Heworth. Andrew Willis, 51, hewer.
On 7th December, 1921, this man sustained injuries to his elbow through a fall of stone. Full compensation was paid until he ultimately commenced light work, and he continued at such intermittently until 6th November, 1925, when he again fell off. Full compensation was paid until 12th December, 1925, when it was reduced to 7/6 per week on a report of Dr. Willan (the Owners' doctor) who reported on 27th November, 1925, as follows :—
"Signs. — There is some wasting of the right arm and forearm muscles. He cannot flex the elbow joint as far as a right angle, nor can he extend it the range of movement is about 40 degrees. He can pronate the right forearm, but cannot full supinate it. There is no heat about the joint.
On palpation there is an irregularity of the right olecranon — There has been a fracture with firm bony union.
Opinion. — As a result of the accident he had a fracture of the right olecranon process into the elbow joint. This has left some degree of disability, and I do not think he is capable of working as a hewer. He can do a full left handed job with substantial assistance from the right hand. I believe his story that the jarring pain using a pick or shovel will cause him pain."
Dr. Durant (the man's own doctor) on 6th November, 1925, reported as follows :—
"The injury caused such damage to one of the hones of the joint as to leave an enlargement which impedes the movement of the elbow to some extent. Although not bad enough to stop him working as a miner — he is not capable of doing a full miner's work. He is capable of doing work of a character not entailing heavy laborious movement — such as surface work or screen work. He will never be able again to do the full work of a miner."
No suitable light work has been offered and Willis now claims full compensation.
Awarded 12/6 per week.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/6, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol VI covering Jan-Dec 1926