South Moor 1. Robert Gibson, 53, hewer.
On 16th April, 1925, this man sustained an injury to his right ankle through being struck with the handle of a shovel. Full compensation was paid until 10th November, 1925, when it was reduced to 7/6 per week on a report of Dr. Willan (the Owners' Doctor) who reported on 28th October, 1925, as follows :—
"On examination I find there is no wasting of the leg muscles. The normal hollows on either side of the Tendo Achillis are present. There is no swelling of the foot, ankle or leg to be made out.
The ankle and mid-tarsal joint movements are normal. No creaking can be made out on movement. He has normally a high arch of his foot. He can stand on his toes.
The peroneal tendons behind the external malleolus can be displaced on to the lateral aspect of the bone.
Opinion. — As a result of the accident he has torn the ligament normally holding the peroneal tendons in the bony groove. He can do light work, but he cannot work in the dark where he cannot pick his ground to walk on.
I would recommend that he have the ligament reconstructed by operation. This would probably be successful and, if so, he would be cured. I informed him of this recommendation.
Dr. Dewar (the man's own doctor) on 13th November, 1925, reported as follows :—
Present Condition. — One tendon still out of position. This causes him to slip when walking and gives him a sense of insecurity."
No suitable light work has been offered and Gibson now claims full compensation.
Awarded full compensation up to date. Full compensation to be paid when undergoing operative treatment.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/6, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol VI covering Jan-Dec 1926