|
John Thomas Gawne
Accident at Great Laxey Mine. About 11.30 a.m., on the 10th December, 1904, four miners named Robert Wade (26), John Thomas Gawne (40), John Thomas Quayle (40), and Harry Lewis Gelling (18), lost their lives by a scaffold giving way at the 190-fathom level and they were precipitated into water below. Medical evidence was given at the inquest to the effect that Robert Wade died from fracture of the base of the skull, the other three from drowning. Great Laxey Mine is owned by Great Laxey, Limited; it is situated about the centre of the East Coast of the Isle of Man, and about a mile from the shore. A Board of Directors, of whom Mr. F. J. Robertshaw is Chairman, controls the affairs of the Company; Captain Roberts, the resident manager, only assumed office in February, 1904, before which date he was unacquainted with the mine. Captain Killip is the under captain and John Bateman is underground foreman, both of whom had been many years at the mine. The vein, which yields lead and zinc ore, and occasionally copper ore, runs north and south and has an easterly hade of about 15 degrees. It has been followed to a depth of 302 fathoms below the adit on the underlay, and for a considerable distance to the north and south. In October, 1901, a feeder of water, amounting to 170 gallons per minute, was tapped in driving north in the 255-fathom level ; attempts to dam it back were not successful, and as the existing pumping machinery (actuated by the celebrated Great Wheel) was not able to cope with this additional feeder, the mine gradually filled with water up to about the 110-fathom level, which height was attained in about two years, the 190-fathom level being submerged in July, 1902. In September, 1903, new machinery was installed and a commencement made to pump out the water, and in December last the 190-fathom level was reached. As the water fell and access was gained to the lower levels, the old timber, ladders, &c., were examined and renewed where necessary, but it was stated that although all the timber was waterlogged and heavier than water, much of it was sound and was allowed to remain in position. It was stated that the water had a preservative effect on the timber, and that as the place where the accident occurred was in fresh air the timber there did not rot as in some other parts of the mine. The cheeks of the vein are hard slate rock, and comparatively few falls were observed. When the 190-fathom level was reached it was arranged to repair the part of it that lay between two shafts known as the Engine and Welsh shafts, in order that a new sinking pump could be taken along it. Prior to the accident and since the water had been removed the level had not been examined by Captains Roberts and Killip, but John Bateman had examined it and tested the wood with an iron bar. The sectional plan of the mine showed the sole of the 190-fathom level as solid ground at the place of the accident, whereas commencing 80 feet from the Engine shaft an underhand stope had been carried down several fathoms and for some distance along the level, and had been bridged across so as to preserve the use of the level as a travelling way. This inaccuracy of the section cannot be said to have had any direct bearing on the accident as the actual condition of the level was well known to both Captain Killip and John Bateman, and probably to the deceased men, before it was reached, and when reached was apparent at once. It is indeed possible that had the section been accurate, Captain Roberts' attention might have been called to the existence of the scaffolding and this might have suggested some extra precautions to him. In accordance with instructions he had received the day before the accident from Captain Roberts, Captain Killip instructed the deceased men on the day of the accident to descend to the 190-fathom level and ascertain what repairs were necessary in order to make the road between the Engine and Welsh shafts safe to use in conveying the pump. They left the surface about 6 a.m. Wade was the leading man of the party; Gawne, who was on the books as a timberer, and Quayle were both practical miners ; Gelling was a miner's labourer; the party was considered quite competent to do the work it was sent to perform. The vein is about 8 feet wide at the place where the accident occurred, and the scaffolding consisted of beams 8½ inches deep by 5 inches wide, and about 8 feet long, fixed about 3½ feet apart into notches in each cheek of the vein across the excavated ground and covered by planks 8 inches wide and 2 inches deep, nailed to the cross beams. It was stated that this timber had been renewed about 16 years ago. The planking only extended about half way across the vein from the foot wall, the open side having been fenced by a wire rope carried by standards. John Bateman was the last person to see the deceased men alive when he visited them about 9.30 a.m. on the 10th. They then reported that they had examined the scaffolding and found the cross beams, or "sticks" as they are locally termed, all fairly good, except the first one coming from the engine shaft. Bateman then examined the condemned beam along with Wade and Gawne. Gawne went down on his knees and struck it on both sides with an axe and remarked it was "gone a bit." Bateman instructed them to measure it before they left so that it could be replaced by a new one from the surface. Bateman left them about 9.50 a.m. As they had not returned to the surface by 2.30 p.m., Captain Killip became alarmed, and by his instructions some miners descended to the 190-fathom level and he followed. Nothing was seen of the repairing party, and it was observed that the defective beam and the planking over it had disappeared and had no doubt fallen into the water, which was then about 9 feet below, and sunk to the bottom of the stops. The planking which had disappeared consisted (1) of two short planks in line next the footwall, one of them extending from the solid sole of the level to the first cross beam, and the other from the first to the second cross beam, and (2) four long planks, one of which extended from the solid sole to the second cross beam, the other three extending from the solid sole beyond the second cross beam, at which point they had broken. This wood had all sunk, and at the inquest no evidence could be given as to whether the cross beam had broken or slipped out of the hitches. The hitches, in which the missing beam had rested, could be seen and were of the usual type; that on the hanging wall was a hole 2 or 3 inches deep, and on the footwall the hitch had been cut 9 inches deep by 5 inches wide, and there was a ledge of 1½ inches on to which the beam had been driven downwards. There was no appearance of any fall from the cheeks of the vein or from the vein itself, which had been stopped above the beam for a height of about 30 feet. After searching for the men for some time in the level, fears were entertained that they had fallen into the water below, and with an improvised grappling iron the body of Quayle was recovered. Proper grappling irons were sent for, and with them the bodies of Gelling, Gawne, and Wade were recovered in the order named, the last not being got out until December 12th. Gawne's watch had stopped at 11.30 a.m., and this was probably the hour when the accident happened. Wade was dressed in the ordinary fashion in which he worked and travelled about the mine, and had no clothing near which he would have put on before ascending to the surface ; the other three men had waistcoats on, which, it was stated, they would not have worn unless about to leave their work. It was surmised that the party was about to leave the place and that before doing so Wade had been on the missing beam measuring it, the others standing near, when the beam either broke or slipped out of the hitches, Wade falling with it, and that the centre support of the planks having gone they, in turn, broke, and the rest of the party were precipitated into the water. It was stated that finger marks were observed on the footwall as though made by falling men trying to save themselves. The fact of Wade having sustained, according to the medical evidence, a fracture of the skull suggests the idea that something may have fallen from above upon him, but, as already stated, there was no evidence of any such fall. Owing to a break-down of the pumping arrangements, the water was rising at the time of the accident, and has since risen above the 190-fathom level, but by descending the mine on the evening of the 12th December I was able, accompanied by Mr. Leck, to make an inspection of the place. The operation the men were engaged on required the exercise of considerable caution on their part, but I think they were competent, as a party, for the work, and an inspection of the place had been made by John Bateman, an experienced mine official, two or three hours before the accident happened. The beam that fell away, had it been new, would have borne a weight of 9 tons 2 cwt. in its centre before breaking, while the longer planks would have broken under 17 cwts. similarly applied after the centre beam had broken or fallen away. The weight of the four men would not be more than 6 cwt. There is little doubt that the timber was weakened by the lapse of time and by its immersion in water, but notwithstanding this I think it was not unreasonable to suppose it capable of bearing any ordinary weight. Mr. J. S. Gell, High Bailiff of Castletown, opened the inquest on the 13th December, and adjourned it until the 20th December, when I was present, accompanied by Mr. W. Leek. Mr. Hughes-Games, Advocate of Douglas, was present on behalf of the Mining Company. Captains Roberts and Killip, John Bateman, Doctor Shaw, Edward Christian, miner, and Captain W. H. Kitto, of Foxdale Mines, gave evidence. The verdict of the jury was as follows "We find that Quayle, Gawne, and Gelling met their deaths accidentally by drowning, owing to the collapse of the sole of the 190-level in Great Laxey Mines, and that Wade met his death at the same time and place by sustaining a fracture of the skull." Since the inquest the beam that fell away has been recovered and brought to the surface and Mr. Leek examined it on the 29th March last. He found it to be rotten and that it had given way at the end next the footwall ; 2 or 3 inches of its end had been shorn off and allowed it to fall out of the hitch.
If you are researching John Thomas Gawne (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Jan 2023
|
Search |
|
|||