Springwell. George Lewis, 16, driver.
In June, 1924, this lad had his leg crushed between the rope and limbers. He continued to work until 4th December, 1925, when he had to fall off owing to the injury sustained in June, 1924. The management are refusing to pay compensation on the grounds that the accident was not reported.
Dr. Willan (the Owners' doctor) on 10th March, 1926, reported as follows :—
"On Examination. — The patient was examined in bed. He has a long operation scar on the outer side of the right thigh, practically along its whole length. It is healed, except near the lower end where it is discharging.
He has a healed, circular, non-adherent scar, the size of a three-penny-bit, over the inner side of the right knee.
The lower three-fifths of the shaft of the right femur is very much thickened.
Except for full flexion on to the thigh, the right knee joint movements are normal.
The right hip joint is normal.
Opinion. — This patient has a chronic osteitis of the femur, probably with some necrosis of the bone, He cannot work.
Such an accident as he describes could cause necrosis of the bone in the lower end of the femur. If, therefore, you are satisfied that an accident, as described, did occur I would recommend that liability be accepted."
Dr. Hetherington (Lewis's own doctor) on 5th April, 1926, reported as follows :—
"Present Condition. — The right thigh shows a scar in the length of the thigh about 12 inches long. At the lower end of the scar there is a discharging Sinus (communication with the bone) and, in my opinion, there is still a small piece of dead bone (sequestrum) to be discharged.
Grounds of Opinion. — The accident which happened in 1924 is quite consistent with the condition (If the patient at present, and was, in my opinion, the cause of the Chronic Osteitis (inflammation of the bone) present."
Lewis is still off work and now claims full compensation.
Awarded full compensation from 7th December, 1925.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/6, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol VI covering Jan-Dec 1926