Dean and Chapter. John William Allan, 50, hewer.
On 20th May, 1923, this man fell off with Miners' Nystagmus. Full compensation was paid until 7th November, 1925, when it was reduced to 7/6 per week on a report of Dr. Wardale (the Owners' doctor) who reported on 23rd October, 1925, as follows :—
"Present Condition. — This man has slight traces of Nystagmus and is therefore not fit to go down the pit, but I think he is well able to work at bank.
He is very stout and is greatly troubled with shortness of breath if he exerts himself, so that because of his physical condition he is unable to do much stooping or hard manual labour."
Dr. Boyd Cunningham (the man's own doctor) on 31st October, 1925, reported as follows :—
"Examination. — Allan is suffering to-day from Miners' Nystagmus. The oscillation of the eyeballs can be seen after he has been stooping for a short time. They are more marked when he is examined in a darkened room. Twitching of the lids and giddiness are also present.
From the result of my examination I am of opinion that Allan is incapacitated from working underground. He is also unfit for the full work of a labourer at bank. He is only fit for light work in daylight where there is little or no stooping or heavy lifting, as stooping or heavy lifting would only aggravate the Miners' Nystagmus from which he is still suffering."
No suitable light work has been offered and Allan now claims full compensation.
The Committee failed to agree.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/6, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol VI covering Jan-Dec 1926