1624. Bowden Close. Thomas Birbeck, 65, bargain man.
Died on 22nd October, 1922, as the result, it is alleged, of injuries received on 22nd October, 1914, when he had his thigh broken and his back injured.
A post-mortem examination was held, and Dr. McCullagh reported as follows :—
"A large section of the spinal cord was removed — this has been sent to the Pathologist, Newcastle, for microscopic examination. There was no sign of dislocation or old fracture of the Vertebrae. The abdominal organs were all healthy — there was no malignant growth in the abdomen.
OPINION. — All were agreed that death was due to Spinal Paralsis, i.e., a transverse Myelitis of the chord. The microscopic examination will let us know the actual pathological lesion.
The question arises — how far was the injury in 1914, responsible for the Spinal Paralysis?
Very little is known as to the exact cause of these cases of Paralysis. All authorities give previous accident or injuries as contributory causes ; also pain, suffering, exposure, are given as contributory causes.
In my opinion (1) death was due to Paralysis. (2) The accident in 1914, was probably a contributory cause.
Up to the time of the accident he was a strong healthy man with a large healthy family. No history of Syphilis can be elicited."
The Pathologist's report stated :—
"The specimen received shows on histological examination no tissue resembling dorsal chord. The sections are evidently those of cauda equina. In the sections there is chronic fifrotic thickening of the meninges and foci of calcification, all of which mat possibly be the result of previous haemorrhage. There is no evidence of tumour or tubercle. The blood vessels present contain numerous polymorph leucocytes."
Deceased left a widow, aged 51, wholly dependent.
Prior to the accident Birbeck had been employed for 111 weeks, and had earned on an average, including rent allowance, £2/7/5 per week.
| | £ | s. | d. |
| Three years' earnings on this average, including rent allowance | 369 | 17 | 0 |
| Coals | 15 | 12 | 9 |
| |
|
| | £385 | 0 | 0 |
Claim made by the widow.
Claim disallowed
Source: Durham Miners' Association, Compensation Department, Minutes of Arbitration Committee - January 1923 to December 1924. Vol VI. Kindly provided by Barry J. Simpson.