|
Non-fatal AccidentRobert Humble
Durham Miners' Association
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Arbitration Committee — 13th April 1926 | |
Report of Proceedings
of
Arbitration Committee Meeting
held in the
The Coal Trade Offices, Newcastle-on-Tyne
On April 13th 1926
South Pelaw. Robert Humble, 37, hewer.
On 27th June 1922, this man fell off with Miners' Nystagmus. Full compensation was paid until 30th December, 1925, when it was stopped on a report of the Owners' doctor (Dr. Wardale).
The case was referred to the Official Medical Referee (Dr. Percival) who reported on 13th March, 1926, as follows :—
1. "The said R. Humble is afflicted with persistent tremors of the head and neck and of the hands and arms when extended. His muscles are apparently of good tone and well developed but he has lost power. His knee jerks are excessive, and his condition is such that he is quite unfit for work. To-day he gives no evidence of Miners' Nystagmus. I am unable to express any opinion as to whether his present condition is due or is not due to Miners' Nystagmus.
2. The incapacity of the said R. Humble is due to his present condition, whether that condition is due to a previous Miners' Nystagmus, I have no experience on which to base an opinion."
On the above report no compensation is being paid. Humble is still off work and now claims full compensation.
Referred to Dr. Beattie for examination and report.
Official Medical Referee Cases.
South Pelaw. Robert J. Humble.
"Condition on Examination. — He is a tall, well nourished, heavy man. His neck is slightly flexed so that his head hangs a little forward. His face is stolid and expressionless. He shows coarse tremors of his head amid of his hands. He stands in a slightly stooping attitude amid walks with a shuffling unsteady gait and totters forward when pushed and backwards when pulled (festination and retropulsion). His eyes show no Nystagmus, not even with artificial light, leaning forward and with head rotated and eyes deviated to either side. His pupils are equal and react normally. His optic discs show no optic neuritis or atrophy. There is no paresis of his ocular muscle on extreme deviation in any direction and his motor cranial nerve paths show no defect. his knee jerks are active and equal on the two sides. He anticipates and voluntarily jerks his leg before receiving the tap on the patella tendon. His lungs show nothing abnormal. His heart is regular; there is no valvular defect. His abdominal organs are normal on palpation. His urine contains no albumen and no sugar.
Opinion. — There is no evidence of Miners' Nystagmus at the present time. His present condition is suggestive of paralysis agitans which may have arisen primarily or may have resulted from a mild and undetected attack of encephalitis lethargica.
His present condition is not due to existing, nor to a previously existing Miners' Nystagmus, and cannot in my opinion, be in any way associated with that condition. He is not fit for any form of work and I am afraid, his disability is permanent."
(Signed) THOMAS BEATTIE,
Medical Referee."
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/6, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol VI covering Jan-Dec 1926
| Arbitration Committee — 7th June 1926 | |
Report of Proceedings
of
Arbitration Committee Meeting
held in the
The Coal Trade Offices, Newcastle-on-Tyne
On June 7th 1926
South Pelaw. Robert Humble, 37, hewer.
On 27th June, 1922, this man fell off with Miners' Nystagmus. Full compensation was paid until 30th December, 1925, when it was stopped on a report of the Owners' doctor (Dr. Wardale).
The case was referred to the Official Medical Referee (Dr. Percival) who reported on 13th March, 1926, as follows :—
1. "The said R. Humble is afflicted with persistent tremors of the head and neck and of the hands and arms when extended. His muscles are apparently of good tone and well developed but he has lost power. His knee jerks are excessive, and his condition is such that he is quite unfit for work. To-day he gives no evidence of Miners' Nystagmus. I am unable to express any opinion as to whether his present condition is due or is not due to Miners' Nystagmus.
2. The incapacity of the said R. Humble is due to his present condition, whether that condition is due to a previous Miners' Nystagmus, I have no experience on which to base an opinion."
The case was before the Arbitration Committee on 13th April, 1926, when it was referred to Dr. Thomas Beattie, who reported on 21st April, 1926, as follows :—
"Condition on Examination. — He is a tall, well nourished, heavy man. His neck is slightly flexed so that his head hangs a little forward. His face is stolid and expressionless. He shows coarse tremors of his head and of his hands. He stands in a slightly stooping attitude and walks with a shuffling, unsteady gait and totters forwards when pushed, and backwards when pulled (festination and retropulsion). H is eyes show no Nystagmus — not even with artificial light, leaning forward and with head rotated and eyes deviated to either side.
His pupils are equal and react normally. His optic discs show no optic neuritis or atrophy. There is no paresis of his ocular muscles on extreme deviation in any direction and his motor cranial nerve paths show no defect. His knee jerks are active and equal on the two sides. He anticipates and voluntarily jerks his leg before receiving the tap on the patellar tendon.
His lungs show nothing abnormal. His heart is regular. There is no valvular defect. H is abdominal organs are normal on Palliation. His urine contains no albumen and no sugar.
Opinion. — There is no evidence of Miners' Nystagmus at the present time. H is present condition is suggestive of paralysis agitans which may have arisen primarily or may have resulted from a mild and undetected attack of encephalitis lethiargica.
His present condition is not due to existing nor to a previously existing Miners' Nystagmus, and cannot in my opinion, be in any way associated with that condition. He is not fit for any form of work and I am afraid his disability is permanent."
Humble is still off work and now claims full compensation.
Claim disallowed
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/6, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol VI covering Jan-Dec 1926
| Sources | |
| Researchers | |
| Researcher | Date | Interest | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Geoffrey Humble |
Humble One Name Study |
||
If you are researching Robert Humble (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||