|
John Harris
Boiler explosions. The facts of the West Tolgus case are as follows :— The boiler that exploded was of the usual Cornish type, with a single flue, and internally fired. The length of the boiler was 34 feet 6 inches, the diameter of the case 6 feet 5 inches, and of the flue 3 feet 10 inches. Plates of the flue 3/8 inch thick; no strengthening rings. The fittings were, one lever safety valve, one steam pressure gauge, one glass water gauge, and two gauge cocks. The boiler that exploded was the middle one of a group of five, and was at the very least 10 years old. The working pressure was 36 lbs. Steam was shut off at 9 p.m. one evening for the purpose of doing some repairs, and at 4 a.m. on the following morning, as the work was completed, the engineman went to the fires to get up steam, but the pressure had only reached 31 to 32 lbs., it is said, when the explosion took place, scalding the engineman so severely that he died on the following day. There was a partial collapse of the tube above the fire, the two first plates bulging down considerably and the third very slightly. There was also a great rent along the seam uniting the first and second rings. It is probable that the explosion was caused by overheating of the plates from shortness of water, though the deceased was very positive on his death-bed that he saw the water at the proper height in the gauge glass. I think that he must have been mistaken, or else that the gauge was choked. There was a special donkey-engine for pumping in feed-water during lengthened stoppages, but it was not put to work on this occasion. The verdict of the Coroner's jury, after a deliberation of more than two hours, was as follows: "That the deceased was accidentally scalded to death by the explosion of a boiler caused by shortness of water, and the jury regret that the mining company did not use a fusible plug which would have prevented the accident in question, and they are of opinion that the consulting engineer should not have allowed the boiler tube to be subjected to a pressure of 36 lbs. per square inch, which was half the maximum collapsing pressure of the tube when perfectly new." Of course fusible plugs must not be considered as an infallible remedy against boiler explosions; they are only expected to prevent one source of danger, overheating from shortness of water, and they in nowise counteract the great evil of the ordinary Cornish boiler, viz., weakness of the tube. Besides which, like other appliances, they must be watched and kept in good order ; but when attended to they form an additional safeguard, and one that has in many cases given timely warning of a deficiency of feed. One of the Boiler Insurance companies shows its appreciation of them by reducing its premiums where certain fusible plugs are used. I cannot help thinking that the shortness of water may have been caused by one of the other boilers having "robbed" the one that exploded, owing to the back pressure valve having become inoperative from a chip or stone getting under it and preventing it from closing. I found that the feed was brought in 20 inches below the water line, and on questioning the working engineer at the inquest he replied: "We often find one boiler rob another when we stop. More attention is required when the engine is idle than when we are working." The consulting engineer in answer to my question also said : "I believe if the feed inlet were higher up the 'robbing' would be less." I am decidedly of opinion that in many of the boilers in my district the feed is brought in too low, causing an additional chance of shortness of water during the stoppage of a group of boilers. I quite agree with the latter part of the verdict of the jury, for though the inherent weakness of the boiler may not have caused the explosion, it is not right to work any boiler, and especially an old one, with so small a margin of safety.
If you are researching John Harris (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||