|
Non-fatal AccidentThomas Armstrong
Durham Miners' Association
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Arbitration Committee — 20th February 1924 | |
Report of Proceedings
of
Arbitration Committee Meeting
held in the
The Coal Trade Offices, Newcastle-on-Tyne
On 6th and 20th February 1924
Report of Meeting held 20th February, 1924
County Court Cases.
Blackhall. Thomas Armstrong, 39, coal cutter.
Armstrong had his spine fractured by a fall of stone on 8th May, 1918. Full compensation was paid up till 16th April, 1923, when Armstrong was certified fit for light work. The reference was drawn up for the case to be referred to the Official Medical Referee but Armstrong refused to allow his case to be referred, and our side on 5th June, 1923, decided that the case be taken to the Committee. Dr. Falconer reported on 23rd April, 1923, that Armstrong was unfit for light employment. Armstrong also produced a report and X-ray plates from Dr. Waters, of Sunderland.
The case was before the Committee on 1st August, 1923, and adjourned as Armstrong was unable to attend.
The Committee failed to agree on 7th November, 1923.
Our side of the Committee discussed the case on the 21st November, 1923, and decided to meet the doctor and if the evidence was strong enough to warrant the case being tested at court, it be taken there. It was tried at West Hartlepool County Court on 1st February, 1924.
In addition to Dr. Thom the local doctor, our side deemed it advisable to call in expert evidence, and Dr. Waters, of Sunderland, was engaged.
Dr. Thom stated that Armstrong was suffering from Neurasthenia, and that the accident as described could produce all of what Armstrong complained of. His gait was spactic, and in his opinion, the nerves of the back had been injured.
Cross-examined by the owners’ barrister (Dr. Charlesworth) Dr. Thom admitted he did not see Armstrong for years after the accident and had not treated him.
Dr. Waters said he examined Armstrong on the 14th May, 1923, and 31st January, 1924. His present condition showed no change from that in May, 1923. Armstrong was very unsteady on his legs and there was pain opposite the fourth and fifth lumbar vertebrae. There were signs which suggested nerve injury and his condition was chiefly neurasthenic set up by the accident. His gait could not be simulated.
In answer to the Judge Dr. Waters stated there was no sign of bone injury and X-ray examination did not show any, but the force used probably injured his kidney. He was not fit for work at present but light work that he could manage would benefit Armstrong.
Cross examined at great length by Dr. Charlesworth, Dr. Waters stated there was no bone injury and could not say there was any dislocation of the spine. The condition was largely one of traumatic neurasthenia. There were definite signs of painful action of spinal muscles which would influence his gait and in his opinion the accident accounted for the pain.
Dr. Hare (for the owners) stated he first saw Armstrong on 16th August, 1919, and declared him unfit for any work and advised him to discard a spinal jacket he was wearing. He examined him seven times afterwards, the last time on 8th August, 1922, when he was of opinion that Armstrong was fit for light work and would be better for it.
Cross-examined by Mr. Heath, Dr. Hare admitted there was not a great deal of difference between his opinion and that of Dr. Waters.
Without calling upon the other doctors for the owners (Drs. Willan and Stuart) the Judge was of opinion that light work was the best possible thing for Armstrong in his condition, and awarded him full compensation up to 1st February, 1924, and afterwards at light work rate, Armstrong to commence light work on 11th February, 1924.
Source: Documents at the Durham Miners' Association, Redhills, Durham
| Sources | |
| Researchers | |
If you are researching Thomas Armstrong (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 30 Apr 2023
|
Search |
|
|||