Alexander Aitken
| Age: | 47 |
| Died: | 16th Jul 1861 |
| Accident: | 16th Jul 1861 |
| Year Born: | abt. 1814 |
| Colliery: | Kelvinside |
| Company: | Montgomerie and Fleming |
| Occupation: | Miner |
| Notes: | Inundation from an adjoining waste |
| Buried: | [not known] |
| Category: | |
No. 20 accident, schedule No. 1, was occasioned by an irruption of water from an
abandoned work.
This unfortunate occurrence was occasioned by an irruption of water from an abandoned
waste, forming part of the same colliery, and lying near to the going works.
The accompanying sketch shows the position of the "waste" at the time the accident
happened, according to plan produced by the owners of the colliery. Referring to it,
the workings of the old Sheep-mount pit, abandoned for the last 12 years, are shaded
yellow, the workings from the "upper doors" of the new Sheep-mount pit are shaded
blue, and the Stone mine, situated about three fathoms below the "upper doors" is
shaded brown, and marked "Stone Mine."
The workings from the "upper doors" of the new Sheep-mount pit were principally
confined to a dook west of the slip marked 27 feet down to west, and the only extension
from the "lower doors" was the stone mine. Aitken, one of the deceased, and a man
named Develin worked in the stone mine. It appears that shortly before the accident
they had been blasting at A, and on discovering that an excess of water was rushing
through the openings and crevices in the rock at the face of the mine, they had abandoned
their work, and were in the act of being raised by the engine, when, unfortunately, a
"hutch," which had been standing near to the pit bottom, was driven by the force of the
water between the cage and the side of the shaft, and for some time prevented the cage
being raised. Develin scrambled on to the cover of the cage, and kept himself above
the water, and was rescued; but Aitken appears to have got jammed between the
"hutch" and the cage, and must have been drowned in a few moments after. The
water rose rapidly in the shaft, closing up the entrance into the "upper doors," and the
highest level it is supposed to have reached in the works was to the point B.
At this time only four persons were engaged in the workings leading off at the
"upper doors." They soon discovered their helpless situation, and after being inclosed
112 hours, three of them were safely rescued. It is uncertain whether the boy <Fagan
was drowned at the pit bottom, by the water closing in upon him unexpectedly, or that
in attempting to reach it, he had got entangled with some projecting part of the mine,
which cut off or retarded his retreat.
The workings from the old Sheep-mount pit were known to be standing full of water.
In nearing this dangerous accumulation it does not appear that the underground manager
took the usual and necessary precaution of surveying the mine to know its relative
position to these works, or of causing boreholes to be made, as provided by the 15th
general rule of the Mine Inspection Act, which, under the circumstances, he was bound
to do.
The Procurator Fiscal charged the underground manager with culpable homicide in
neglecting to adopt due precautions to prevent the flooding of the workings. The case
was tried at the Glasgow Autumn Circuit Court, before the Lord Justice Clerk and a
jury. After a lengthened trial the jury found the accused guilty as libelled ; but in
respect of his good character, they strongly recommended him to the leniency of the
Court.
In passing sentence, the Lord Justice Clerk said, "It was painful to him to have to
deal with a charge of such a kind against a person who occupied the position of the
manager of a coal work, and, above all, against one who previous to the unfortunate
occurrence bore a very excellent character. Unfortunately, his duty left him no alternative
but to pronounce such a sentence as would sufficiently mark the sense which the
Court entertained of the offence. However, believing that the failure of the panel to
do his duty was merely the result of thoughtlessness, and was not intentional ; and that
notwithstanding the apparently reckless manner in which the work was conducted, the
panel believed it possible to carry it through without serious consequences. It was
because he (his lordship) believed that, and because the sentence he would pronounce,
without being severe, would operate as a warning to the panel at all times, and would
show the public that the lives of persons in employment were not to be trifled with, that
he would restrict the sentence to four months' imprisonment."
- 1861 Mines Inspectors Report, by William Alexander, H.M. Inspector of Mines, Page: 135
- 1861 Mines Inspectors Report, by William Alexander, H.M. Inspector of Mines, Page: 141, Accident Number: 20
If you are researching Alexander Aitken (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would
like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete
the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide
on this page so that you can be contacted.

Return

Return to Top