Ravensworth. John G. Rutter, 36, labourer.
On 10th May, 1919, this man was caught by the set and sustained a compound fracture of the left leg. Full compensation was paid for 7 months when he commenced light work, greasing rollers above ground, and he continued at such until the National stoppage in March, 1921. He has not worked since, and full compensation was paid until 6th February, 1926, when it was reduced to 10/- per week on a report of Dr. Martin (the Owners' doctor) who reported on 21st January, 1926, as follows :—
"His present condition is as follows :—
He is a healthy looking man who walks with a pronounced limp.
Left Leg. — There has been a fracture about the situation of the middle and lower third of the tibia. There is now firm union but with marked visible angular deformity, the direction of the angle being forwards and inwards. As a consequence of the inward displacement of the upper end of the lower fragment the foot is in a valgus position. There is shortening of the left leg to the extent of one inch.
Left Knee. — He complains of tenderness on pressure over the internal condyle of the thigh bone. He also complains of pain in the same situation when the knee is bent. There is some slight crepitation on movement.
An X-ray examination carried out by Dr. Gamlen confirms the above findings in the case of the injured leg. It also shows there are no bone changes in the case of the left knee.
This man, in consequence of his accident, has, in the case of the left leg, received considerable permanent disablement, and will never be able to do anything but light work. He can now carry on the light work at which he was employed seven months after the accident."
Dr. Bush (the man's own doctor) on 28th January, 1926, reported as follows :—
"Present Condition. — He walks with a marked limp.
There is marked angular deformity at the juncture of the lower and middle third of the shin bone (Tibia). In consequence there is one inch shortening of the left leg with valgus deformity of the foot.
The left knee is tender on pressure over the inner condyle of the thigh bone (Femur). The pain is increased by bending the knee.
Grounds of Opinion. — Owing to the deformity of the left leg resulting from the accident I consider that this man will never be able to resume his usual occupation, and that light work will be all he will ever be able for."
Rutter is still off work and now claims full compensation.
Awarded compensation at the reduced rate of 18/- per week.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/6, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol VI covering Jan-Dec 1926