|
Non-fatal AccidentHales Richardson
Durham Miners' Association
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Arbitration Committee — 7th April 1924 | |
Report of Proceedings
of
Arbitration Committee Meeting
held in the
The Coal Trade Offices, Newcastle-on-Tyne
On 7th April 1924
Pelton Fell. Hales Richardson, 45, hewer.
On 20th April, 1910, Richardson was lifting a large piece of hand when it broke in two, and he fell back over and sprained himself and set up an anuerism. He went to work the following day but had to give up at once and went home and has not worked since. He was paid full compensation until 27th January, 1924, when he received notice that payment would cease on a report of Dr. Hume, who reported on 28th December, 1923, and 14th January, 1924 :—
"I was unable to detect any enlargement or other abnormality in the heart and his blood pressure is 140. I was unable to detect any evidence of anuerism. As far as my examination went it was completely negative, but it is necessary to have an X-ray picture of the chest"
After seeing the X-ray picture Dr. Hume reported :—
"The X-ray examination bears out my opinion that this man has no anuerism at all. The history of the original accident sounds much more like a strain of muscles in the chest wall and was not the sort of accident that would be liable to cause heart disease or aneurism. Neither heart disease nor aneurism is caused by sudden exertion. I consider that the effects of the accident of 21st April, 1910, have, for long, passed away."
Dr. Donald McKenzie, on behalf of Richardson, reported on 23rd January, 1924, as follows :—
HISTORY OF CASE. Says on 21st April, 1910, he was lifting a piece of stone band. The band broke and he fell backwards. He felt a click at the heart. He was sent to Royal Victoria Infirmary, Newcastle, and X-rayed and understood found to be suffering from an aneurism (thoracic). He has suffered from pain and shortness of breath at intervals since the date of his accident.
PRESENT CONDITION. He says he has faint attacks on an average twice a week. He suffers from pain, sometimes being severe shortness of breath. A systolic murmur of right nipple is heard a distance of three inches to the left of the right nipple and three inches below right nipple.
GROUNDS OF OPINION. I am of opinion the man is suffering from Thoracic Aneurism (Aorta). That the aneurism was due to his accident and that he is unable to carry on his employment.
The case has been before Dr. Plummer, who reported :—
"In my opinion there is a distinct evidence that Hales Richardson is permanently disabled from work as a hewer and that such disability is due to the strain he sustained on April 20th, 1910, when lifting a hand or piece of stone. He has, in my opinion, an Aneurism of the Aorta."
The case was before the Committee on 20th February, 1924, and referred to Dr. Drummond for report.
Dr. Drummond reported on 20th March :—
"On March 20th, the above man was sent to me for an opinion upon his case, and Messrs. Cook, Foster and Robinson attended and submitted medical reports.
Richardson met with an accident in April, 1910, when he sustained a strain, referable to his heart, when lifting a stone.
I examined him carefully and came to the conclusion that he is not the subject of Anuerism, and is not now suffering from the effects of the accident."
Claim disallowed.
Source: Documents at the Durham Miners' Association, Redhills, Durham
| Sources | |
| Researchers | |
If you are researching Hales Richardson (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||