County Court Cases.
West Auckland. George Hathaway, 55, hewer.
Contracted Miners’ Nystagmus on 1st August, 1915. He commenced light work as a shifter on 28th August, 1916, and continued for 2 months, when he had to give up. Full compensation was resumed, and this was continued until 2nd June, 1923, when it was stopped on a report by Dr. Wardale. The case was referred to the Official Medical Referee (Dr. Percival) who reported on 22nd June, 1923, as follows :—
1. "The said G. Hathaway is now suffering from arterio-sclerosis, which would itself account for his tremors and dizziness. He shows no Nystagmus to-day, but I cannot say that a previous Nystagmus has not aggravated his tremors, etc., and his condition is such that he is now unfit to do any work that involves stooping. Possibly he might be able to do some work in the lamp cabin.
2. The incapacity of the said G. Hathaway is not complete, and it is not entirely due to Miners’ Nystagmus."
Compensation was paid at the rate of 5/- per week, and Hathaway claimed the full rate with War addition.
This case was considered by our side on 14th August, 1923, when it was decided to have Hathaway examined by Dr. Cunningham, and if the report from Dr. Cunningham was favourable the case be taken to Court.
Dr. Cunningham examined Hathaway on 18th August, and reported as follows :—
"EXAMINATION — When Hathaway is examined in a stooping position and in a darkened room definite signs of Miners’ Nystagmus can be seen.
From the result of my examination I am of opinion that Hathaway is incapacitated from performing any kind of work underground ; he is, however, fit to perform most kinds of light work at bank in daylight where there is not too much stooping."
The Committee failed to agree on 29th August, 1923.
Judge McCarthy tried the case at Middlesbro’ County Court on 22nd October, 1923, and gave an award for 5/- per week.
Source: Documents at the Durham Miners' Association, Redhills, Durham