1880 Seaham Colliery Disaster
Inquest Report
Seaham Colliery Inquest, 15th September 1880 (cont.).
Mr. George Thompson sworn and examined.
370. (The Coroner.) What are you? — A stoneman.
371. Can you tell us where this explosion took place? — As nigh as I could tell from going up from the pit, about ten minutes past two o'clock.
372. Where did the explosion take place — the locality? — I could not tell where, because we did not hear the shock.
373. Where were you working? — In the skirting way right back over.
374. In the seam? — In the main coal seam.
375. That is somewhere near where Marley was — was not it? — Yes.
376. Was there any fault to find with the air or the ventilation up to that time during that shift? — No the ventilation there was just as usual, and good. There was a good supply of air.
377. Now then, was there one or two explosions? — Well, we never heard an explosion at all where me and my mates were.
378. Did you not find the wind altering? — The way we got to know, there was a boy came in, and he said, "You had better make way to the flats; there's something the matter," and we were 100 yards from the flats.
379. You knew nothing till a boy told you something had happened? — No; and when we came out to the flat we smelt the after-damp, as it was supposed to be.
380. Had you been shot-firing that night? — Not that night.
381. What is your practice, so far as shot-firing is concerned? — With me and my mates, I take charge of firing shots; and in taking stone down I fire the shots in that case.
382. Have you any communication with anybody, or do you do it on your own responsibility? — For instance, if a place wants blasting we have to communicate with the master shifter — that's our master, Anthony Smith.
383. That is, before firing, you have to have communication with the master shifter? — Yes. When he gives the order to fire shots, I then go so far in-bye and so far out anywhere where I see any signs of gas lodging, and I examine the place.
384. How far in and out? — About 50 yards in and out, and above that if I think fit.
385. Does the master shifter make an examination himself? — No ; the man who has charge of the shift, he is on the right to examine the place — he is got charge.
386. (Mr. Bell.) Have you a certificate to fire a shot? — Yes.
387. Is it a written or printed one? — It is a printed one.
388. Do I understand you to say that you do not fire shots unless you are authorised by the master shifter? — Not unless authorised by the master shifter and if he gives the command to fire the shots we have then rules to go by, and there are only certain persons to fire.
389. What time in the morning did this happen? — As nigh as I could guess the way we found the stuff it was 20 minutes past two o'clock.
390. Had you a watch? — Yes; I looked at it.
391. What time was it that you got word? — About 25 minutes to 3 o'clock, and all the men were on the main way then.
392. (Mr. Bowey.) You have a licence for shot firing? — Yes.
393. Let me understand — you say that before you fire shots you have got to have a communication with the master shifter? — Yes.
394. Well, then, when you get leave from him to fire shots, after that you go and examine the place? — Yes; just before we fire the shots.
395. When you have got the leave from the master shifter you have not seen the place? — Yes; we have seen the place before that.
396. And you examine them after? — Yes; to examine them before any thing has come since that time.
397. But who examines the place — you? — The man who has charge.
398. You have got charge — do you examine the place? — No.
399. Does the man from whom you get the leave examine them — he does not examine them? — Yes.
400. Supposing you want to fire shots, what do you do? — Supposing I want to get a refuge hole he will come in the night before and mention the names.
401. Who will come in? — The master shifter ; and he will say, may be, "Thompson, we are going to put a refuge hole out, and you can start the next shift;" and he has seen the place and he has examined it, and he tells us to go on next night, and we commence to drill holes, and then fire.
402. Without any further communications? — Without any further communication.
403. There is a whole day between the giving of the order and the making of the holes? — Yes; a day betwixt his command and our going to the place.
404. What knowledge have you particularly of whether there is gas in the place? — I know gas when I see it.
405. There may be an interval of 20 hours and you do not get any further orders from the master shifter to fire? — No; we will say that he gives the order on the Tuesday night and we fire on the Wednesday, and betwixt that time we get no further orders.
406. And you examine the place? — Yes; we examine the place within and without before we do fire.
407. And it might so be that it might be 48 hours afterwards in some places, or even three days? — No.
408. Supposing you get orders from the Tuesday night you might fire on the Friday night? — No; they would stop us before that.
409. How far would they let your go? — Perhaps a day or two. If it is beyond a day there will be something else.
410. What is that? — If it goes beyond the day there is something the matter then.
411. That is, assuming you have not made the holes within the day? — Yes.
412. (The Coroner.) You say 24 and 48 hours between getting leave and firing the shot, but not three days? — No, not three days.
413. (Mr. Bowey.) Never three days? — Never beyond one shift in my case.
414. Then when you once get one order to fire shots in a certain place who stops you? — The master shifter will stop us if there is anything the matter.
415. Then you will go on until you are stopped? — Yes; we finish the job.
416. Well, now, when you have got commenced firing shots, how long may you sometimes go on before getting another order? — If we once get command, if the job is a long one, we continue.
417. And the job may continue for two or three days? — It may continue for two or three months.
418. And the orders that you get, are they always verbal word of mouth? — Yes; all but the rules of firing shots.
419. What rules are there? — The guides that we go by.
420. Have you got one of these? — Yes.
421. Have you got it with you? — I have not it with me.
422. You have not it with you, where do you keep it? — I keep it out of the road at home — I take care of it.
423. What do you take care of it at home for? — Because it is a rule that we have got to keep it out of the way. When it is done we will have to give it in.
424. When did you read it last? — A week or two since.
425. Why then? — Just to keep it in remembrance.
426. Had you forgotten something? — No; but it behoves every man to read the rules.
427. Do you look at it every fortnight? — No; just when it comes across my hands.
(Mr. Bowey.) I would like to read those rules.
(The Coroner.) Upon that subject I may say that I am allowing you to examine that witness in the absence of Mr. Stratton; and I was just wondering myself whether he ought not to have been present in that portion of the examination.
(Mr. Bowey.) I did not know whether Mr. Stratton was here. I have not the pleasure of knowing him.
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) It would be more convenient to defer the cross-examination until Mr. Stratton is present.
(Mr. Bowey.) That is the disadvantage of having the witness now.
(The Coroner.) We cannot help it.
428. Did you ever fire any shots without the master shifter first making the examination? — No; I do not think I ever did. I never fired a shot without his sanction, as far as I know.
429. (Mr. H. B. Wright.) Did the master shifter visit you every night when you were at work? — Close upon every night. Some nights he might be occupied in another seam.
430. But he goes all round his work every night — the master shifter? — Yes; our master shifter has got two seams — the main seam and the Hutton seam.
431. And he is engaged every night between these seams? — Yes.
432. You say you go 50 yards each way to look for gas before firing the shot. Is that after you have drilled the hole? — After we have drilled the holes, we put the powder in, and then we make examination to see if there is any gas; and if there is any gas I don't light her.
433. Didn't you see the master shifter every night? — Yes; before we go in-bye.
434. And he is engaged every night between the two seams? — Yes.
435. (Mr. Bowey.) But you did not see him this night? — Yes.
436. Before you went in? — Yes.
437. (Mr. H. B. Wright.) You were firing no shots that night? — No.
(Mr. Bowey.) I want the practice merely?
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) This witness can be recalled if necessary.
(The Coroner.) Are there any further witnesses of this class that you wish to call, say from any one of the three seams, that have been got out alive?
(Mr. Bowey.) No.
(Mr. Marshall.) We cannot call any from the Maudlin.
(The Coroner.) Are there any other witnesses that have been got out alive that you wish to be called?
(Mr. Bowey.) We are in a difficult position. At present, we do not know where we are not having these plans.
(The Coroner.) I wanted the evidence of these men when it was fresh in their minds, and it seems to me that we have got this far, that we confine the explosion as far as we have got to the Hutton seam and the Maudlin seams. That is as far as we have got our evidence this morning, and it is confined to one explosion.
(Mr. Atkinson.) There is a slight evidence of two explosions, if you could get the evidence of some one working further out.
(The Coroner.) You mean working further out than this present witness?
(Mr. Atkinson.) Yes; some one not working so far in-bye as the 1,200 yards.
(The Coroner.) Is there such a man?
438. (Mr. Bell.) Was any one working further in-bye (addressing Mr. Robert Wardle, recalled)? — No one but Marley; and Marley was the furthest man from the shaft.
439. Who was the furthest out-bye man that night? The man nearest the shaft working by the man Gill that night? — I cannot say. Hartley was the nighest to; he went down the staple.
440. But in the seam, I mean — had you any men working in the flat? — There were four men working in the flat, Marley and Smith.
441. They were all towards the flat; there were none between the flat and the shaft? — None but the drivers — the boys. Robert Strawbridge was 50 yards away from me.
442. What was he — a driver? — Yes; a driver.
(Mr. Bell.) It is not material to clear it up now.
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) I do not see that we can proceed any further to-day.
(The Coroner.) Are there any men here that got out alive that wish to tender themselves as witnesses, that think they know something about the explosion? If there is anyone who wishes to be examined he has nought to do but say so, and I am prepared to examine him. Is there any one of you that came out of the pit alive that can say whether there was one or two explosions?
There being no response to this appeal, after a pause,
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) It would be convenient if we are to understand this before we separate to-day, that no further evidence is required for the Government inspectors as to those two seams — this lower seam, the Harvey seam, or the main coal seam — because you said it would be necessary to produce plans at the next sitting of the inquest; and my desire is that we should know what plans it is desirable to have produced. If we had the plans shewing the workings of the two seams to which the inquiry should be directed — the Maudlin and the Hutton seam — that would be sufficient.
(The Coroner.) And the connection with the other seams which we say is safe.
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) But the seams to which attention is directed are the Harvey and the main coal seam — the low seam and the high seam.
(Mr. Willis.) Out of which all the men are saved?
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) Yes.
(Mr. Willis.) And we should like to get a fact from these saved men as to whether there were two explosions distinctly felt by any of them, or really only one felt by the 67 men rescued.
(The Coroner.) I take it that Mr. Wright is asking us what plans will be necessary for our purpose at the next adjournment — that is what you want?
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) Quite so.
(Mr. Bell.) You can put the whole of the Hutton seam workings on one plan. At present they are divided into three.
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) The Harvey No. 1; No. 3 Hutton seam; and No. 2 Hutton seam is the Harvey seam.
(Mr. Bell.) Then they are all one seam, and the workings can be reduced on one sheet.
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) It could be.
(Mr. Marshall.) I think you had better have them all on one.
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) I will produce any plans that may be required by Mr. Bell or the Government inspectors; but the productions of a lot of plans will only tend to confusion.
(The Coroner.) So far as I am concerned, what I think would satisfy us would be the two localities where the explosion seems to have taken place, with the connecting links as to the places that we have been examining about to-day.
(Mr. Bowey.) When we have got that we have got the plan of the whole mine.
(The Coroner.) If you take Mr. Willis and Mr. Bell's views on the subject I think we will get what plans we want. It would be better to leave it to them.
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) It was, first, that there should be no misunderstanding that I mentioned what I thought would be wanted at the next inquiries, and that you should have such plans as may assist the inquiry. What I suggested was, and Mr. Bell concurred, that there should be one plan showing the Hutton seam of No. 3 and the Hutton seam of No. 1, in which the explosion occurred; and also, on the same plan, that there should be the Maudlin seam — the explosion occurring in the Maudlin and Hutton. If you had the plans of these seams in which the explosion occurred it will tend to assist the inquiry. On that plan the connecting link would be placed, and we could produce the main coal and the Harvey seam if you require it. But if I produce half a dozen.
(Mr. Bowey.) Why not show one plan of the whole?
(Mr. Bell.) It would be enormous to give all; but if you reduce the connections through the shaft and No. 1, then you could have the detailed plans to refer to beyond this line.
(Mr. Willis.) I do not see, Mr. Wright, why you should not get up what plans are necessary, and not take it from this Court.
(Mr. Bowey.) I quite agree with that.
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) If yourself and Mr. Bell will agree upon the plans, I can undertake that your suggestions will be immediately acted upon.
(Mr. Bowey.) And Mr. Wright, you will supply us with a tracing?
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) I have no objection at all.
(The Coroner.) Will you agree when to adjourn to? I have nothing to guide me as to when we will start again. I have made my mind that at any future sitting I shall go on from day to day with the exception of Fridays and Saturdays, those days being, in my opinion, the most valuable time to the members of the jury, and therefore I will not proceed on either Friday or Saturday; but every other part of the week I shall sit.
(Mr. Marshall.) But it will take a length of time to go through the workings.
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) But you say you will examine hewers first and deputies afterwards.
(The Coroner.) We will as far as we can.
(Mr. Bowey.) We have broken through that already.
(The Coroner.) We cannot have a fast line.
(Mr. Willis.) We might have this little point cleared from those 67 saved men. You have asked them publicly to come forward; but could we not have it from some one working nearer the shaft, because it is really an important point as to whether there is one or two explosions.
(The Coroner.) There is only the boy that you can have at the next sitting.
(Mr. Willis.) The only difficulty is that they might get away.
(Mr. Bowey.) You might call some of them by name.
(Mr. H. B. Wright.) I am afraid that Laverick could give no evidence on that; he would be reduced to insensibility.
The witness withdrew.