Harton. James Hagan, hewer.
On 12th January, 1923, this man fell off with Miners' Nystagmus. Full compensation was paid until 6th May, 1925, when it was reduced to 5/6 per week on a report of Dr. Wardale (the Owners' doctor) who reported on 18th April, 1925, as follows :—
"There were traces of Miners' Nystagmus but they were very slight.
When he was stooping in the dark room and with his eyes turned up and to one side there were slight jerking movements of the eyes which ceased directly he turned his eyes from that position, even if he looked at a light.
This man is able to do a good deal of work on bank."
Dr Cunningham (the man's own doctor) on 27th April, 1925, reported as follows :—
"Examination — Hagan is suffering from Miners' Nystagmus. The oscillation of the eyeballs and twitching of the lids can be observed when he is in a stooping position. They are also more marked when he is examined in a darkened room and his eyes are turned into extreme positions. There is undoubted giddiness while stooping, but this giddiness disappears when he stands erect.
From the result of my examination I am of opinion that Hagan is incapacitated from performing any kind of work underground. He is also incapacitated from performing the work of a labourer at bank. He is only fit to perform very suitable light work in daylight where there is little or no stooping, as stooping would only aggravate the Nystagmus."
The case was referred to the Official Medical Referee (Dr. Percival) who reported on 29th May, 1925, as follows :—
1. "The said J. Hagan is to-day showing signs of Miners' Nystagmus, and his condition is such that he is unable to do any work that involves much stooping.
2. The incapacity of the said James Hagan is partial and is entirely due to Miners' Nystagmus."
The case was before the Arbitration Committee on 22nd June, 1925, when he was awarded compensation at the reduced rate of 15/- per week. Hagan then commenced light work and continued at such until 30th April, 1926, when he received his notice on account of the National Stoppage. Hagan contends that he should have been allowed to continue at the light work seeing it is regarded as safety work. He now claims full compensation.
Awarded compensation at the reduced rate of 10/- per week.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/6, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol VI covering Jan-Dec 1926