| Notes: | Thomas Rees Evans, 25, collier, when working at Waun Llwyd Colliery on the 10th March, 1904, met with a simple fracture of the thigh as the result of a fall of top coal and died on the 27th July, 1905. A post-mortem examination was made in the presence of three doctors, two of whom stated at the inquest that the thigh bone was firmly united although in a faulty condition, that there were no internal complications to account for death, and that death was in no way connected with the accident to the leg. He lost about 1½ stone in weight after the accident, but the doctors agreed that they could only say that death resulted from "natural causes." The coroner in summing up pointed out to the jury that the only proper verdict on the evidence before them would be "death from natural causes," but the jury decided to return a verdict that death was due to the fractured bone of the leg, the result of an accident. This decision was so completely contrary to the evidence before them that I have no hesitation in removing the case from the list of fatal accidents. It shows how valueless is the opinion of a sympathetic local jury in cases where compensation questions are likely to arise [fatality reported during the year but not classified as a reportable accident] |