Tanfield Moor. James Rourke, 15, driver.
On 16th December, 1916, Rourke sustained a compound fracture of the right leg through being run over by a full tub of stones. He ultimately commenced light work and continued at such for about three years. He then tried putting, and on 27th September, 1922, a tub came back on the same leg and broke open the wound. Full compensation was paid until 8th January, 1923, when he commenced light work and he continued at such until 4th July, 1925, when the colliery closed down.
Dr. Gemmell (the man's own doctor) on 14th August, 1925, reported as follows :—
"Present Condition. — There is a large healed scar over the site of the injury. There is some deformity and wasting of the leg. He complains of pain and weakness in the leg, especially if he has much walking to do.
Grounds of Opinion. — His condition is due to the accident. He is fit for light work."
The case was before the Arbitration Committee on 16th November, 1925, when it was referred to the Official Medical Referee (Dr. Gordon Bell) who reported on 8th December, 1925, as follows :—
"The said James Rourke is suffering from a healed scar on the site of an old fracture, and his condition is such that he is fit for the work of a putter.
Note. — The reference limits me to the accident of 27th November, 1922. — R.G.B."
The case was before the Arbitration Committee on 21st December, 1925, when it was referred back to the Official Medical Referee (Dr. Gordon Bell) who reported on 27th January, 1926, as follows :—
1. "The said James Rourke is suffering from an old fracture which has a moderate deformity, and his condition is such that he is not incapacitated for work as a driver.
Note. — I see the question in the reference is limited to a driver."
No suitable light work being available Rouke now claims full compensation.
The Committee failed to agree.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/6, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol VI covering Jan-Dec 1926