Horden. John Burke, 19, cleaner-out.
On 30th October, 1925, this man sustained an injury to his left breast through the key slipping when he was tightening up the coal-cutting machine. The management are refusing to pay compensation.
The man's own doctor on 9th January, 1926, reported as follows :—
"Present Condition. — Scar healed: will be fit to work in seven days.
Grounds of Opinion. — No lump in breast till after injury. Lump occurred day after injury."
Dr. Noble (the Hospital doctor) on 11th February, 1926, reported as follows :—
In reply to your letter of the fifth instant in the matter of John Burke, aged 19 years, who was an in-patient of this Hospital from November 25th to December 16th, 1925, I regret that through preparation of my Annual Report I have not been able to attend to it earlier. Some time ago I wrote a report on the case for the Horden Colliery Company, and in all fairness you should have a similar statement.
The case of Burke is one of interest from the point of view of Compensation claims. This youth was admitted on November 25th, 1925, suffering from a benign tumour in the left breast known as an adenoma. It appeared, he alleged, subsequent to a blow on the breast sustained while at work. Now these tumours arise quite independently of any injury, and are comparatively common in women, though rare in the male sex. Burke has a condition of both breasts known as Gynalcomazia — which means that he has breasts like those of a woman. While such a tumour as I say, develops in a woman, and would be predisposed to by the condition of Burke's breast, yet no one could definitely prove that the condition, i.e., the tumour, did not follow a blow. I think, privately, that the tumour was not due the injury, but I also think that a medical man would be quite justified in supporting the view that accident may cause such a tumour. It may be difficult for you to appreciate the position. Perhaps I can put it clearly as follows :— Burke had a tumour which he alleges followed an injury. I removed the tumour and know that it microscopically is an "adenoma." Now an adenoma is a gland tumour which is quite common in the breast of a woman. Moreover, Burke has a congenital condition of woman-like breasts, so that he is more likely to develop such a tumour without any definite cause. Again, so little is definitely known of the primary cause of such new growths as Burke had that I say it would be impossible for anyone to wholly exclude a blow as the origin. I feel, and I mentioned this when I made a report to the Horden Collieries Company, that I could go into Court and make a very good case either for or against an injury being the primary activation. I am of the candid opinion, however, that although no definite proof could he given as excluding an injury, it would not be considered as causal. I may say in closing, that this report is almost identical — in gist — with that which I submitted to the Company."
Burke commenced at his own work on 18th January, 1926, and now claims full compensation for time off.
Awarded full compensation for six weeks in settlement.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/6, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol VI covering Jan-Dec 1926