Museum Entrance logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Donate to support the Museum
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

  Individual Details   Individual Details  
 

Non-fatal Accident

Thomas Wild

Accident:  
Age:   21
Year Born:   abt. 1898
Colliery:   Dawdon
Company:  
Occupation:   Putter
Notes:  

Arbitration Committee — 7th July 1919

Durham Miners' Association
Compensation Committee

Committee Meeting
Held on July 7th 1919

County Court Cases

2851. Dawdon. Thomas Wild, 21, putter.

I append the judgment given by Judge Moore in this case at the Sunderland County Court on July 24th. The case was heard before him at Sunderland County Court on June 26th. Briefly it is as follows :—

Wild was employed as a putter at Dawdon, and when the Government required men to work in the shipyards he was one of the number who volunteered from Dawdon, and started under conditions arranged by the representatives of the Ministry of National Service and our Association. Unfortunately whilst working in the shipyard Wild was injured, and our contention was that, had it not been for the accident he would now have been following his ordinary occupation as a putter at Dawdon, and thereby earning much higher wages than he is in receipt of at the present time. The shipbuilding firm by whom he was and is at present employed alleged that they were not liable, as Wild was set on by representatives of the Government, and they therefore declined to accept liability for partial compensation. We were not so much concerned as to who was liable so long as we were able to obtain what we thought was due to Wild. You will see by the decision that the Judge is of opinion that the case is met by awarding 6/- per week light work rate. I do not think we have any reason to grumble at such a decision. The case was a very complicated one, and the Respondents had the assistance of Mr Meynell, Barrister-at-Law, whilst our side of the case was presented by Mr Heath in his usual able manner. The Respondents feel that the decision is not a correct one, and have accordingly sent in notice of appeal, and Wild will therefore have to wait until the case is decided in the Appeal Court.

JUDGMENT

HIS HONOUR: In this case the Applicant, Thomas Wild, claims compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1906, in respect of an injury received by him through an accident which occurred on 27th April, 1918.

At the time of the accident the Applicant was employed in the Respondent's Shipyard as a plater's helper, but prior to 5th February, 1918, he was a miner employed as a putter at the Dawdon Colliery by the Londonderry Collieries, Ltd. It appears that in normal times the earnings of a putter employed in a mine are considerably higher than those of a plater's helper employed in a shipyard, but at the beginning of the year 1918 there was a great need for additional hands in the shipyards to expedite the work of replacing tonnage lost in the War, and the Government, through the Ministry of National Service, made a call addressed to men engaged in the mining industry for volunteers to undertake temporary work during the emergency in the shipyards instead of the mines. As an inducement to the men to volunteer, an arrangement was made whereby all those miners whose services were accepted should, in effect, be guaranteed by the Government the same earnings which they would have received at the mines — that is to say, they were to receive from the Shipbuilders the usual shipyard wage, and if that should be less than what they would have been earning in the colliery, the Government would make up the difference. It was also arranged that as soon as the emergency was over and there was no longer any need for their services in the shipyard, the men would be entitled to return to their work in the mines on the same terms as before. The Government, the Shipbuilders, the Colliery Owners, and the representatives of the miners themselves were all parties to this arrangement.

The Applicant was among those who responded to the call for volunteers and his services were accepted on the above terms.

What was the exact arrangement between the Government and the Shipbuilders with regard to the payment of the Government contribution there is no satisfactory evidence to show; but so far as the men were concerned they received from the Shipbuilders the full amount of their agreed remuneration (including whatever sum was contributed by the Government) and the Government made no payment direct to the men. It is said that the Shipbuilders were merely the Agents of the Government to pay to the men the difference between the shipyard wage and the amount which they would have been earning in the mines. That may be so, but I rather expect that if the full facts were before me I should find that the Shipbuilders were liable to the men for the full amount of their remuneration, and that the Government undertook to repay them the amount by which such remuneration exceeded the shipyard wage. However, in the view which I take of the case, the precise arrangements between the Government and the Shipbuilders are not very material.

The Applicant's services having been accepted, he started work with the Respondents as a plater's helper on 29th January, 1918. On 27th April, whilst engaged on his work, a heavy plate fell on his right foot, causing a compound fracture of the first or principal joint, and this has resulted in the big toe becoming permanently rigid. As a consequence of the accident, the Applicant was absent from work for twenty weeks, during which period he was paid by the Respondents full compensation tinder the Act. He returned to work in the shipyard as a plater's helper on 14th September, and from that date down to 17th December his average earnings, including the Government contribution, were £3/8/5 per week, as compared with £3/6/10 before the accident.

In December, 1918, the Government ceased to require the services of the miners in the shipyards, and on the 18th December the men, other than the Applicant who volunteered from Dawdon Colliery, returned according to arrangement to work at the mines. As from that date the Government contribution towards the wages of the miners ceased.

The Applicant did not return with the other men to the colliery, but stayed on in the employ of the Respondents, although he stated in evidence (and I accept his statement), that he preferred his old work as a putter to the work he is now doing, and although he is now receiving only the shipyard wage instead of the higher wage of a putter. The reason he gives for not returning to the colliery is that owing to the rigidity of his great toe he can no longer do the work of a putter. The Respondents deny that the rigidity of the great toe is a sufficiently serious drawback to prevent him from following that employment, but after hearing the evidence I find as a fact that it would handicap him to such an extent in the performance of the work of a putter as practically to debar him from earning his living in that way. He is still employed by the Respondents in their shipyard, but owing to the discontinuance of the Government contribution his earnings have now fallen to about £2/3/7, which is approximately the same amount as he was receiving before the accident, after deducting the amount of the Government contribution. He accordingly now claims compensation on the basis that he has, in consequence of the accident, lost the difference between the wages he is now receiving and his earnings at the time of the accident, that is to say, on the basis that he has lost the average amount of the Government contribution, his contention being that but for the accident, he would now be earning in the capacity of a putter at the colliery the same amount as he was receiving as a shipyard worker at the time of the accident.

On behalf of the Respondents it is contended that I am not entitled to award compensation on this basis. In the first place it is said that I ought not to take into account the amount of the Government contributions, as these contributions were not part of the Applicant's earnings as a shipyard worker, and did not come out of the pockets of the Respondents, but out of the pocket of the Government. I do not think this contention is sound. They were clearly part of the man's earnings; they were paid to him as part of the consideration for the services which be was rendering to the Respondents; they were to the knowledge of the Respondents, held out as an inducement to the Applicant to. enter their service; and they were actually paid over to the Applicant by the Respondents themselves.

Then it is said that on the facts I should not be justified in finding that as a result of the accident there has been any "total or partial incapacity for work" within the meaning of Clause 1 (b) of Schedule 1 of the Act, because the Applicant has since the accident admittedly been employed by the Respondents in the same capacity (i.e., as a shipyard worker) as before the accident, and his earnings were until the cessation of the Government contributions slightly bigger than before. In other words it is said that, as the Applicant is as capable of doing the same work as he happened to be employed on at the time when the accident occurred, I am not entitled to take into account the fact that he has been incapacitated for doing some other class of work. I cannot find in the Act itself any warrant for this contention. To adopt it I should have to read into Clause (b) after the words "total or partial incapacity for work" Some words (which are not there) limiting the meaning of the word "work." But I can see no justification for reading in such words; nor is it easy to see what are the precise words which it would be necessary to insert. It has been suggested that the latter portion of the clause shows that the word work must be limited to work "in the employment of the same employer"; but I cannot accept this suggestion, because the latter part of the clause deals only with the question of the amount of compensation to which a man is entitled, whereas the opening words deal with the conditions which entitle him to claim it. The conditions are, that he must be incapacitated for work, but the amount is regulated by his earnings in the employment of the same employer. It is further said that the loss of the Government contribution is not due to the accident, but solely to the fact that the special emergency which necessitated the employment in the shipyards of miners at a specially high rate of pa, is now over, and wages have accordingly fallen to their normal level. No doubt that is so, but if I am right in the view I have already expressed, that the words "incapacity for work" are not confined to incapacity for the particular class of work on which he was employed at the time of the accident, this fact seems to be irrelevant. Incapacity for work as a putter in a coal mine has ensued from the accident and, but for such incapacity, the Applicant would have been earning at the Colliery the same amount as he was earning as a shipyard worker at the time of the accident. It is therefore immaterial that since the accident wages in the shipyard have fallen.

I now pass on to consider how much in the circumstances of this case I ought to award to the Applicant. I certainly do not propose to give him anything like the difference between his present earnings and his earnings at the time of the accident. Although I have found that he is no longer able to follow the employment of a putter, I am far from satisfied that his earning capacity has fallen off to anything like the amount of that difference. I was very favourably impressed by his appearance. He seemed to be a very intelligent young man, and apart from the slight defect of the stiff joint to be strong and healthy; and I believe there is a very wide field of employment open to him. In fact, I think there is every reason to hope that he may ultimately be able to find employment which will bring him in as much as he was earning at the time of the accident. In the meanwhile I think the case will be met by making an award of six shillings a week.

Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/1, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol I covering Sep 1918-Dec 1919


Sources
  • NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/1, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol I covering Sep 1918-Dec 1919

Researchers

If you are researching Thomas Wild (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.

What is your name?
What is your contact email address?
What is your research interest?

 

Return Return   Return Return to Top

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print