|
Thomas Brett
Durham Miners' Association
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Three years' earnings of deceased | £282 | 15 | 8 |
| House and coals | 39 | 0 | 0 |
| £321 | 15 | 0 |
Claim made by the widow.
On June 4th, 1917, the Committee failed to agree, and we decided to take the case to court, and on October 22nd the case was heard before His Honour Judge Bonsey, and after a hearing which lasted five hours he found as a fact that deceased died as the result of carbon monoxide poisoning contracted in the mine, but reserved his decision on the question as to whether or not this constituted an accident within the meaning of the Workmen's Compensation Act. On November 19th he gave his decision in our favour. The following is the judgment :—
The applicant in this case is the widow of a man named Thomas Brett, who was a hewer at the respondent's Colliery.
On the 2nd of April of this year Brett went to work in apparently good health. He was taken ill about midday and had to discontinue his work for a time and to sit down. He complained of feeling ill. He went home in the evening and then he was described by his wife as being very ill, unable to take his food and he suffered from sickness. Next day he saw his doctor and the doctor immediately detected symptoms of carbon monoxide gas poisoning, and for this he treated him. The man remained at home and some short time after pneumonia supervened and he died on the 17th of April.
Respondents resisted the claim really on two grounds. One ground that the man did not die from carbon monoxide poisoning as alleged in the application, and the second ground was that if he did, death was not the result of an accident within the meaning of the Act of Parliament.
Now the place where Brett was hewing coal was in my opinion badly ventilated. There was evidence that the outlet of air was impeded if not entirely blocked by a fall of stone. A plan was produced, and on it was marked a blue line which showed the intake of the air and a red line showing the outlet of the air, and then there was a disconnecting portion of the red line which showed where there had been this fall of stone which impeded the free exit of the air, and it was in close proximity to this point that Brett was working.
As to the ventilation, a fortnight before the men's inspector and a sub-manager had inspected the place and had signed a report that the ventilation was bad. That was the condition of the place where the man was working.
Another matter to consider is this, that blasting operations took place in this seam about every other day, as I understand for the purpose of clearing space for the tubs.
The 2nd of April was a Monday, and on the previous Saturday there had been blasting in the vicinity of the spot where Brett was working.
This carbon monoxide gas is generated in one way by the explosion of ordinary black powder, and it is produced in varying quantities. I think it was said by one witness that it varied between 7 and 33 per cent of the volume of gas produced by an explosion of an ordinary charge of black powder. A very small quantity of this gas, I mean a very small quantity indeed, is dangerous to life, but under ordinary circumstances there is no danger because in a properly ventilated place where there is a free current of air 'the gas is either carried away or is so diluted that no danger existed or was anticipated from it at all. In fact this gas, as I understand the evidence, is produced by any burning where there is insufficient oxygen, and under ordinary conditions there need be no fear of any injury because in a properly ventilated place it is carried away or becomes diluted far below any danger point.
I have no doubt in my own mind that this man did die from carbon monoxide gas poisoning, and in fact at the close of, I think it was the applicant's case, after Dr. McCullagh had been called that Mr Meynell stated that he could not, in view of the evidence given, contend that the man did not die from carbon monoxide gas poisoning.
Of course the immediate cause of death was pneumonia, but really the primary cause of death was poisoning by this gas.
Therefore I find as a fact in the first place that the man did die from carbon monoxide gas poisoning. What I think occurred was this. Blasting operations had been carried on about midday on the Saturday, and in all probability had produced a considerable amount of carbon monoxide gas.
As we were told by witnesses, or at any rate by one witness, an Analytical Chemist, who was well qualified to speak on the subject, that it was not a constant factor, but varied much from 7 to 33 per cent. What the percentage was on this particular occasion one could not say, but seeing that the gas was present as it was forty-eight hours after, on the Monday, I think there must have been a considerable quantity generated by the explosion of powder on the Saturday.
Then I am also of opinion that in consequence of the bad and insufficient ventilation, that is to say, the current of air being impeded in the outlet, this gas hung about and was there in a quantity which was dangerous to life on the Monday when Brett was working. He inhaled some of this gas which poisoned him, and it was from that he died on the 17th of April.
Now it was said that even so there was no accident within the meaning of the Act.
Two cases chiefly relied on by Mr Meynell for the respondents were the case Broderick v. London County Council and the case of Eke v. Hart Dyke. The London County Council case was where a man contracted disease or poisoning from sewer gas, and Eke v. Hart Dyke was somewhat similar.
Now these cases, I think are clearly distinguishable from the present case. In Eke v. Hart Dyke the Master of the Rolls stated that the decision of Broderick and the London County Council was based shortly upon this ground, namely, that there the element of accident was wanting, and I should think the same might be said with regard to the case of Eke v. Hart Dyke, although I think the main point there was that there was no time or circumstance or place which could be fixed upon and which is necessary in order that you may come within the Provisions of the Act. At any rate my view of those cases is that there was an entire absence of any element of accident. The meaning of the word accident in the Act of Parliament has been laid down by the Highest Authority in the House of Lords in more cases than one, but it seems to be the leading case that may be taken is Fenton and Thornby in 1903, and there is another case of importance, and that is Ismay and Williamson 1908 Appeal Case in the House of Lords. Without referring to the very words I think it may be stated that an accident means an unexpected or unlooked for mishap, an untoward event, and that I take it to be the definition in Fenton and Thornby and repeated in Ismay and Williamson. Lord Loreburn approved of that definition, and stated that they must look at the matter broadly without drawing very subtle distinctions, and I think he used the expression "unusual result from a known cause." At any rate I think this is a case where one could form a very clear idea of what the meaning of the word accident was in the Act of Parliament. We must use the word in its ordinary sense.
I have to apply that definition to the facts of this particular case, and I am assisted very much by the case of Kelly and Anchenlee Coal Company 4 Butterworth 419. That was a Scotch case, but I know of no decision in the English Courts which is inconsistent with it at all. That was a case where the facts were very much like in this case. It was a case of monoxide poisoning by carbon monoxide gas, and the decision in favour of the applicant was confirmed in the Court of Sessions in Scotland, and the ground upon which it was decided was that carbon monoxide was not a constant element in the production of combustion in such proportions as to be vital to life, and that its unexplained presence in such proportion as on the occasion in question was in the ordinary sense of the word an accident. That I take the ground for the decision to be in that case that the production of this gas was an uncertain quantity within limits, and that being so there arose such elements of accident as to bring it within the meaning of the Act.
I think that may be said in regard to those cases, and it could be applied to the facts in this case. I even think the facts in this case are stronger on the question of there being an element of accident.
I start with the fact that under ordinary circumstances where there has been an explosion of powder as in this case there is no reason to anticipate any danger whatever, and therefore that in itself seems to me to point to the fact that there must have been something abnormal and accidental in what happened in the present case. The fact that the ventilation was so imperfect as to impede the outlet of the air and so prevent the gas being carried away or diluted so as to be free from any danger to life, that in itself is an accidental circumstance, and therefore combining the two, that is to say, considering that under normal circumstances no danger need be anticipated or looked for, and that the gas produced is in such varying quantity and that the freedom from injury depended upon the ventilation of the place where the explosion took place, and that at this place the ventilation was impeded and imperfect, to my mind there is ample evidence of an accident in the ordinary sense of the word in the facts of this particular case.
Therefore in my opinion the whole case is this, that the man died from carbon monoxide poisoning in consequence of inhaling this poisonous gas while at work at the coal face, and I think the circumstances under which he inhaled it showed it was there in a dangerous quantity and that it was accidental.
I think that the man's death did result from an accident within the meaning of the Act, and I give judgment for the applicant. I believe there is no doubt as to the amount.
MR HEATH (for the applicant): The amount agreed is £300 without costs.
HIS HONOUR: I shall make an award for that sum £300 without costs.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/1/6/43, D.M.A. Minutes, Circulars etc. for 1918 (two volumes: covers Jan-Jun, Jul-Dec)
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||