|
Non-fatal AccidentFrancis Raw
Durham Miners' Association
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Arbitration Committee — 3rd March 1919 | |
Committee Meeting
Held on March 3rd 1919
County Court Cases
2821. New Copley. Francis Raw, 65, hewer.
This man received an injury to his eye through a piece of coal getting into it on July 27th, 1918. He did not report the accident at the time as he did not know that a piece of coal had got into his eye. He was sent to Darlington Hospital and had the piece of coal extracted from the eye by the House Surgeon. The claim was before the Arbitration Committee on December 2nd, 1918, when the Committee failed to agree. We decided to take the case to the County Court, and it was heard at Barnard Castle on February 10th before Judge McCarthy, who has just recently been appointed in place of Judge Templer. I herewith give you His Honour's decision which you will see is in our favour :—
Raw v. The New Copley Colliery Co. Ltd.
In this arbitration which was heard by me at Barnard Castle on the 10th inst., the workman claimed that he was totally and permanently disabled by accident arising out of and in the course of his employment. The employers pleaded that there was no injury by accident arising out of and in the course of his employment, and that due notice of the alleged accident was not given by him.
The workman was a hewer at the coal face. He is 66 years of age, and is an ignorant and somewhat unintelligent man. On Saturday morning, July 27th, at 7.30, he began his shift. There was nothing the matter with his eyes then, nor had he ever had anything wrong with them, except about twenty years ago when, he said, he had a cold in his right eye. Towards 11 o'clock a.m., being at his work the whole time, the left eye began to pain and become inflamed, but he worked out the shift which ended at o'clock. On getting home he bathed the eye and put on a bandage, but with no improvement. He was unable to work on Monday. He was not conscious of a blow on the eye, or of a foreign substance in it; he attributed its condition to a severe cold. As it did not get better he consulted his doctor, who is also the colliery doctor, who treated the ailment as Conjunctivitis, and gave the man a lotion with which to bathe the eye. On visiting the doctor a second time he advised him to consult a specialist, when the same advice was given by the colliery engineer, the witness, Frederick Thompson.
Accordingly on August 11th the workman went to Darlington and saw Dr Hern, an Ophthalmic Surgeon of great experience in the North of England and in Scotland. Up to this time the workman knew of no accident, and had no reason to think he was suffering from the results of an accident. The medical man who had treated him did not suggest and apparently did not suspect an accident. Dr Hern, however, discovered that a piece of coal, the size of a small pin's head, had penetrated the cornea, inflammation had set in, matter had collected, and although Dr Hern removed the coal in the hospital, the sight of the eye is destroyed, the lens being now quite opaque. The workman was detained in the hospital for about three weeks and was then discharged.
On August 5th, while believing that he was suffering from inflammation brought on by cold, the man had applied for sick benefit under the National Health Insurance, the statement signed by himself giving the ground as "illness," while the certificate of the Insurance Doctor, who was also his own and the Colliery Doctor, stated his ailment as "Conjunctivitis." It should be noted that a certificate from the Colliery Doctor dated August 9th, stating that he was suffering from "injury to the eye due to a blow from coal," was admittedly not given until a date about the middle of September or about a month after the date on the certificate.
I am satisfied that the first intimation the man had that he had been struck by a piece of coal which was then in the eye was on Au gust 11th or 12th, and that he was then in hospital about to undergo, or having just undergone, an operation which detained him there for three weeks. On his return home he saw the local Secretary of his Union, the witness, Henry Dunning, who had a meeting with the Respondent's Manager on September 5th on various matters, and put the Applicant's claim before him and a certificate from Dr Hern. The Manager wished for a certificate from their own doctor, and the document dated August 9th already mentioned was obtained. Mr Raine, the Manager, did not remember this, and thought he first heard about the matter on or about October 1st, when a formal written claim to compensation was put forward by the workman. I think the claim was verbally made by the Trade Union Secretary at or soon after September 5th, and that the certificate supporting it was in the hands of the Respondent's officials about the middle of September.
It should be mentioned that there is a friendly arrangement between the representatives of the Durham Coal Owners and Miners in regard to the administration of the Workmen's Compensation Act, by which (inter alia) costs are never asked for or paid, and verbal notice of an accident to a mine official is under certain circumstances accepted as sufficient by the Owner. Probably this latter agreement explains why Mr Dunning did not give formal written notice to the Manager on September 5th or soon afterwards, but it is agreed that I have to deal with this case independently of such agreement.
Dr Hern, the Ophthalmic Surgeon, gave evidence of great importance. He said the particle of coal which he found must have entered the eye with great force ; it could not have been "a mere wind-blown piece of coal dust. In half the cases I get of this kind the people are unconscious of a blow ; they think it is cold generally. I have had dozens of cases where the man has been unconscious of a blow like this." He gave instances in his recent practice of this, and said "the coal could not have got in while rubbing the eye for a cold — hand-rubbing would not apply enough force for that — never heard of such a case," i.e., of the hand rubbing a particle of coal into the ball of the eye, and in reply to a question by me Dr Hern said that getting particles of coal into the eye while working at the coal face was a very common accident in his experiences.
On this state of facts Mr Meynell for the Respondents contended than an accident arising out of and in the course of the employment was not proved. We are thrown back, he said, on conjecture or surmise. There are many ways in which a piece of coal or grit may be driven into the eye. As to the absence of notice, the learned Counsel contended that the prejudice to the employers was obvious, inasmuch as they had no opportunity of investigating the matter.
I think the workman is entitled to succeed on both points. The accident was one common in the work in which he was engaged; his eye was sound and healthy at 7.30 a.m. and for some hours later; about 11, whilst still at the work, the eye was painful and turns out to have been injured by a particle of coal entering it. Thus while at work he is found suffering from an injury common in that description of work. The only reasonable inference I feel able to draw from the facts is that he was injured in the course of his work by an accident arising out of that work. Any other inference seems to me to be baseless conjecture. In Evans v. Astley 11911 A.C. 678: 4 Butt, 319) Lord Loreburn, L.C., says: "It is of course impossible to lay down in words any scale or standard by which you can measure the degree of proof which will suffice to support a particular conclusion of fact. The Applicant must prove his case. This does not mean that he must demonstrate his case. If the more probable conclusion is that for which he contends and there is anything pointing to it there is evidence for the Court to act upon. Any conclusion short of certainty may be miscalled conjecture or surmise, but Courts, like individuals, habitually act on a balance of probabilities." And in Rice v. S.S. Swansea (1912 A.C. 238), His Lordship said, "What you want is to weigh probabilities, if there be proof of facts sufficient to enable you to find some foothold or ground for comparing and balancing possibilities at their respective values one against the other." See also Hayward v. Westleigh Colliery Co. (1915 A.C. 540), and Mr Adshead Elliott's work on the Act, 7th Edition, p. 19 et seq., where all the cases are collected under the heading "drawing inferences."
As to the absence of notice, there was, I think "reasonable cause" within Sec. 2 s.s.1. of the Act for not giving notice up to August 12th, when the workman first became acquainted with the facts connected with the injury (Thompson v. North Eastern Marine Co. [No. 2] 7 Butt. 49), and probably for some days later when he was lying at the hospital after the operation and was unable to give notice. However this may be, I am satisfied that the employers were not prejudiced by the delay after August 12th. On that date the man had the best medical treatment, and was in hospital tinder skilled care. So far as investigation of the accident is concerned I can see no ground for suggestion or suspicion of prejudice. His fellow-workmen could say nothing about an accident; the man himself did not know there was one; that he was suffering a few days later from something wrong with his eye was seen by his foreman and the Respondents' Engineer, both of whom gave evidence. I therefore find that there was no prejudice to the employers by reason of the delay in giving notice of the accident. See Tydmann v. Premier Accumulator Co. (9 Butt. 384) and Mills v. Dinning ton Main (to Butt. 153).
No argument was addressed to me and no evidence was given on the point whether the workman's incapacity was total, partial, or had ceased altogether. I cannot from my own knowledge of the industrial condition of the district say that a miner 66 years of age, whose loss of the sight of an eye is obvious, can obtain light work. It may be that he can, for except for the injured eye he seems in good health, but I have no evidence or knowledge on which to base any finding on the point.
Accordingly I award in favour of the workman in the terms of the application paragraph 10. I find total incapacity at present. Costs are provided for by agreement between the parties.
(Signed) J. W. MCCARTHY, Judge.
February 25th, 1919.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/1, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol I covering Sep 1918-Dec 1919
| Sources | |
| Researchers | |
If you are researching Francis Raw (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||