Browney. Fred Lonsdale, 45, shifter.
On 18th May, 1917, this man sustained an injury to his knee and full compensation was paid. On 9th July, 1923, he sustained another injury to his knee and full compensation was again paid. On 4th February, 1926, the same knee was again injured in the same place, but the management are refusing the pay compensation on a report of Dr. Leigh de Legh (the Owners' doctor) who reported on 18th February, 1926, as follows :—
"He is recovered. The left knee joint was successfully operated upon for loose cartilage in 1918 ; the result is very good, I can find no evidence of any disability.
His condition is such that he is fit for his own work."
Dr. Denholm (the man's own doctor) on 22nd February, 1926, reported as follows :—
"Present Condition. — Very much improved and patient is practically ready for work.
Grounds of Opinion. — I am of opinion that originally this was a dislocated cartilage of knee which was operated on and a slight tag of cartilage was left. This would be sufficient to cause this accident and the disability.
Lonsdale is still off work and now claims full compensation.
The Committee failed to agree.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/6, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol VI covering Jan-Dec 1926