Chopwell. William Henderson, 39, stoneman.
In June, 1909, this man had his left foot fractured through a fall of stone. He was off work six months and full compensation was paid. He continued to work until July, 1912, when be sustained another fracture of the left foot on the site of the old fracture. Full compensation was again paid and continued until 1921, when he commenced, light work at which he continued for a few months and he then commenced at his ordinary work. He continued to work as a stoneman until 18th June, 1925, when the colliery closed down. On 26th July, 1926, the foot was X-rayed at the Royal Victoria Infirmary at Newcastle, and on 28th July, 1926, Dr. Mackae (the man's own doctor) reported as follows :—
"Present Condition. — He complains of great pain in his left foot and leg on making any movement and is only able to walk with the aid of a stick.
There is marked limitation of movement in the left ankle joint and also swelling of foot and ankle. The internal aspect of dorsum of left foot shows swelling suggestive of an old fracture of left tarsal bones. There is a distinct prominence palpable next the lower extremity of left fibula, and the X-ray report states that there is an old fracture in lower third of left fibula with bony union to the left tibia.
Grounds of Opinion. — I am of the opinion that, as a direct result of the above accidents, this man is quite unfit for work."
The management are refusing to pay compensation on the grounds that Henderson's present incapacity is not due to an accident. Henderson now claims full compensation.
Awarded compensation at the reduced rate of 12/- per week from 26th July, 1926.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/6, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol VI covering Jan-Dec 1926