|
Non-fatal AccidentJonathan Davison
Durham Miners' Association
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Arbitration Committee — 20th February 1924 | |
Report of Proceedings
of
Arbitration Committee Meeting
held in the
The Coal Trade Offices, Newcastle-on-Tyne
On 6th and 20th February 1924
Report of Meeting held 20th February, 1924
County Court Cases.
East Hetton. Jonathan Davison, 63, wasteman.
In September, 1913, Davison had his right ankle and knee injured by a fall of stone. He was paid full compensation until 7th September, 1923, when payment was reduced to 5/- per week on a report by Dr. Morison, who reported that the inability to work was chiefly due to old age (74).
The case was before the Committee on 23rd November, 1923, and the Committee failed to agree. Our side on 3rd December, 1923, decided to take the case to the County Court, and it was tried at Durham, before Judge Moore, on 4th February, 1924.
The medical evidence was given by Dr. Morison, of Sunderland, on behalf of the Owners, and Dr. Clay, of Newcastle, represented our Association.
Dr. Clay stated he examined Davison on 31st January, 1924. He found he was suffering to a serious degree from osteo-arthritis in the right knee joint and pain in ankle joint, but the chief inability was due to knee injury. There was practically no osteo-arthritis in the left (uninjured knee) and he did not think there was any work Davison could do so far as the accident was concerned, except sedentary work and such work should be very near his home. The condition he found was permanent, and, apart from the accident, Davison would have been able to work as a wasteman at present.
Dr. Charlesworth, who was Barrister for the Owners, cross-examined Dr. Clay, who admitted there was good union of the bones in ankle, but there would be great difficulty in balancing himself on uneven surface.
Re-examined by Mr. Heath Dr. Clay said he had never seen a case where osteo-arthritis seriously affected one knee and not the other without injury.
Dr. A. E. Morison said he examined Davison on 7th September, 1923, and 29th January, 1924. There was a fracture of both bones above the ankle, some limitation of movement, but there was good union and bones were soundly healed. His right knee was slightly worse than left but both conditions were rheumatic. He was not aware the knee had been injured.
Cross-examined by Mr. Heath, he said he did not agree with Dr. Clay there was a marked difference between the knees. If the knee was injured he would agree with Dr. Clay there would be a difference between the two knees, but he had never been told the knee had been twisted.
Judge Moore was of opinion that had it not been for the accident Davison would have been able to work as a wasteman, and therefore there would be an award for full compensation, with War addition, as from 7th September, 1923.
Source: Documents at the Durham Miners' Association, Redhills, Durham
| Sources | |
| Researchers | |
If you are researching Jonathan Davison (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||