logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Donate to support the Museum
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

  Individual Details   Individual Details  
 


Arthur William Evans

Age:   64
Died:   25th Oct 1918
Accident:   25th Oct 1918
Year Born:   abt. 1854
Colliery:   Wheatley Hill
Company:   Weardale Steel, Coal and Coke Co., Ltd.
Occupation:   Shifter
Notes:  
"accidently killed through being caught by a travelling rope whilst following his employment"
Buried:   [not known]

Arbitration Committee — 2nd December 1918

Durham Miners' Association
Compensation Committee

Committee Meeting
Held on December 2nd 1918

1076. Wheatley Hill. Arthur Evans, 64, shifter.

Died on October 25th, 1918, from shock following injuries to his head and arm accidentally caused by being crushed between the steel tail rope of a set of tubs and a sheave. It was alleged deceased should not have travelled along the road be did, and it was suggested that he committed a breach of the regulations.

Deceased was employed at light work, and was in receipt of a reduced rate of 11d. per week at the date of death in respect of an accident in the pit on December 9th, 1913.

Deceased left a widow, aged 70, wholly dependent.

Three years' earnings of deceased, including rent allowance  £329 16 2
Coals  15 12 0
  £345 8 2

Claim made by the widow.

It was stated by the other side that notice boards were at each end of the road deceased had travelled prohibiting the use of such road, and that the manager had made a proper travelling way which was recognised by the workmen as being the only one to be used by the workmen. The case is very slender in view of the evidence submitted, but our side thought they would like time to go further into the matter, and with that purpose in view the Committee failed to agree.

Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/1, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol I covering Sep 1918-Dec 1919


Arbitration Committee — 6th January 1919

Durham Miners' Association
Compensation Committee

Committee Meeting
Held on January 6th 1919

County Court Cases

1076. Wheatley Hill. Arthur Evans, 66, shifter.

Died on October 25th, 1918, from shock following injuries to his head, accidentally caused by being crushed between a tail rope and a sheave. Deceased was a shifter and in receipt of light work rate, and left a widow, aged 70, wholly dependent. The claim was one for £300, as the three years' earnings, together with rent and coals, amounted to £345/8/2.

At the Arbitration Committee held on December 2nd, the Committee failed to agree, and our side of the Committee decided to take the case to the County Court. The facts are that on October 25th, 1918, deceased was on his road outbye. About 30 yards from his working place there was a landing at which point he came to a backbye drift that the manager had driven for a matter of 400 yards, on which the workmen could travel instead of travelling on the engine plane. It must be said that this travelling way was used by the workmen, and only officials and wagonwaymen were officially allowed on the engine plane, and at each side of the engine plane where it was joined with the travelling way was a notice board with "No Road" on. On the day of the accident deceased, when he got to the notice board, instead of travelling outbye by the travelling road, went straight on and had only gone a few yards in the landing when he was caught somehow by the tail rope of the set and a sheave, and received fatal injuries. The case was heard at Durham County Court before Judge Bonsey on January 21st.

The case, we must admit, was looked upon by our side as one in which the chance of success was very remote owing to the decisions that have already been given in the Appeal Court and in the House of Lords on cases almost identical. A case that is cited regularly is one of Barnes v. the Nunnery Collieries. This was a case where a lad, employed at a pit in Yorkshire, was killed whilst riding inbye on a tub. It arose in the course of Barnes' employment to go in and outbye, but it was held that it did not arise out of his employment to ride inbye contrary to regulations, and on that ground the House of Lords decided that in taking an added risk by riding inbye instead of walking, deceased had taken a risk that was not incidental to and did not arise out of his employment, and therefore the Serious and Wilful Misconduct clause of the Act did not arise. I need not point out that if a workman is guilty of serious and wilful misconduct whilst injured by an accident arising out of and in the course of his employment, and such accident causes permanent or fatal injuries, compensation is payable, but there have been so many cases decided that the Serious and Wilful Misconduct clause has almost been eliminated from the Act.

In the case of Evans, Mr Heath placed the manager of the colliery in the witness box, who, in evidence, stated that the backbye drift was driven for the men to travel on so as to obviate travelling upon the engine plane, which at this particular stretch had a gradient of four inches to the yard, with its attendant risks of meeting with injuries that may be received owing to mishaps to the set. Therefore you will see that if deceased, when disobeying, had continued by the main engine plane and had been knocked down by the set, he would then have been taking an added risk which was not incidental to his employment, and we could not have established our claim to compensation. At the hearing of the case Mr Heath very ably pointed out, and I think quite properly, that the case was distinct from Barnes v. the Nunnery Collieries. As I said before Barnes was employed to walk inbye, but he chose to ride inbye. In our case Evans was employed to walk outbye, and was walking outbye when the accident occurred, and although he had reached the portion of the engine plane where he would have been running an additional risk, it was not an accident that arose by running such a risk, and consequently it was argued at great length by Mr Heath that it was a case which clearly came under the Serious and Wilful Misconduct clause, and that compensation should be awarded to the widow. The Judge reserved his judgment, and will give it at the next sitting of the County Court.

Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/1, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol I covering Sep 1918-Dec 1919


Arbitration Committee — 3rd March 1919

Durham Miners' Association
Compensation Committee

Committee Meeting
Held on March 3rd 1919

County Court Cases

Wheatley Hill. Evans.

In the January report I stated the Judge would give him judgment at the next sitting of the Court. Owing to illness he has not been able to attend Court, and judgment has consequently not yet been given.

Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/1, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol I covering Sep 1918-Dec 1919


Arbitration Committee — 7th July 1919

Durham Miners' Association
Compensation Committee

Committee Meeting
Held on July 7th 1919

County Court Cases

Wheatley Hill. Arthur Evans.

In the January circular this case is set out and, as stated by me, it was heard before Judge Bonsey at Durham County Court on January 21st, after a very long hearing, in which Mr Heath put up an exceedingly strong case. It lasted the whole of the day, and ultimately Judge Bonsey reserved his judgment. Unfortunately he never sat in Court again, and has since died. Consequently, the case was re-tried before Judge Bonsey's successor (Judge Moore) and appended is his decision.

JUDGMENT

The case was originally heard before my predecessor, the late Judge Bonsey, who reserved his decision, but unfortunately died before he could deliver judgment. The case was accordingly re-heard before me on the 23rd June, 1919.

The facts are not in dispute and the only question is whether on those facts the Applicant is entitled to be awarded compensation under the Workmen's Compensation Act.

The Applicant is the widow of Arthur Evans, a miner in the employ of the Respondents, who met his death by an accident on the 25th October, 1918.

On the day in question the deceased, having finished his work, was making his way from his working place to the shaft bottom for the purpose of returning to the surface. Instead of proceeding by the recognised road or track, which is coloured pink in the plan that has been put in, he took a short cut and went by that portion of the main haulage plane which is left uncoloured in the said plait In so doing he was knowingly committing a breach of one of the rules of the Colliery, made with the object of securing the safety of the men employed there. This rule is not one of those rules, such as one sometimes comes across, which are made simply for the sake of form and are in practice habitually disregarded by the men to the knowledge of the management; but is a rule which is strictly enforced. Fines are exacted for its infringement, and a notice-board with the words "No road" upon it is conspicuously exhibited at either end of the portion of the track which is prohibited.

The deceased was perfectly well aware of the rule, and it is indeed admitted that in using the prohibited portion of the track he was guilty of serious and wilful misconduct; although, as death has ensued, that fact appears only to be material so far as it may bear on the question whether the man was acting in the course of his employment at the time when the accident occurred.

The sole reason for the prohibition is that the gradient of this portion of the haulage plane is very steep, being as much as 1 in 9, and consequently the safety of any foot passenger walking along it would be seriously imperilled in the event of the breaking of any of the couplings of the line of tubs which might at the time be travelling along it.

No one seems actually to have witnessed the accident, but, from the position in which the deceased's body was found, it appears that he must have stumbled or tripped over the running-rope and, his limbs having become entangled with it, his body was drawn in and jambed between the running-rope and one of the "holding-down" sheaves which are used for keeping the rope in position. The injuries which he thus received were so severe that he died the same

The accident was not of a kind which was anticipated by the management, nor was it one against which the rule prohibiting the use of that portion of the track was intended to guard; and it was said that, had it not been for the steepness of the gradient, the men would have been permitted to use that portion in the same manner as they were permitted to use the portion which is coloured pink in the plain.

It appears, moreover, that the accident was one which might have occurred on the permitted portion of the track, since there was a similar "holding-down" sheave on such permitted portion, and it is conceivable that a man might trip at the point where such other sheave is situated and get entangled in a similar way to that in which the deceased man became entangled on the occasion in question.

In these circumstances the question which I have to decide is whether the accident arose "out of and in the course of" the deceased's employment.

I have been referred to a larger number of cases bearing on this point. None of them appear to be quite on all fours so far as the facts are concerned, but I think that the principles which ought to guide me are to be found in the speeches delivered in the House of Lords in the cases of Barnes v. Nunnery Colliery Co. (1912 A.C. 44), and Plumb v. Cobden Flour Mills (1914 A.C. 62). Now it is to be observed that in the present case, not only was the deceased at the time of the accident on what may be called "forbidden territory," but that he had gone there for no purpose connected with the work which he was engaged to perform — that is to say, he had not gone there for the purpose of fetching a tool to enable him to carry on his work, or to do any act which constituted part of the work itself or was intended by him to further the performance of the tasks allotted to him. His sole object was to leave his work more expeditiously than he would have been able to. do if he had obeyed the rules.

Further — and this is the point to which I attach most importance — in using the prohibited portion of the track, the deceased was undertaking a risk which his contract of service did not contemplate. Indeed, he was doing a thing which, in the words of Lord Loreburn, "was put outside the range of his service by a genuine prohibition" (1912 A.C. at p. 47; see Lord Dunedin's reference to this passage in Plumb's case, 1914, A.C. at p. 69). In other words "he lost his life through a new and added peril to which by his own conduct he exposed himself, not through any peril which his contract of service directly or indirectly involved or at all obliged him to encounter" (see per Lord Atkinson in Barnes' case, 1914, A.C. at p. 50).

In these circumstances I am of opinion that, upon the authorities above referred to, it is not open to me to find that the accident arose "out of and in course of" deceased's employment. It was suggested in the course of argument that, although the deceased by breaking the rule in question was incurring a risk which was not covered by his contract of service, that fact is immaterial, because death did not result from the particular peril which the rule was intended to guard against, but from a cause which might equally have operated on the permitted portion of the track. I cannot agree with that contention. The accident occurred whilst the man was on forbidden ground, and in my opinion, so long as he was there, he was acting outside the scope of his employment. The claim cannot succeed unless the accident arose in the course of his employment, and if it did not it appears to be immaterial how it occurred.

The Applicant is therefore, in my opinion, not entitled to any compensation under the Act.

(Signed) Robert Ernest Moore,

Judge.

21st July, 1919.

Source: NEEMARC - Ref: NUMDA/6/1/1/1, Reports of the Compensation Department, Vol I covering Sep 1918-Dec 1919

 

Return Return   Return Return to Top

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 16 Feb 2023

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print