|
Thomas Stones
Durham Miners' Association
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Three years' earnings on this average | £474 | 10 | 0 |
| Coals | 15 | 12 | 0 |
| £490 | 2 | 0 |
Claim made by the widow.
Adjourned for further medical evidence.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/1/6/43, D.M.A. Minutes, Circulars etc. for 1918 (two volumes: covers Jan-Jun, Jul-Dec)
| Arbitration Committee — 8th April 1918 | |
Committee Meeting
Held on April 8th 1918
County Court Case.
905. North Hetton. Thomas Stones, 33, hewer.
Was found dead in his working place on October 18th, 1917. The Coroner's jury brought in a verdict that deceased's death arose from syncope due to rupture of the heart accelerated by the exertions of his employment in the Hazard Pit on the day of his death.
Deceased left a widow aged 36. one son aged 13. and a daughter aged 9, wholly dependent.
He had been employed since July, 1915, and had earned on an average £3/0/10 per week.
| Three years' earnings on this average | £474 | 10 | 0 |
| Coals | 15 | 12 | 0 |
| £490 | 2 | 0 |
Claim made by the widow
This case was before the Arbitration Committee on December 10th, 1917, when it was adjourned and ultimately the Committee failed to agree as the owners contended that no accident within the meaning of the Act had occurred to deceased and therefore they were not liable to pay compensation. Whilst we might agree that no accident in the ordinary sense of the term did occur, we felt that deceased's death was accelerated by exertion at work and therefore even if such exertion did not come within the term accident, it was sufficient for us if we could prove it had accelerated death. We therefore took the matter to the Durham County Court, and the case was tried there before His Honour Judge Bonsey on March 25th. ~. Our solicitor, Mr. Heath, stated the case for our side in such a way that there seemed no doubt as to what decision should he given, but the Judge thought it was one bristling with various points of the Law and would like to take time to consider his judgment. At the Court held on Monday. April 22nd, Judge Bonsey gave the following judgment, which you will see is in our favour and is a decision we have every reason to be pleased with.
"The Applicant in this case was the widow of Thomas Stones, who was a hewer at the respondent's colliery and who died on the 18th of October last.
It appeared that Stones, who was apparently a healthy man from all outside appearances and an active man of thirty-three years of age, went down the pit about four o'clock in the morning of the 18th October. He worked at hewing and loading of tubs until half-past eight o'clock, when he was last seen alive by a putter named Joseph Alderson. Alderson had been taking his tubs away, and at half-past eight he took away a loaded tub and left Stones in the act of loading another tub. When Alderson came back ten minutes after Stones was lying on the ground on his back near the tub. He was dead. A post mortem examination was held and that disclosed the cause of death as being a ruptured heart, and it was stated by one of the doctors that this was a rather rare occurrence. The muscular walls of the heart had become weakened by the infiltration of fat and was in such a condition that if he was subjected to any considerable strain then in all probability the rupture would take place, causing instant death.
According to the evidence of Dr Sutherland the walls of the heart were not absolutely degenerate, but had become weakened by an infiltration of fat. There was some muscular substance left and there was a distinct tear in the muscles and a clear rupture.
Upon those stated facts the question arose as to whether the accident arose out of the man's employment. There was no question of it being in the course of employment or no question of it being an accident within the meaning of the Act. The only question was whether it arose out of the employment.
Now the law applicable to a ease of that kind is to be found in Clover Clayton & Hughes, and the question I have to ask myself in the language of Lord Loreburn is, "Did he die from the disease alone or from the disease and employment taken together and looking at it broadly. Looking at it broadly, I say, and free from over nice conjectures, was it the disease that did it or did the work he was doing help in any material degree."
If the man had been seen to fall down dead while he was actually shovelling coal into the tub I do not suppose Mr Maynell, who appeared for the respondent, would have resisted the claim. I understand his argument to be inasmuch as no one saw the man at the moment death actually took place there was no evidence to justify my answering the question which I have just read from the judgment of Lord Loreburn in the affirmative. He (Mr Maynell) contended that it was just as probable that the man died from disease alone as it was that he died from the disease and the employment together, and he relied upon two cases. Barnabas and Birsham Colliery Co., and another more recent case. Both of these cases I have considered, and to my mind they were clearly distinguishable. In these cases the evidence was that the condition of the man was such that he might die at any moment without any strain at all, and just as probably he died from the disease and not from any additional strain as that he died from the employment in which he was engaged.
But I really do not think there is much advantage in endeavouring to find cases in the books exactly on all fours with the case under consideration when you have a principle clearly defined. What you have to do is to apply that principle to the facts of a particular case.
But if I had to find a case, or if it was necessary to find a case, which I do not think it is at all, exactly to meet the circumstances of the present case, there is one to which I was not referred at the hearing, and that is the case re Hickman & Butterworth, page 77. In that case a workman was loading sacks on a truck, and then it was his duty when he had loaded the sacks to push the truck along some rails. While he was having a rest from his work he fell senseless and died soon after. A post mortem examination showed that the heart was in a weak condition, and the medical evidence was that the heart would not have failed at that moment, probably would not have failed at that moment if it had not been subject to some strain. The County Court Judge found in favour of the Applicant and the Court of Appeal upheld that finding.
Apart from any decided case, and believing the principle laid down in Clover Clayton & Hughes, I am clearly of opinion that in this case Applicant is entitled to succeed. In my opinion the condition of this man's heart, although the walls were very much weakened, was not such that death would have ensued at that time unless he had been subjected to some considerable strain.
Dr Sutherland was very clear upon that point. and further he added that the work which the man was engaged upon, that is, shovelling coal into a tub, would be sufficient to cause the strain and produce the rupture.
While it is not necessary that there should be direct evidence, I am entitled to draw a reasonable inference from established facts. The facts are that this man's heart, as I have just said, was in a condition that a rupture would occur if he was subjected to some considerable strain, and I do not think it was in the condition that he would have been likely to die at that time if he had been doing nothing, or, as said in some cases, if he had been in a sleep. Dr Morgan did not take quite the same view as Dr Sutherland, but at the same time he said that it was quite possible that the work the man was doing contributed to death at that moment.
Thus you have the case in this way. The man is seen at half-past eight engaged in work which was sufficient to cause the strain and to produce a rupture of the heart, from which he died, and is found ten minutes after dead and his heart ruptured.
The inference I draw is that the work did contribute or was one cause which lead to the rupture of the heart, and secondly that his death occurred at that moment not from the disease alone, but from the disease and the work with which he was engaged at the time.
It is impossible to say, of course, whether he was actually in the act of putting a shovelful of coal into the tub when he fell or whether a few seconds after he fell he died. At any rate there is only an interval of ten minutes from the time when he was seen working to the time he was found dead.
I think the only reasonable inference to draw from these facts as having regard to the evidence of Dr Sutherland, particularly as to the condition of the man's heart, and which I accept as being correct, is that the heart would not have ruptured at that moment unless subjected to some strain. I think it is clear that the accident arose out of the man's employment, and as the amount is not disputed there will be an award for £300."
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/1/6/43, D.M.A. Minutes, Circulars etc. for 1918 (two volumes: covers Jan-Jun, Jul-Dec)
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||