|
George Foster
Durham Miners' Association
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| New Monckton Collieries & Keeling | 1911 | A. C. 648 |
| Lee & Owners of s.s. Bessie | 1912 I | K. B. 83 |
| Potts or Young v. | 1913 | A. C. 531 |
He further argued that the compensation should be the full amount of £300, citing in support certain well-known passages in the speeches of Lord Loreburn, L.C., Lord MacNaughton and Lord Shaw in Hodgson v. West Stanley Colliery, 1910 A.C. 229, to the effect that if the Arbitrator thinks £300 reasonable and proportionate to the injury the dependent has suffered in case of partial dependency it is his duty to award that amount.
In reply Mr Hedley argued that the Applicant could and did earn her own living, that there was no presumption of dependency because no liability of the husband to support her, that the statute confines the Arbitrator to compensation, "reasonable and proportionate to the injury," to the dependent (grief and pain not being subjects of compensation under the Act), and that here she had sustained no injury. She is no worse off now, the learned Counsel said, than she was while her husband was alive, while the fact that she has been able to earn sufficient to support herself during the past four years shows that she is capable of doing so in the future.
I am of opinion that the Applicant is entitled to succeed and that she was partially dependent. What she has lost by the accident is her permanent support, her breadwinner. That she has been able for a period which is now ending to earn enough to support herself is an accident of the times. To bold that a woman who has been taking a man's place during the war is thereby deprived of her rights as a dependent under the Act might have very serious and far reaching consequences. Moreover, I think it is not the law. Both in the New Monckton & Potts cases cited above, the necessity for an Arbitrator to take into account the legal liability of a husband to support his wife is emphasised by their lordships. Thus Lord Atkinson in the New Monckton case said :— "It by no means follows, however, that there is no presumption of law that a wife is dependent upon her husband's earnings merely because of his obligation to maintain her, this legal obligation is to be ignored in deciding the fact of her dependency. On the contrary, the existence of the obligation, the probability that it will be discharged, either voluntarily or under compulsion, the probability that the wife will ever enforce her right if the obligation be not discharged voluntarily are all matters properly to be considered by the Arbitrator in determining the question of fact, whether or not the wife at the time of her husband's injury looked to his earnings for her maintenance and support in whole or in part: it is one of the many elements to be taken into account," and in Pott's case Lord Haldane, L.C., said: "The true question in the present case" (the wife had endeavoured with small success to enforce her legal rights against her husband) "is in my opinion whether there was as one of the facts to be taken into account an effective and valuable legal right. If there was such a right, and there was no legal difficulty in the way of enforcing it, then the mere fact that want of opportunity to resort to it, which might have proved only temporary, had reduced the mother and children for the time being to charity, cannot effect the conclusion that by the father's death they lost something on which they could depend."
Applying the principle of these passages to the facts of the present case, I think the Applicant has lost the right to support by her husband, on which alone she could rely for her maintenance after a period which, on the facts, must be near at hand. I think, therefore, she was partially dependent on her husband's earnings. The question of the amount of compensation is more difficult. The practical difference between total dependency and the partial dependency of the Applicant seems to me on the facts of this case to be little. Taking into account as well as I can all the facts, and having in mind the injunctions given to Arbitrators by the House of Lords in Hodgson's case, I award £280 "to be reasonable and proportionate to the injury" to the Applicant.
Award for £280. Stay for a month.
Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/1, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol I covering Sep 1918-Dec 1919
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||