Chopwell. William Noble, 63, stoneman.
Whilst lifting a heavy stone on October 19th, 1911, Noble fell and injured his back, and he has been off work since, and received full compensation. The Owners ask a review of the compensation on the grounds that Dr. Morison has reported that 75% of Noble's inability is due to natural causes, and only 25 % to the accident. Dr. Morison reported on November 23rd, 1915, as follows:—
"Noble is no better since I last reported on him (June 7th, 1913). He has done nothing since, because of pain in the back. He cannot lift anything.
I find that he is broken down nervous old man. He walks with a stick and limps. He is stiff all over, and cannot stoop because his back is stiff.
My opinion is, he is totally and permanently incapacitated for any sort of work, chiefly owing to his feebly general condition, partly owing to injured back."
Noble has been examined on behalf of the Association by Dr. Parkin, of Newcastle, who reported on December 11th :—
"In my opinion Parkin is unfit for work of any kind at present, and this disability will probably be permanent. His present condition is, in my opinion, the result of a severe sprain of the muscles of his back resulting from the accident."
The Owners withdrew the case.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/1/6/41, D.M.A. Minutes, Circulars etc. for 1916 (one volume: covers Jan-Jun)