Windlestone. Joseph Barker, 48, shifter.
On October 25th, Barker and a stoneman named Patterson were pushing a tram of timber on to the Bank head of an incline. When they reached the top of the incline Patterson went to the fore-end of the tram for some purpose, and Barker was holding on to the tram alone, and whilst doing so he slipped and strained himself. Barker did not report the accident, but on the Thursday when he went across for his pay-note, he reported it to the master shifter. Barker resumed work on the Sunday, and worked two shifts, but was compelled to be off again, and he then sent word with his wife to tell the master shifter of his inability to continue working owing to the strain. Barker was operated upon at Newcastle Infirmary on November 5th, 1915, and Dr. Pybus reported on January 17th, 19 16:—
1st. Accident.
Three years ago a piece of timber fell and hit him on the right groin. He was off work weeks. After he started work a lump appeared in the right groin after 8 or 9 weeks, and proved to be a hernia. This did not trouble him much, and he has worked up till the second accident. The hernia was about the size of a hen's egg, and he never wore a truss. This rupture may have been caused by the accident.
On 26th October, 1915, while shoving a tram of timber his foot slipped, and he felt a sudden pain in the right groin. He was able to finish the shift. On getting home he found the rupture was much larger. He stayed off worked the next day, but later tried to work and found it impossible.
At the operation I found a hernia of some standing, but partially divided into two parts, one probably of long standing, and the other of recent origin, and most probably representing the extra part forced out by the second accident.
I therefore consider the second accident undoubtedly aggravated a hernia already present, and was the cause of his being off work and operation.
The claim was resisted on the grounds that the accident was not reported, and that Barker was suffering from the effects of an old injury.
We failed to connect Barker's condition with the accident, and the claim was therefore disallowed.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/1/6/41, D.M.A. Minutes, Circulars etc. for 1916 (one volume: covers Jan-Jun)