Ryhope. James Patton, 74, onsetter.
On 28th January, 1925, this man sustained an injury to his left shoulder through falling down whilst at work. Full compensation was paid until 13th March, 1926, when it was stopped on a report of Dr. Raw (the Owners' doctor) who reported on 25th February, 1926, as follows :—
"On examination I found that he was feet 10 inches in height, and weighs 9 st. 8lbs. There are marked senile changes in his whole arterial system, and his blood pressure is raised 20% above the normal. His exercise tolerance is bad. I found some wasting of the muscles which is the principal agent in raising of the arm above the level of the shoulder, and I formed the opinion that this wasting was the direct result of injury to the nerve supply to the muscle. It is a not uncommon result of a fall upon the point of the shoulder. As a consequence of this wasting he is unable to lift the arm above the horizontal, and is completely incapacitated front doing any work that would necessitate the use of his arm in this position.
This is the only remaining disability from his accident, and whilst it is real, though small, disability, it would not in itself prevent him from following his usual work as an on-setter regularly.
I am, however, of opinion that he is quite unable to follow any manual occupation. He is both aged and old, and I am very definitely of opinion that he would have had to give up work before now, even though he had not sustained any injury a year ago, because of the failing of his general health.
I am, therefore, of opinion
1. That but for his age and general health he would have been able to return to work.
2. Because of his age and general health he is unable to return to work, and he is not likely to become able to return to work."
Dr. Bain (the man's own doctor) on 6th March, 1926, reported as follows :—
"Present Condition. — He still suffers pain and disability in left shoulder joint and arm. There is wasting of muscles of left shoulder. Considering his age (75) his constitution is sound ; his vital organs healthy. But for the injury he would be able to resume his work.
Grounds of Opinion. — Constitution is still sound. There is wasting of muscles of left shoulder region."
Patton is still off work and now claims full compensation.
Awarded 12/6 per week permanent rate.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/6, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol VI covering Jan-Dec 1926