|
Frank Tate
Explosions of fire-damp or coal dust The next explosion, involving the loss of three lives, occurred on the 27th of June in Ferniegare No. 1 pit, Lanarkshire, worked by Messrs. Archd. Russell, Limited. This accident was investigated by the late Mr. Ronaldson, and by Mr. Robert Nelson, H.M. Electrical Inspector of Mines. The deceased men were employed working an electrical coal cutter in a section of the Virtuewell coal, 450 yards from the pit bottom. They descended the pit about 11 a.m., and at 1.30 p.m., after the machine had cut a distance of 43 feet along the longwall face, it was stopped to allow one of the men to lengthen the trailing cable by means of a plug connection between two lengths of cable, when an explosion of fire-damp occurred, killing one man instantly and fatally injuring his two companions. Safety lamps were in use, and those in the possession of the deceased, who were the only persons employed in the vicinity at the time, were subsequently tested and reported to be in good order. Fire-damp appears to have been but seldom seen in the Virtuewell seam ; indeed, the only evidence as to the finding of gas before the day of the explosion was from overman James Rodney, who spoke to the finding of "a little gas" early in the previous month. The fireman, Henry Dunn, appointed to inspect the section before the deceased persons started work on the day of the explosion, reported the workings clear. He did not "chalk the day of the month on the working face" required by the Special Rules, for the reason that he was called upon to act as fireman in an emergency, and it did not occur to him to provide himself with chalk. After the explosion, fire-damp was discovered in the workings. There were seven longwall places numbered 1 to 7 in the section referred to. Number 1 was stripping a down-throw fault. By the time of the accident the machine had cut back from No. 6 to No. 5 road-head (a distance of 43 feet as previously mentioned) and had been stopped to allow the electric trailing cable to be lengthened. After the explosion the current was found off the machine, and the "hauler" rope disconnected. Mr. Nelson along with Mr. Ronaldson visited the colliery on the 1st July and examined the electrical installation in the neighbourhood of the explosion, with special regard to the coal cutting machinery. They found the voltage 420, continuous current. The trailing cable was discovered in bad condition, the leather protection being worn away in parts. The method of extending the trailing cable was by means of disconnecting it from the coal cutter and the insertion of a second length of cable, the joining of the two lengths being made by an ordinary plug connection without any arrangement whatever to guard against the circuit being accidentally broken. The gate end box was not gas-tight, and both the design of the box, and the method of, and the arrangements for lengthening the trailing cable were unsuitable for a safety lamp pit. The fuses were still in the gate end box, showing that the length of cable connected to the gate end box was alive at the time the workman was connecting together the two lengths of trailing cable. As the explosion appears to have happened when the cable was being lengthened, likely the fire-damp, which apparently had accumulated in the workings, became ignited by a spark made in joining the two lengths of trailing cable. There was no evidence forthcoming upon which to base any other theory. A public inquiry was held in the Sheriff Court, Hamilton, on the 29th July, before Sheriff Thomson and a jury. Mr. William Thomson, Procurator Fiscal, was for the Crown, and the late Mr. Ronaldson, along with Mr. Nelson, represented the Home Office. Mr. W. T. Craig for the employers ; Mr. G. C. Macintyre, writer, for the representatives of the deceased, John Adams ; Mr. James C. Allan for the representatives of the deceased, Francis Tate ; and Mr. James C. Pollok for the representatives of the deceased, George Hunter, were also present and took part in the proceedings. Including Mr. Nelson, fourteen witnesses were examined, and after a careful hearing the Sheriff proposed to the jury the following verdict which they adopted :— "The jury find that the deceased, George Hunter, died on the 27th June in No. 1 pit Ferniegare Colliery, Hamilton, belonging to Archibald Russell, Ltd., and that the deceased John Adams died on the 29th June, and the deceased Francis Tate on the 30th June, both in the Royal Infirmary, Glasgow, the death of the three men being due to an explosion of fire-damp in the pit on the 27th June under the following circumstances:— "They had been working an electric coal cutting machine to which a trailing cable was attached. The work had reached a stage when this cable required to be lengthened by the insertion of a coil of fresh cable. The men accordingly proceeded to insert it, and just as they were doing so the explosion took place. In the opinion of the jury a spark from the electric plant ignited the gas and caused the explosion. The jury are of opinion that whether or not the workmen were to blame for manipulating a 'live' cable in the presence of gas — the employers were in fault in respect (1) that the examination by the acting fireman on the morning of the explosion had been perfunctory and insufficient to discover gas, (2) that the electric plant was not suitable for a fiery mine, and (3) that there was an absence of due inspection from time to time of the electric apparatus installed in the pit." Following this verdict the certificated colliery manager, Mr. Andrew Salmond, was charged in the Hamilton Court with contravening Electrical Special Rule 30, in respect that he failed to see that the trailing cable was kept in order but it was decided that it was inadvisable to proceed in respect of the inefficient, and in the circumstances, dangerous method of joining together the two lengths of trailing cable (Electrical Special Rule 33) because the electric plant had been in use in the colliery before the rules governing the use of electricity in mines had been established. With regard to the trailing cable, the Sheriff found that though it was probable that it had been defective before the beginning of the shift during which the accident occurred, the man who was in charge was the person responsible under the Electrical Special Rules and he had been killed by the explosion. As regards the manager the Sheriff found there was no evidence of any neglect on his part, and accordingly he declared the charge not proven. The electrical plant at Ferniegare was installed before the Electrical Special Rules were established. The manager in his evidence at the Public Inquiry stated, that safety lamps were used as a precaution, not because fire-damp had been found, but for the reason that safety lamps were in use in adjoining collieries. The fact of fire-damp having been previously seen in the Ferniegare Virtuewell workings was not, he averred, reported to him. Whether this were so or not if safety lamps were necessary as a precaution it was equally necessary to have the electrical appliances of such design and construction that no part could ignite gas, otherwise it was practically introducing an open light into the workings and to some extent rendering the use of safely lamps abortive.
If you are researching Frank Tate (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 30 Apr 2023
|
Search |
|
|||