Non-Fatal Cases.
New Brancepeth. Robert Illand, 35, hewer.
On 26th January, 1915, this main sustained an injury to his skull and lost the sight of his right eye through a fall of stone. Full compensation was paid until 1st November, 1925, when it was reduced to 7/6 per week on a report of Dr. Hare (the Owners' doctor) who reported on 16th October, 1925, as follows :—
"He is complaining that he cannot do any heavy work. Whilst acting as a hewer he was caught by a fall of stone and sustained a compound fracture of the skull over R. eye chiefly. Blindness followed in R. eye immediately. There was no paralysis except R. eye. He did light work at bank then did three months as wagonwayman, returned to light work at bank, returned to hewing for 12 months and had to cease when big strike occurred in 1921. He did stonework and shift work until 19th June. Examined by Dr. Hume in July, 1924. He has not worked since. He was certified fit for work at bank by Dr. Hume. His condition is such that he is fit for useful labouring work at bank or shift work down pit. I do not consider him any worse than he was in 1921 when he managed to hew for 12 months.
In my opinion the cause or causes of the workman's present disablement are due to injury to head and eye, and that the probable duration of the partial disability is permanent and slight."
Dr. Norris (the man's own doctor) on 26th October, 1925, reported as follows :—
"Present Condition — In my opinion the accident caused atrophy or injury to the optic nerve. He gets giddy when stooping. He is nervous and suffers from dizziness. He is completely blind in right eye. Disability will be permanent.
Grounds of Opinion. — He is fit for work at bank. In my opinion he is not fit to work as a hewer again as his partial blindness (blind in one eye) and his dizziness and nervousness when stooping, due to the injuries to the head, render him unable to work at the coal face."
No suitable light work being available Illand now claims full compensation.
Awarded 16/- per week.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/6, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol VI covering Jan-Dec 1926