Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Disaster Report Text
Disaster Report Name Index
UK Disaster Report Text
UK Disaster Report Name Index
Inquest Texts
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

Inquests Prev Page Return to Index Next Page Inquests
/   \

1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster

Inquest Report

Seaham Colliery Inquest, 21st October 1880.

The Londonderry Institute, Seaham Harbour, 21st October 1880.

Fifth Day.

Present:

Mr. CROFTON MAYNARD, Coroner.

Representatives of Home Office — Mr. R. S. WRIGHT, Barrister; Mr. THOMAS BELL, Mr. WILLIS, and Mr. ATKINSON, Government Inspectors.

Representatives of the Marquis of Londonderry — Mr. JOHN EDGE, Barrister, and Mr. H. B. WRIGHT, Solicitor.

Representatives of the National Miners' Association — Mr. ATHERLEY JONES, Barrister; Mr. BOWEY, and Mr. MARSHALL, Solicitors.

Mr. John Hutchinson called and sworn.

2,921. (The Coroner.) What are you? — A coal hewer.

2,922. Where are you living now? — Wheatley Hill.

2,923. Where were you? — I was in the 10 o'clock shift.

2,924. On what day? — On the 7th of September.

2,925. The shift going into the pit at 10 o'clock at night? — Yes.

2,926. In what mine? — In the Maudlin seam.

2,927. Tell us what you know? — Our lamps were looked at at the bit travelling-way — the shift that goes into the Maudlin.

2,928. Is that the usual place of examining the lamps for the Maudlin? — Yes.

2,929. What number of you went in together? — I cannot say the number, but I think there were nine of us.

2,930. Were all your lamps examined — the lamps of all the men with you? — Yes.

2,931. And locked? — Yes.

2,932. In going in did you find any difference in the air or ventilation? — No.

2,933. Did anything unusual attract your attention? — Nothing.

2,934. Was the pit any warmer than usual? — No, not that I felt.

2,935. What part of the Maudlin were you in? — The south flat.

2,936. South flat district? — Yes, up the incline.

2,937. Which incline? — The Maudlin incline.

2,938. During your shift, did anything out of the ordinary occur? — Quite at the top, the north part of the Maudlin.

2,939. Do you know whether it is the north part of the Maudlin? Is it south from the shaft, or north from the shaft — or where? — North.

2,940. (Mr. Wright.) By the long wall? — Yes.

2,941. (The Coroner.) In the long wall working? — Yes.

2,942. (Mr. Wright.) The long wall by the north goaf?

2,942a. (The Coroner.) Was there any goaf near you? — No.

2,943. Go on, and tell us what occurred during that shift? — I had been two shifts before, I was unwell, thinking that I could work it off. I was in with a man called Pat Carrol, No. 4 gateway, so I thought I would come out-bye.

2,944. When was that? — I could not say, because the deputy had left that flat.

2,945. How long were you in that shift? — It was about a quarter past two, I think.

2,946. Did you come out because you did not feel well enough to continue the shift? — Yes.

2,947. Were you affected any way by wanting air or anything? — No, nothing.

2,948. Your illness was not increased by the state the pit was in? — No.

2,949. Did you go back by the return or by the main in-take? — I came the same road out again.

2,950. By the main way? — By the main way.

2,951. What was the state of the ventilation, as far as you know, of the pit, both going in and coming out? — It was right enough, I think, as it had always been.

2,952. Was there anything to indicate that there was any risk or chance of an explosion taking place? — Nothing that I saw. I never felt any difference going in or coining out. There were two men working so far down; they were upon some scaffolding or something; coming out. Down the incline.

2,953. Whereabouts — what locality? — The main way.

2,954. Did you know them? — No; I have taken notice of them working there two or three shifts.

2,955. Can you fix that point — do you know it by any name? — I was not quite sure whether it was before I came to the arch or through the arch.

2,956. Which arch? — The big arch, beyond the meetings.

2,957. Do you mean the in-bye or the out-bye? — In-bye.

2,958. How far from the shaft? — It would be a good bit from the shaft. I do not know the distance; I had only been there about two months.

2,959. A mile, or half a mile, or a quarter? — It would be a mile or more.

2,960. Do you know what they were busy with? — No; I do not know what they were busy with. I did not take any notice of them. I just saw them there.

2,961. What lights had they? — Lamps — Clanny lamps.

2,962. In your road out did you take notice of any other men? — I came to that bit travelling-way again straight up the bank. There are two banks. When you come down the incline there is another bank rising to the stables.

2,963. Which bank is this you are speaking about? — The bank just going into the Maudlin, after you get through the travelling-way.

2,964. Did you see anyone there? — No; I took ill there — at the bank. When I got into the travelling-way I sat down there and I fell asleep.

2,965. What then? — I had only been there a minute or two, till Walter Murray was come through there.

2,966. What with? — Nothing — I do not know.

2,967. Did he wake you? — He tapped me with a stick ; I was half asleep.

2,968. What light had he? — One of them Davy lamps.

2,969. What is he? — A master shifter. He asked what was the matter with me. I told him ; so he said I had better make into the shaft to get ridden.

2,970. Did any further conversation pass between you? — Nothing.

2,971. Did you see any other men at any other points? — When I got to the shaft there was five, I think, altogether; I took them to be horse-keepers. They had just come down; it may he about 20 yards or so from the shaft.

2,971a. What lights had they? — They had big tin lamps.

2,972. Is that the stable lamp? — Yes. There were four of them at the Maudlin side of the shaft, and one at No. 1 side.

2,973. Are those all the men you saw in coming out-by? — Yes; there was the man at the shaft — Laverick.

2,974. Have you heard in the pit at any time of the returns being foul? — Never.

2,975. You never heard any of the men talk of the returns being foul in any way? — Nothing.

2,976. Have you ever found gas yourself in any place? — No, not during the time I have been in the pit.

2,977. Was there any general complaint amongst the men of gas? — No, no complaint.

2,978. (Mr. Wright.) Did you hear the explosion? — Yes.

2,979. You heard the sound of it did you — where were you? — I was in the cabin in the front of the shaft.

2,980. In the cabin? — Yes.

2,981. The front of which shaft? — The low pit shaft I had just ridden.

2,982. Is that the downcast shaft.? — There are two. There is a brattice that goes up.

2,983. Nos. 1 and 2 pit? — Yes.

2,984. What was the first thing you heard? — A report.

2,985. A loud one? — Very; it lifted us nearly off our feet.

2,986. Had you heard any sound just before that? — Nothing.

2,987. No rumbling? — No, just the shaft crack.

2,988. You heard only one noise? — Just one. There were two men in the cabin — banksmen. They clipped hold of the wood. The cage had gone away or something.

2,989. Had you heard a shot fired? — No, no shot.

2,990. (Mr. Wright.) Had you heard any shots at all that night? — Nothing; I never heard any shots.

2,991. At the same time that you heard the noise did a puff of wind come in? — Yes; there was wind that come in like a cloud after the report.

2,992. With smoke? — It was dark, you know, and the lamps were knocked out; we could not see, but we found the dust and stuff in the wind.

2,993. You felt the coal dust in the wind? — Yes.

(The Coroner.) He does not say coal dust.

2,994. (Mr. Wright.) Was it coal dust? — I think it was coal dust, because the flat sheets were covered with it.

2,995. Did you say the lamps were put out? — Yes, as soon as the crack came the lamps were put out.

2,996. The puff put them out, I suppose? — Yes.

2,997. Was it hot at all? — No, I never found any heat.

2,998. None of you were burnt? — No; none of us.

2,999. There was no after-damp? — No; no afterdamp.

3,000. After the shock and the noise, what was the next thing you noticed? — There was nothing more. The banksman went out to get a light. He thought, and I thought myself that the cage had gone and the ropes had broken. The crack was that sharp I thought the cage had gone away; he looked at the ropes to see if all was right, and crept away from the flat sheets.

3,000a. (The Coroner.) Did the wind reverse at all? — No, not that I could see.

3,001. (Mr. Wright.) After he went out what happened? — The brakesman, who was there, said the pit had fired.

3,002. What happened after that? — I stood about a bit on the heap to see if there were any people coming.

3,003. Afterwards? — There was the overman and the masterman came, and then I went home. They could not get the cage down.

3,004. Did you hear any report from No. 3 pit? — No.

3,005. No noise? — No, I just heard one report, just opposite where I was standing.

3,006. Did you see a man called Brown as you came out? — No.

3,007. Nor a man called Simpson? — I never saw no man, but just what I have mentioned; it might be one of them.

3,008. As you went into work that night, how far did you go along the main in-take in the Maudlin — did you go a mile along it? — When I went in to go to my work?

3,009. Yes? — More than that, I should think — a mile and a half.

3,010. You went straight on, and then turned to the left? — Yes; straight on and then turned to the left — to the flat.

3,011. So that you were working between the two long walls? — Yes.

3,012. That would be near the extreme north end of the in-take? Where was the scaffolding that you saw the men going to work at? — Coming down the incline.

3,013. Down the incline — was it near the old broken landing? — I do not know where that landing is.

3,014. Was it near the crossing where the return crosses the intake?

3,015. (The Coroner.) You may get it in this way: he says it was an archway above the in-bye meetings on the main way. Mr. Stratton can point it out upon the plan — where is the archway?

(Mr. Stratton.) There it is, where my finger is (pointing).

3,016. (The Coroner.) That is the most northerly inclined bank?

(Mr. Stratton.) Yes.

3,017. (Mr. Wright, to witness.) How far to the scaffold from the incline wheel? — Nothing near it.

(The Coroner.) He says it is a mile or more from the shaft.

3,018. How far was this archway from your face? — I could not say exactly.

3,019. We do not want the exact measurement — can you give us to 100 yards or 50 yards? — It maybe 200 yards.

3,020. (Mr. Wright.) You know the bottom of the incline? — Yes.

3,021. And you know the incline wheel — was it about half way between those two? — Yes; about half way.

3,022. In the meetings? — No; I think it is beyond the meetings.

3,023. Did you see what they were doing with the scaffold? — No; there was one shaft I was in. I did not notice what they were doing; there were two at the bottom of the scaffold.

3,024. You do not know what size place it was above the scaffold? — No; I never took notice.

3,025. (Mr. Jones.) You know that a shot had been fired in the Maudlin? — No.

3,026. Did you know of a shot being fired that night or that morning? — No; I never heard any shots.

3,027. You never heard any shot? — No.

3,028. Did you hear that there was a shot to be fired? — No.

3,029. How many hewers went down into the Maudlin seam — have you any idea?

(The Coroner.) He said he did know that nine men went with him, but he could not speak further.

3,030. (Mr. Jones.) You know that there were more hewers than the nine that were with you? — There would be no more than nine, I think, altogether.

3,031. In the Maudlin? — Up the incline.

3,032. In the Maudlin altogether — in the Maudlin seam that morning, how many hewers would there be? — I am sure I do not know; they were part down east — that is another way altogether from where I am working.

3,033. There were part of the hewers down east? — Yes.

3,034. And where were you working (I do not know that we have got that)? — Up the incline.

3,035. Where besides?

(Mr. Wright.) I have got it marked as closely as possible; there it is, by the long wall (pointing.)

3,036. (Mr. Jones.) Where are the stables — the Maudlin stables? — That is about the bottom, on the bottom of the bank.

(Mr. Wright.) Is it shown on the plan.

3,037. (The Coroner.) Near the entrance of the Maudlin seam? — It is down the first bank.

3,038. (Mr. Jones.) You know that there are stables in the east part? — I have never been down there.

3,039. Then the stables are close to the shaft — the Maudlin stables? — No, they are not close.

3,040. How far from the shaft are the stables — how far in-bye? — About 300 yards, I think, from the shaft.

3,041. How long after you met the men would it be, as far as you can remember, that you heard the explosion. You met the horsemen coming to the stables; you say that four were going to the Maudlin stables, and one to No. 1 Hutton? — Yes.

3,042. How long after you saw the men at the bottom of the shaft? — I could not say exactly, I was going into a cabin at the bottom of the shaft, and Laverick said I had better ride, because the cage was on the bottom, so he rapped for them until I got in.

3,043. You had got up to the top of the shaft, and you had gone into the cabin, I understand? — Yes.

3,044. You did not delay or dawdle between going up and going into the cabin? — No.

3,045. How long had you been in the cabin, do you think, before you heard the report? — I had no watch.

3,046. Two, or three, or five minutes? — Three or four minutes.

3,047. How long does it take you to go up the shaft? — It does not take long to go up the shaft.

3,048. How long to get to the bank? — I do not know.

3,049. (The Coroner.) Do you mean that the three or four minutes would cover going up the shaft? — No, that was when I got to the bank.

3,050. What do you mean — the three or four minutes that you spoke of — is that the time between your seeing these men and reaching the bottom of the shaft, or between the time of seeing the men and getting to the top of the shaft? — Between seeing the men and getting to the bottom of the shaft.

3,050a. Then you would be three or four minutes in the cabin? — The brakesman had a watch, and he said I was three minutes.

3,051. That would make seven minutes altogether from the time you saw the men? — That is it.

3,052. You are quite sure that one of the horse-keepers was going into No. 1 Hutton? — Yes, I saw the man going; I do not know his name — I think it would be Panton; he was working in the shaft — yon side of the shaft.

3,053. Do you know whether Panton was got out alive? — No, he was not got out alive, he was dead, he had just got to his stables, I heard.

3,054. Which stables was Panton going to?

(Mr. Jones.) No. 1 Hutton.

3,055. Do you know — were you sure that the other horse-keepers were going to the Maudlin stables? — I was not sure they were all going there.

3,056. Might any of them be going to No. 3 Hutton? — I do not think they were those men.

3,057. The stables of No. 3 Hutton — do you know where they are? — No.

(Mr. Jones.) They are marked, close to the shaft.

(Mr. Bell.) No. 3, stables are on the other side of the shaft, on the No. 1 side.

3,058. (Mr. Jones.) How long have you been working in the pit? — I have been working in the pit about seven years.

3,059. Had you ever come across gas yourself during the seven years you were in the pit? — No, never.

3,060. You have never seen it yourself at all? — I have never seen it myself.

3,061. Have you been all the seven years working in the Maudlin? — No; I have been only about two months in the Maudlin.

3,062. How long have you been working in the Seaham pit altogether? — Two months.

3,063. And during the whole of that time you have been in the Maudlin? — Yes.

3,064. During that two months did you ever come across any gas? — No.

3,065. You had heard of men coming across gas in the Maudlin? — No, I never heard of any.

3,066. You never heard gas mentioned? — No, not there.

3,067. Not in the Maudlin or that part? — Not in the pit at all.

3,068. Not in the Maudlin seam at all? — No.

3,069. Not that you know of? — No.

3,070. You stated that you did not notice any difference in the ventilation — did you notice whether the ventilation was a little slower in the air-ways that night? — No, I did not think anything was amiss that night.

3,071. Do you think the air was travelling as fast down the main in-take? — Yes.

3,072. You think it was? — Yes.

3,073. Was there much dust blowing? — No, there was none.

3,074. None blowing as you went in? — No.

3,075. Had you ever seen dust blowing down the main in-take? — No, I have never seen any dust.

3,076. I mean coal dust by the air passing through down the main in-take? — No, I have never seen any dust blowing without you put your feet down and disturb it.

3,077. If you put your foot down you would disturb it? — You might disturb it.

3,078. How thick would the dust lie? — I cannot say exactly.

3,079. Of course it would differ, I suppose, in places — it would be thicker near the shaft than further in-bye? — I never found any dust just through the travelling way; it comes up the bank away from the Maudlin stables in the travelling way going there.

3,080. You say you find it there? — I have found a little just there with my foot when I have been walking.

3,080a. On the travelling way? — Yes, upon the travelling way that goes through there.

3,081. Would it be an inch thick, or two inches, or. more? — It would not be an inch thick — just slight.

3,082. Would you see it on the timbers? How deep would it be on the timbers — on the baulks? — I have never taken any notice of the baulks.

3,083. But you have seen the dust there, I suppose — coal dust lying there? — Yes, slight.

3,084. I suppose you have been in the travelling way when the tubs have been coming down, have you not? — I have been entering the travelling way when the tubs have been down there.

3,085. As they have been travelling down have you seen the dust flying much? — No.

3,086. You never noticed it much? — No, I never noticed.

3,087. You say that those horse keepers were carrying not the safety lamp, but an open lamp? — I think it was them tin lamps.

3,088. (Mr. Edge.) As I understand, the only dust you noticed was at one place where you put your foot — you noticed it under your feet? — Yes.

(Mr. Jones.) In the travelling way.

(Mr. Edge.) That was only a slight amount of dust.

(The Coroner.) He says, "I never found any except on the travelling way near the Maudlin stables ; it was not an inch thick — just slight. I never noticed the baulks and the timber to see if there were any."

3,089. (Mr. Edge.) How long have you been working at this other pit that you are at now? — I was going with the old shift when the police came.

3,090. It does not belong to the Seaham Colliery? — No.

(The Coroner.) It belongs to the Old Hartlepool Company.

(Mr. Edge.) A different company altogether.

The witness withdrew.

 

Prev Page Return to Top of Page Next Page

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print