|
Wilfred Smith
Sundries. Accident by Electricity, one death. Bower Colliery, June 14th, 7.30 p.m. Wilfred Smith, 26, dataller, received fatal shock from electric power cable. A full tub and an empty tub had got off the rails and met in the endless rope dip slant, causing the rope to stop. The fireman went down from the top of the brow and deceased with another dataller hurried up from the bottom to see what was wrong and remedy it. The fireman determined to slacken the clip connecting the full tub to the rope, and told deceased to stand clear of the full tub as it went back, in stepping to the side of the road deceased tripped over the haulage rope falling with his bare back against the two electric cables, he cried "Oh" and moaned, the dataller who had seen the haulage rope shake when deceased stumbled over it and saw sparks and blue flame from the cables, seized both legs of deceased pulling him clear of the cables, receiving a distinct shock when he took hold of deceased. The fireman ran for aid. The dataller "rubbed the body and worked his arms to keep him breathing," but in a few minutes he was quite dead. He was taken to the surface and there examined by a doctor. The dataller said that deceased was bare down to the top of his trousers, was sweating, where he fell was wet with water and the sides distinctly damp. At my request you permitted Mr. Gilbert Scott Ram, H.M. Electrical Inspector of Factories, to accompany me to the mine to examine the electrical installation and to attend the coroner’s inquest. His large experience and full knowledge conveyed to the coroner and jury a clear view of the cause of the accident. When we examined the installation it was found that the electric cables had been damaged in many places by the tubs leaving the rails and by falls of roof. Portions of the cables containing repaired joints were cut out, from above the place of accident and from below, between the two a distance of 100 yards. These joinings, four in number, were taken to the surface. Mr. Ram tested each, he connected one pole on the main switch board to the copper conductor of the cut out portion of cable, another pole to the armouring of the cable, an electric lamp being inserted between. In one case the current passed through, lighting the lamp and conclusively showing that the armouring was alive. The other three portions of cable failed to pass current to the lamp ; the joints were electrically good. On opening the defective joint it was seen that no india-rubber had been wrapped around, nothing but the tape covered it, at one point two of the copper wires were fused to the galvanized wire armouring. The installation is a small one, the full load capacity being about 30 electrical horse power. The generator has not yet worked under full load, a reserve of power having been provided to meet possible extensions. Continuous current at a pressure of 230 to 240 volts is generated above ground by a six pole belt driven machine, giving under a full load 93.25 amperes at 240 volts. The current is used in the mine for driving two electric motors working pumps, one being of 10 h.p., the other of 3 h.p. and for electric lighting. The current is conveyed by a pair of single cables down the downcast shaft to a distribution fuse board, from this board the circuits go on to the 10 h.p. motor and the 3 h.p. motor. Some lighting circuits are also taken from the board. The cables from this board to the 3 h.p. motor are those which caused the fatality, they consisted of a single strand of seven copper wires, 20 S.W.G., covered with vulcanized india-rubber over which two layers of thin cotton tape were wrapped, the outer covering being galvanized wire armouring. The two cables were on the same side of the road, six inches apart, secured to props by porcelain insulators. There was no earthing of the cables. At the inquest Mr. Ram gave evidence fully describing the defective repairs of the electric cables, and further clearly explained that the conditions were as favourable as they could possibly be for the man to receive the full force of the shock. Having no clothes above his waist, falling with his bare back on the wire, causing a mark 8½ inches long, shewing a long connection ; he was no doubt warm, perspiring, which would increase the effect of the shock, the current would more readily pass into his body ; the ground was wet, practically he was standing in water, this would assist the current to pass through his body to the earth. Mr. Ram said that he had no doubt there was leakage from the other pole which would enable sufficient current to flow to produce the effect. Had everything else been sound, the one piece of cable been the only fault, the shock would not have been sufficient to kill the man, there must have been sufficient leakage on the other side to allow it to pass. A fatality had occurred in London where the voltage was 200, alternate current; a number of cases between 200 and 240 volts, one at Bradford at 225 volts. It showed that under favourable conditions such a pressure was dangerous. Dr. Harold Ashton said that he made a post mortem examination of the body. Externally he found a slight mark on the back of the right shoulder, running, in a downward and inward direction : a slight abrasion, this might have been caused by a slight burn but appeared to have been caused by a rub. The body was well nourished with good muscles. The heart was normal in size and weight, weighed 12½ ounces. It contained very little blood, but there were a few clots of blood. The brain was normal. There was no fracture of the skull or spine. All the organs were normal. The lungs were rather congested, of a purplish colour and a little frothy fluid oozed out on squeezing them. There was no evidence of death from any cause but from the electrical shock, and in his opinion that was the cause of death. Evidence of the engineman proved the voltage at the time of the accident could not have been more than 240 and may have been 230 only, the pump was not at work. Mr. W. W. Millington, Mining Engineer, Chamber Colliery Co., Ltd., was the foreman of the jury ; the following being their verdict:— "The deceased met with his death by an electric shock caused by falling against a wire that was alive in consequence of a leakage the result of a faulty piecing of the cable." They made three recommendations, (1) that the joints in future should be properly and scientifically made ; (2) that the armouring should be made continous over the joint; (3) that the wires should be properly earthed. After the inquest the cables were overhauled, all the faulty repairs were corrected, 51 in number : a good earth was made by connecting the armouring of the two cables to a flange of the water delivery pipe below the cables. It was found that the pump motor would not work, due to earthing ; the motor armature was at fault through damp, this was put right and the motor has continued to work satisfactorily since. It should be stated that this electric installation was put in about 14 months before the accident. Tenders were obtained from a number of electricians, the order was to a local firm having works near the colliery in order that their services might readily obtained in case of need. This firm was responsible for the use of porcelain insulators, and for the size of the cables. The repairs to the cables were at first made with care by the manager, he instructed one of the workmen, this man gradually got more and more careless until finally the conductors were loosely looped together and twisted back on themselves forming an eye, the actual connection being quite loose as shown in the illustrations (Figs. 1, 2, and 3). This accident teaches several lessons, the most important probably being that low pressures under favourable conditions are dangerous ; the favourable conditions may be ordinary mining conditions. A very general opinion has existed that no danger attaches to voltages under 500. This fatality occurred with 230 volts, one at another Lancashire colliery at 100 volts. Another lesson is that mining men having but a slight acquaintance with electricity ought to consult experts as to installations, earthing, repairs, &c. To repair an electric conductor in the same way as bell lines for signalling are repaired, is absolutely foolish. Armoured cables require to be earthed, and periodical tests should be made to prove they are in order.
If you are researching Wilfred Smith (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||