|
Non-fatal AccidentWittrance Cope
Durham Miners' Association
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Arbitration Committee — 9th September 1918 | |
Arbitration Committee Meeting
Held on September 9th 1918
2726. Houghton. Wittrance Cope, 48, timber drawer.
Received injuries to his back and hip on July 16th, 1903. The Official Medical Referee reported on June 8th, 1904, that Cope was not able to do the light work offered, and the Committee on July 25th, 1904, awarded compensation at the full rate. The Official Medical Referee reported again on January 4th, 1905, that sufficient time had elapsed for Cope to have fully recovered from his accident, and that he could do light work. On February 13th, 1905, the case was again referred to the Official Medical Referee, and also on March 2nd, 1905, when he reported that Cope was not suffering from the effects of the accident, and the inability to work was due to disease. On April 10th, 1905, the Committee awarded Cope full Compensation at 17/8¾ per week up to March 2nd, 1905, payments to cease after that date. On June 23rd, 1905, the case was again referred to the Official Medical Referee who reported that inability to work was not connected with the accident. The case was again before the Committee on November 17th, 1905, when it was decided to refer the matter to Dr Hume, who reported on December 4th, 1905 :—
1. "That Cope had entirely recovered from the effects of his accident;
2. "That he is not in good general health, but that this condition of health is not in any way the result of the accident;
3. "That he is fit to do light work, and the state of his health would be thereby improved."
This report was before the Committee on December 22nd, 1905, when the claim was disallowed. Cope has now produced medical evidence that he is unable to work owing to the injuries received on July 16th, 1903, and one of the doctors is one who formerly certified that Cope was not suffering from the accident, and Cope claimed to have his case re-opened.
The case was before the last meeting of the Committee when it was adjourned.
The Committee decided to refer the case to Dr G. H. Hume again, a doctor to be present from each side to give evidence.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/1, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol I covering Sep 1918-Dec 1919
| Arbitration Committee — 14th October 1918 | |
Arbitration Committee Meeting
Held on October 14th 1918
2726. Houghton. Wittrance Cope, 48, timber drawer.
Received injuries to his back and hip on July 16th, 1903. The Official Medical Referee reported on June 8th, 1904, that Cope was not able to do the light work offered, and the Committee on July 25th, 1904, awarded compensation at the full rate. The Official Medical Referee reported again on January 4th, 1905, that sufficient time had elapsed for Cope to have recovered from his accident, and that he could do light work. On February 13th, 1905, the case was again referred back to the Official Medical Referee, and also on March 2nd, when he reported that Cope was not suffering from the effects of the accident and the inability to work was clue to disease. On April 10th, 1905, the Committee awarded Cope full compensation at 17/8.75 per week up to March 2nd, 1905, payments to cease after that date. On June 23rd, 1905, the case was again referred to the Official Medical Referee, who reported that the inability to work was not connected with the accident. The case was again before the Committee on November 17th, 1905, when it was decided to refer the matter to Dr. Hume, who reported on December 4th, 1905, as follows :—
1. "That Cope had entirely recovered from the effects of his accident.
2. "That he is not in good general health, but that this condition of health is not in any way the result of the accident.
3. "That he is fit to do light work and the state of his health would be thereby improved."
This report was before the Committee on December 22nd, 1905, when the claim was disallowed. Cope now produced medical evidence that he is unable to work owing to the injuries received on July 10th, 1903, and one of the doctors is one who formerly certified that Cope was not suffering from the accident, and Cope claimed to have his case reopened.
The case was before the August meeting of the Committee when it was adjourned, and at the last meeting the Committee decided to refer the case again to Dr. Hume, and for a doctor on each side to be present when Cope was examined. Cope was examined by Dr. Home at Dr. Morgan's rooms at Sunderland on October 1st, and the following is his report :—
"I have to report that at the request of the Arbitration Committee of the Owners and Miners in the County of Durham, on the 1st of October, 1918, in Sunderland, I examined Wittrance Cope in respect of injuries he sustained in July, 1903. At the examination there were p resent Drs G. B. Morgan and A. E. Morison. I was also furnished with copies of reports which had been made from time to time on the case, and with an X-ray photograph showing the injured part of the body.
"The description given of the accident was that while drawing props a mass of stone fell, burying him and crushing his back. The result was an injury to the back, and the breaking of several ribs. The injury to the ribs was in course of time recovered from; he states that he still suffers from and is disabled by the injury to the back.
"On examining the back, especially in the erect position, there is a marked double curvature of the lower portion of the spine. There is also a depression of the bone on the left side of the spine, corresponding to a prominence on the right side, and indicating some separation of the bones from each other. That there has been displacement of the bones due to a fracture dislocation is shown by a clear X-ray photograph taken by Dr. G. B. Morgan. There is no ground for thinking that the injury and the results thus disclosed have been clue to any other cause than the fall of stone in July, 1903.
"It is probable, in my opinion, that the displacement of the bones was not at first so marked as now, on account of the long continued three months' maintenance of the recumbent position, but that it has in course of time become more pronounced since he began to move about.
"With regard to applicant's ability to do light work, I am of opinion that the present condition of the back disables him for any work involving prolonged standing or stooping or walking, and that he is disabled for any light work.
"(Signed) GEORGE H. HUME."
The Committee awarded full compensation to be resumed as from September 9th, 1918, and the two solicitors to meet the agent of the colliery on the question of back money.
From the introduction to the volume:
There is one case that was considered by the Committee that calls for especial mention. A man named Wittrance Cope, employed at Houghton Colliery as a timber drawer, happened a serious accident in July, 1903, by a fall of stone. Between the above date and 1905 he was before several Medical Referees who gave varying decisions. Finally he was sent to Dr. Hume, a prominent physician in Newcastle at that time. He reported that Cope had entirely recovered from the accident, and on the strength of such report, Cope's money was stopped, and he has not received a penny compensation since.
A few weeks ago Cope was examined by Dr. Morison, of Sunderland, who put him under X-ray, and discovered some displacement of bones linked to his spine. We brought the case before the September meeting of the Committee and asked to have it re-opened. By law we had no authority to make such a claim, as the decisions of the Committee are as equally binding as those of a County Court, and had we been doing our work through the agency of the County Court there were no means by which we could have re-opened the case. The Committee agreed to have the man again examined by Dr. Hume, who retired from practice many years ago, and is now living in Bournemouth. The result of the examination is set out in the report, and we are glad to say that the man's compensation has been resumed as from September 9th, 1918.
Before the Owners would agree to the case being re-opened we had to give an assurance that we would not ask for back money. Had we not given this undertaking they would undoubtedly have refused our request.
However, after some discussion at our last meeting, the two Solicitors were instructed to see the Agent of the Lambton and Hetton Collieries (Owners of Houghton Colliery) for the purpose of placing the whole facts before him with a view to obtaining some back money.
If ever a man suffered a gross injustice at the hands of fellow mortal, Cope has. He has been deprived of his compensation for 13 years, and has had to bring up his family practically on the Parish. The effect upon a man's general health in having to live under such a great injustice must have been enormous, but to witness his family living under straitened circumstances as compared to what he might have done for them under normal circumstances, and to be further deprived of any little assistance he was legally entitled to must have robbed him of any little pleasure he might obtain in life.
We hope a reasonable offer will be made and end an unfortunate case.
Yours truly,
James Robson.
November, 1918.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/1, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol I covering Sep 1918-Dec 1919
| Arbitration Committee — 2nd December 1918 | |
Committee Meeting
Held on December 2nd 1918
2726. Houghton. Wittrance Cope.
This case was fully explained in detail in the October circular when I stated that in addition to the Committee awarding Cope full compensation as from September 9th, 1918, the two solicitors had to meet the representative of the owners of the colliery, on the question of back money. After several meetings at which various offers and counter-offers were made, it has been agreed to end the question of back money by payment of a lump sum of £300, and this Cope and the Lodge have agreed to accept.
Yours faithfully,
James Robson.
January 15th, 1919.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/1, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol I covering Sep 1918-Dec 1919
| Sources | |
| Researchers | |
If you are researching Wittrance Cope (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||