|
Thomas Price
Accident No. 53. — Loss of life from inhaling carbonic oxide, or carbon monoxide, is so rare in mines, that a full description must be given of the fatality which happened at. the New Welsh Slate (Cwmorthin) Mine last August. About half-past seven on a Monday morning several men walked in as usual to their accustomed working places through one of the tunnels driven into the hillside. Less than an hour afterwards William Williams, who was entering the level from the outside, stumbled across a horse lying on the ground; after calling for assistance he went in further, and found Richard Jones prostrate, and further on the bodies of Hugh Davies and Thomas Price. Richard Jones recovered after having been brought out, and was able to give a full account of the catastrophe at the coroner's inquest on the following day. He and his partner, Hugh Davies, had gone in to their working place, about a quarter mile from the mouth of the tunnel, and were returning with a load of slate, which Thomas Price, the carter, was to draw out with his horse. On corning up to Price they found him sitting down by the side of the tramroad complaining that he was very ill. Jones said he would help him to go out, and endeavoured to do so; Price then found that his legs were so weak that he could not walk, so Jones got Davies to lift Price on to his back. Jones carried Price a yard or two, when his legs began to fail him, and he had to put his burden down. He then tried to walk out alone, but, like Price and Davies, fell down unconscious. The horse dropped a few yards in front of him. Dr. Richard Jones, of Blaenau Festiniog, who treated Jones and Williams after they were brought out, and who saw the two dead bodies about two hours after the accident, had no hesitation in ascribing the fatality to carbonic oxide and not to carbonic acid. He said that the presence of very many characteristic symptoms left no doubt whatever in his mind upon the subject. The source of the carbonic oxide was easily found. About 200 yards from the mouth of the tunnel, the chimney of a steam boiler, situated at a lower level, was discharging its smoke. Workings for slate at this point had left a large chamber, and originally the iron chimney had been carried well up into it, so that the fumes found their way to the surface without inconveniencing the persons employed. About a year or 18 months before the accident, this chimney was broken by a fall of roof, and the smoke was then allowed to issue into the level itself. Most of it escaped by ascending into the old chamber as before, but under certain atmospheric conditions some found its way out along the horizontal tunnel. The boiler had been in use for 15 years. It is well known that the gases coming from boiler furnaces consist almost exclusively of oxygen, carbonic acid, and nitrogen, and the presence of carbon monoxide is unusual; and though it appeared from the evidence at the inquest that the men had complained of having to walk through smoke occasionally, no danger was apprehended from it. In the early part of the year the manager heard good accounts of "Norman's Patent Fuel Economiser and Smoke Annihilator," and, after sending his engineer to see it at work, had the appliance attached to his underground boiler. Norman's method may be briefly described as burning the fuel with the aid of a forced draught created by jets of steam. Instead of having the ordinary fire-bars, the furnace bottom consists of plates of iron with perforations about ¾-inch square; through these a strong current of air is driven by means of a couple of small steam jets outside the boiler, which act after the manner of a Korting air injector. These jets are kept going most of the time the furnace is at work, and there are also jets above the fire for producing an additional draught, if there is a tendency for the flame to escape by the fire-door; a special flue underneath the air-blast brings in a supply of fresh air, which becomes warmed before meeting with the hot gases escaping from the fire and passing over the bridge. The inventor professes that the furnace consumes everything, and that in this way it effects a considerable saving of fuel. Judging by the testimonials brought forward by the inventor, it can prevent the issue of black smoke from the chimney, but that perfect combustion is not always secured is proved by the accident. Though the furnace undoubtedly emitted carbonic oxide on the morning of the accident, it could not have done so for long. The men walked in without feeling any inconvenience, and were not overcome until half an hour later, on returning. William Williams, who went in probably about a quarter of an hour after they had fallen, felt the effects of the poisonous gas; but its issue must have ceased almost immediately, as the other rescuers were subjected to no discomfort. It should be said that on the morning of the accident the natural ventilation created a strong current which carried the smoke out along the level. Analyses of the chimney gas taken the day after the accident showed that under ordinary circumstances combustion was complete, in fact, that the whole of the carbon of the coal was brought into the state of carbonic acid, and that none was left as carbonic oxide. For some reason or other the supply of air during part of the morning of the accident was inadequate, and carbonic oxide, or, in other words, imperfectly consumed carbon, was discharged into the atmosphere of the mine. Several hypotheses suggested themselves to me as possible explanations of the insufficient supply of air :— (1) Door of the air-flue being improperly closed. (2.) Air-flue being choked by ashes. (3.) Excessive supply of steam, causing the formation of more water-gas than could be burnt inside the boiler. The only person capable of throwing any light upon the working of the furnace on the morning of the accident was the stoker, and he declared that everything was in good order, the air-door properly open, the air-flues perfectly clear, and no greater amount of steam injected than usual. It is impossible to assert more than the fact that something went wrong. In justice to the inventor, I may say that he propounded the theory that some carbonic oxide accumulated in the flues between the Sunday morning, when the fires were damped, and the Monday morning, and that this carbonic oxide caused the accident. There are no grounds whatever for accepting this explanation ; the facts are entirely opposed to it. The boiler was set to work at 4 a.m. on the Monday morning, and even if any carbonic oxide had accumulated in the flues during the Sunday, it would have been driven into the level and have been carried away by the strong draught long before the men entered the mine. Besides, the men felt no discomfort on entering; the poisonous gas which did the mischief was generated while they were in the mine. What caused the temporary deficiency of oxygen for the boiler fires will probably never be explained. No written or printed instructions for the stokers were supplied to the mine manager by the inventor, who considered his apparatus so simple that a few words from an experienced hand were all that was needed. An apparatus which without apparent rhyme or reason suddenly goes wrong, is far from being as perfect as the inventor would wish one to suppose. As the accident could be ascribed to inadequate ventilation, I reported it to you, and asked whether proceedings should be taken against the owners for a breach of the first general rule. The matter was fully investigated by the solicitor to the Treasury, who came to the conclusion that, taking all the circumstances of the case into consideration, it would be difficult to establish satisfactorily that the owners had not taken all reasonable means to provide proper and adequate ventilation. Consequently no proceedings were taken. If one recollects that Norman's invention was applied to the boiler with a view to remedy the smoke nuisance of which the men complained, and that the boiler had been in use for many years, it is not likely that a court would have convicted the owner or agent. I have placed this accident amongst the "Sundries underground," because the heading "By underground fires" is intended specially for accidents due to the burning of timber supports or linings, or to the combustion of the mineral itself.
If you are researching Thomas Price (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 01 Sep 2023
|
Search |
|
|||