Brandon. James Burns 53, labourer.
On April 11th, 1922, this man sustained injuries to his foot and shoulder through a kiln collapsing. Full compensation was paid for 15 months when he commenced light work and he continued at such until 28th March, 1926, when he again fell off. Compensation is being paid at the reduced rate of 7/6 per week.
Dr. Willan (the Owners' doctor) on 1st May, 1926, reported as follows :—
"Examination: — There is no evidence of swelling or oedema of the right foot or ankle ; the hollows on either side of the Tendo Achillis are normal. There is some thickening of the posterior part of the Os Calcis. The right ankle joint movements are normal. There is no flat foot. There is wasting of the left arm and shoulder muscles. There is marked creaking on moving the left shoulder, also some limitation of movement. There is slight degree of creaking in the right shoulder.
Opinion: — As a result of the accident he fractured his right Os Calcis ; the fracture was NOT into the ankle joint. He also sustained an injury to the left shoulder which has developed into an osteo arthritis. He should be able to do substantial light work such as wheeling a barrow, etc."
Dr. Brown (the man's own doctor) on 11th May, 1926, reported as follows :—
"Present Condition — I find he complains of pain in right heel (the heel bone having been fractured by the fall, revealed by the X-Ray examination). He cannot spring on the foot ; he cannot raise himself on his toes, when he attempts to do this the pain goes up the calf of the leg. When the ankle is moved there is a rough grating sound to be heard in the joint. There is some thickening of the bone on the outer side where the fracture had been. He cannot walk any distance ; he walks with a limp. There is limitation of movement of the ankle joint. He complains of pain in the left shoulder ; there is wasting of the muscles of the shoulder and arm also creaking on movement of the shoulder joint. The left scapula stands out abnormally. When he attempts to raise his arm above his head he does this with great difficulty.
I am of opinion he is suffering from the accident he received to his foot and shoulder on the 11th April, 1922. He is only able to do very light work not involving any walking or standing on the feet or which requires any strain on the arm. I am further of opinion that his present condition will be permanent."
Burns is still off work and now claims full compensation.
Awarded compensation at the reduced rate of 17/6 per week.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/6, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol VI covering Jan-Dec 1926