Houghton. Robert Robson, 58, stoneman.
Received injuries to his back, left knee and right foot by fall of stone on 24th January, 1924. He was released from the fall by two work men and the accident was reported to the deputy but it was disputed that any report of the accident was received. The claim was also resisted on the grounds that Dr. Todd had reported that Robson was disabled in consequence of rheumatism and not by injury. Robson was off work until the 12th May, and claims compensation up till that date.
Dr. Boyd certified that Robson was suffering from injury to back, knee and foot and Dr. Ritson of Sunderland also reported on the 29th February, 1924, as follows :—
"He complains now of pain at the inner side of the left knee more marked on twisting the joint. I am of opinion that he has sustained injury to his internal semiluna cartilage of this knee and he complains of soreness to right foot. Examination shows him to have had fractures of the second, third and fourth metatarsals and this is confirmed by X-rays. He has also a bony spur growing from the inner side of the first metatarsals but this was no cause of the accident. Movements of the back are stiff and the muscles, especially on the left side, are somewhat tender. I am of opinion that he is not fit for work on account of the effects of the injury especially to the right foot."
Claim disallowed.
Source: Documents at the Durham Miners' Association, Redhills, Durham