4488. Dawdon. George Spooner, 28, hewer.
Slipped whilst hewing on 17th August, 1921. The accident was reported and Spooner continued to follow his work until 22nd December, 1921, when his doctor advised him to undergo an operation. He was admitted to the Sunderland Infirmary on 4th January and operated upon for hernia, on 10th January by Dr. Ayre Smith who reported on 21st January, 1922 :—
"The condition found at the operation showed that a hernia was present — that a tendency towards the formation of a hernia had existed for some time and that an accident such as a fall in August, 1921 (as described by the patient) could reasonably be supposed to have finally caused the hernia to appear."
Dr. Neilan (Spooner's own doctor) reported on 9th January :—
"I examined this man about a week ago. I found that he was suffering from an inquinal hernia (rupture) on the left side. In my opinion the hernia was caused by an accident which took place, as I am informed, on 17th August, 1921
Compensation was refused because Dr. Todd reported that Spooner was not suffering from an accident.
Claim allowed.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/3, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol III covering Jan-Dec 1922