|
William Knuckey
Explosions of Gunpowder, &c. The worst blasting accident, and indeed the most serious casualty of last year, causing the death of two men, occurred at Carn Brea on the 27th September. I happened to be abroad on leave at the time, but I visited the scene of the accident on the 1st October, and on the following day Major Majendie, R.A., H.M. Inspector of Explosives, came down to hold an inquiry under the 66th section of the Explosives Act. As Major Majendie's very exhaustive report has been published, it will not be necessary for me to go so fully into the case as I might otherwise have done; I will merely explain it briefly. Three holes, which I will call Nos. 1, 2, and 3, charged with dynamite on the afternoon of the 26th September, had been fired at 4 p.m. at the bottom of Highburrow West Shaft, which was being sunk with the aid of two percussive drills, worked by compressed air. Three reports were heard; eight other holes were next charged and blasted half an hour afterwards, and the men occupied themselves with clearing away the "stuff." This work having been accomplished by the morning, boring had to be recommenced, and one of the drills was fixed so as to bore a new hole about 10 inches from the remains of No. 1, of the previous afternoon, which had not "torn" quite to the bottom. The drill, which was clamped to a round bar, was apt to shift its position a little if the bit struck a sloping surface; and from the position in which it was found after the accident, with the bit touching part of the old hole, it was evident that in this case it had shifted considerably. At all events the men had been boring a very short time when an explosion took place, which caused the death of two men, and injured three others. As dynamite was the only explosive in use in the shaft, and as the results were too great for the mere explosion of a cap, it may fairly be assumed that the accident was caused by the explosion of dynamite, or nitro-glycerine washed out of it. There are three ways in which the accident may have happened. 1. From loose dynamite lying about. 2. From unexploded dynamite being left in the bottom of the hole, owing to the "collar" having been blown away, with the upper part of the charge, by the explosion of a neighbouring hole fired at the same time. 3. From unexploded dynamite left in the hole due to an imperfect explosion of the charge. A good deal of care seems to have been exercised in sending down the materials for blasting, and there was no evidence in support of the first hypothesis. Nor does the second, which undoubtedly serves to account for some accidents, appear likely in the present instance. The men had arranged the lengths of fuse so that No. 1 was to go off first, and they were of opinion that No. 2, from its position, could not have blown off the collar of No. 1. No. 3 was still further off. Nothing but the best gutta-percha fuse was employed. We now come to the third hypothesis, that the top part of the charge exploded, leaving the bottom intact. More than two years ago I was led to the conclusion that partial explosions of dynamite charges occasionally take place, and in my report for 1876 I said, "It cannot be denied that the whole of the dynamite in a charge does not always go off when a shot is fired, and some occasionally remains, as a source of danger to the workman, ready to explode when struck by the pick or borer." Again, last year, in reporting upon the accident at South Wheal Crofty, I gave it as my opinion that the accident was caused by the "explosion of some remnants of dynamite which did not go off in the original blast." I also suggested the same cause for a non-fatal accident at Wheal Comford. Recollecting these various cases, it naturally occurred to me that the Carn Brea accident might be satisfactorily explained in a similar manner, and I was glad to find that Major Majendie arrived at the same conclusion quite independently. The causes which may lead to the partial explosion of a charge are fully elucidated in his report. Admitting then that unexploded dynamite remained at the bottom of No. 1 hole, and was left there in contact with water for some 15 hours, it is perfectly allowable to suppose that some nitro-glycerine exuded and exploded when the rock was struck by the violent blows of a powerful machine drill, or indeed the drill may have driven down fragments of rock on to the remnants of the charge. The only means of preventing accidents of this kind is set forth in the recommendation of the jury, who returned a verdict of accidental death at the inquest, "that a strict system of searching for unexploded dynamite be invariably carried out after blasting." J. Craze, who was in charge of the men shortly before the accident, was to blame for not having made a proper examination of the ground before the new hole was started. He admitted (and then subsequently denied) that he knew that No. 1 hole had not torn to the bottom. In extenuation of his fault, it is but fair to say that, previous to the ventilation of the question at the Carn Brea inquiry, danger from partial explosions was not so thoroughly recognised as it is now. Considering the large quantities of dynamite in use for blasting, it is of the greatest importance that all mine agents should impress upon the men two of the dangers connected with this explosive, viz., danger of exudation of nitro-glycerine when the charge is left in contact with water, and danger of occasional partial explosions from imperfect detonation. I am glad to find that Nobel's Explosives Company, Limited, have called attention to this danger by a circular.
If you are researching William Knuckey (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 30 Apr 2023
|
Search |
|
|||