of the drift; can you account for his being there? He would then have been within reach of the shot? — Decidedly not; he was 40 yards from the shot.
8,038. I understood you to say you suppose he had gone to a refuge hole? — I did not say he had gone to a refuge hole; there was no necessity. He could go 40 yards from a shot and not go into any hole. The shot goes in another direction.
8,039. Would you not expect him to be standing on the other side of the drift? — He might not; he might fancy he was as safe there as anywhere.
8,040. From the position in which he was found he could see the site of Brown's shot? — Certainly; he could see the blast; so could anybody on either side of it.
8,041. Did you notice the rapper rope in the neighbourhood of Brown's shot? — I did see the rapper rope.
8,042. Did you notice that the rapper rope was coiled up against the sheaves, and showing an indication of east to west? — I dare say it would, but I am not sure the indication was that way.
8,043. Did you also notice the bricks at the end of the Maudlin dock? Were they not blown from east to west? — Yes, it was all confusion.
8,044. But there were bricks blown from east to west? — Blown in all directions.
8,045. Some were blown outwards and some in-bye? — It was all confusion in every direction there.
8,046. Were some of the bricks blown in-bye? — Yes.
8,047. You told us about the debris of the tubs in the fire-hole. Does that represent the place (pointing to diagram)? — This is No. 1 pit, this is No. 1 engine-plane, and here is the way into the fire-hole (describing). I say that I suspected that the end of the tub was amongst the debris.
8,048. Does that fairly represent what I mean? — I really could not say.
8,049. I will take it this way. Is not the fire hole at right angles to No. 1 engine-plane? — I believe it is.
8,050. Were those tubs standing in the engine-plane or in the fire-dish? — I think they were in the dish.
8,051. If they were standing in the fire-hole dish they would be driven past the fire-hole, no matter whether the explosion came in-bye No. 1 or came out-bye No. 1? — They might.
8,052. They would afford no indication? — No.
8,053. Did you see, before you arrived at the takeoff from the travelling way No. 1, a block of coal that had been blown out? — I did not. I might, perhaps, take the opportunity of stating here that we certainly thought we should have compared notes with the other inspectors in order to satisfy ourselves and to afford assistance to unravel any difficulty; but I am sorry to say that the parties who explored exhibited no confidence whatever. I expressed my opinion freely to all the gentlemen about this, that, and the other; but we never heard anything from them until many weeks afterwards, when I was surprised to hear some theory had been started about this fall. The point seems to have been taken for granted, and agreed to perhaps.
8,054. I am sure you do not suggest that any information was withheld from you? — I suggest that we were not taken into the confidence of the party who were trying to find out how the explosion occurred.
8,055. But full opportunity was given you to make your own examinations? — I acknowledge that everything was granted that we wanted. There was nothing left; they gave no permission to go any where, and I believe they gave us rather too much liberty, because I strolled about the pit in every direction myself; they gave me every facility. I was at liberty to go where I liked and how I liked. I admit that handsomely; but certainly I think — it may be it is not for me to say — that we ought to have compared notes; but we did nothing of the kind.
8,056. On the top of the ridge of No. 1 engine plane on the in-bye side, did you notice hay and pieces of stick driven into the spaces between the bricks of the arch? — I did not.
8,057. Did you notice a return wheel at the end of the Maudlin dock? — I did not.
8,058. (Mr. A. Jones.) My friend, Mr. Wright, asked you whether you thought there might not exist practical difficulties in the way of watering or laying the coal-dust by moisture. Would there be any practical difficulty, do you think, in watering the coal-dust in the immediate proximity of a shot? — I think there is some strength in Mr. Wright's observation as to the nature of the floor of the mine, if the floor of the mine is affected by water.
8,059. That is not my question; I quite understand that; but is there any practical difficulty in the way of watering in the immediate proximity of a shot? — There is only a question of a little expense.
8,060. The expense of a watering pot? — That is the only difficulty that I can see.
(Mr. Jones.) I shall just put Mr. Patterson into the box for the purpose of asking him generally, whether, having heard Mr. Forman's evidence, he agrees with it.