|
Non-fatal AccidentEmanuel Clark
Durham Miners' Association
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Arbitration Committee — 13th October 1919 | |
Committee Meeting
Held on October 13th 1919
2944. Usworth. Emanuel Clark, 62, hewer.
Clark received a blow in the right eye on April 4th, 1911, and was off a few months owing to the accident. He started work and in 1912 he contracted Miners' Nystagmus, and was off until 1916, when he started light work which he continued to perform until May 1st, 1919. The case was referred to the Official Medical Referee (Dr Percival), who reported on July 7th as follows :—
"Clark is almost blind from cataract. His right eye has been operated upon unsuccessfully. His left eye cataract is not matured yet, i.e., is not yet ready for operation, and his condition is such that he is unable to do any kind of work at the colliery.
"The incapacity of the said E. Clark is not due to Coal Miners' Nystagmus, from which he has apparently recovered."
Clark then alleged that it was the accident that was disabling him and not the nystagmus. The case was consequently again referred to the Medical Referee, who reported as follows :—
"Clark is almost blind from cataract. His right eye has been unsuccessfully operated upon for cataract due to the injury of April 12th, 1911. His left eye has now a senile cataract not due to the injury, and his condition is such that he is totally incapacitated for work.
"The incapacity of Clark is due to the loss of sight in his right eye which was injured in 1911."
The Owners agreed that the Official Medical Referee had not stated whether the loss of the sight was due to the accident in 1911, and it was decided to refer the matter back to the Medical Referee for him to report on that matter.
Official Medical Referee Cases
2994. Usworth. E. Clark, 62, hewer.
1. "The said E. Clark is almost blind from cataract. His right eye has been unsuccessfully operated upon for cataract due to the injury 12th April, 1911. His left eye has now a senile cataract not due to the injury and his condition is such that he is totally incapacitated for work.
2. "The incapacity of the said E. Clark is due to the loss of sight in his right eye which was injured in 1911.
"Dated this 5th day of September, 1919.
"(Signed) A. S. PERCIVAL,
"Medical Referee."
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/1, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol I covering Sep 1918-Dec 1919
| Arbitration Committee — 1st December 1919 | |
Committee Meeting
Held on December 1st 1919
2994. Usworth. E. Clark, 62, hewer.
Clark received a blow in the right eye on April 12th, 1911, and was off a few months owing to the accident. He started work and in 1912 he contracted Nystagmus and was off work until 1916 when he started light work which he continued to perform until May 1st, 1919. The case was referred to the Official Medical Referee (Dr Percival), who reported on July 7th, 1919, as follows :—
"Clark is almost blind from cataract. His right eye has been operated upon unsuccessfully. His left eye cataract is not matured yet, i.e., is not yet ready for operation, and his condition is such that he is unable to do any kind of work at the Colliery.
"The incapacity of the said E. Clark is not due to Coal Miners' Nystagmus, from which he has apparently recovered."
Clark then alleged that it was the accident that was disabling him and not the nystagmus. The case was consequently again referred to the Medical Referee who reported as follows :—
Clark is almost blind from cataract. His right eye has been unsuccessfully operated upon for cataract due to the injury on 12th April, 1911. His left eye has now a senile cataract not due to the injury, and his condition is such that he is totally incapacitated for work.
"The incapacity of Clark is due to the loss of sight in his right eye which was injured in 1911."
The Committee at their meeting on October 13th decided to refer the matter back to the Official Medical Referee. The Medical Referee reported on November 10th as follows :—
"Clark is quite blind in his right eye and the vision with his left eye is less than 6/60th, and his condition is such that he is totally incapacitated for work.
"The incapacity of Clark is due to the injury on 12th April, 1911."
There was a report from the Medical Referee in 1912 which stated that Clark's disability was not due to the accident and the Owners therefore alleged that the reports of the Medical Referee were contradictory.
It was decided to refer the case to an eye Specialist (Dr Bennett) for him to report as to whether Clark is partially or totally disabled by the accident, nystagmus or natural causes.
Official Medical Referee Cases
2994. Usworth. Emmanuel Clark, 62, hewer.
1. "The said E. Clark is quite blind in his right eye and the vision with his left eye is less than 6/60ths and his condition is such that he is totally incapacitated for work.
2. "The incapacity of the said E. Clark is due to the injury on 12th April, 1911.
"Dated this 10th day of November, 1919.
"(Signed) ARCHD. STANLEY PERCIVAL,
"Medical Referee."
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/1, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol I covering Sep 1918-Dec 1919
| Sources | |
| Researchers | |
If you are researching Emanuel Clark (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||