logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Donate to support the Museum
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

  Individual Details   Individual Details  
 


John Button

Age:  
Died:   22nd Oct 1869
Accident:   22nd Oct 1869
Born:  
Colliery:   Newbury
Company:   Westbury Iron Co.
Occupation:  
Notes:  
Eleven persons killed by explosion of fire-damp ; Explosion, firedamp, ignition caused by safety lamp
Buried:   [not known]
Category:  

Description

The last calamity of the year by fire-damp took place on the morning of the 22nd of October, in the "Mackintosh" side of the Westbury Iron Company's Newbury Colliery, not far from the Mendip Hills in Somersetshire. It is a far more serious event than any yet referred to in this report, inasmuch as it occasioned the death of eleven of the workmen. Some were brought out of the pit dead ; some succumbed shortly afterwards; others, again, lingered many days before they passed away. If I remember rightly, a dozen persons went down the pit that morning, of whom, I think, but one survives. Some of them must have suffered terribly from burns and contusions, from the after damp, and from the amount of dust blown up. Pulverulent matter is of serious import to the coal miner at all times, even in the absence of explosion, and under the most favourable conditions of good management; it affects his digestive organs seriously ; it enters his lungs, and too often becomes the nucleus of disease. Professor Tyndall has shown by a beam of light what we inhale on the surface, but that is nothing to the mass of organic and inorganic particles met with in colliery roads and working places. By explosive action these become an actual portion of the underground atmosphere, and the result is too often most painful suffering and death.

As regards ventilating operations, the fresh air goes down a shaft called the "Newbury pit" and after straggling, and, indeed, struggling, through narrow roadways, finds its exitus at and up the "Mackintosh pit," where there is a furnace for the purpose of producing a movement of the air by rarefaction. The surface distance between these two points I am unable correctly to state, as I possess no general map of the property ; but I should think the travel of the air underground from one shaft to the other will approach eight hundred yards, or perhaps even half a mile. Certain "branches" or stone drifts, across the "measures," exist, and were, at the time of the explosion, progressing; but no coal is wrought, that I am aware of, until near the bottom of the "staple," where a certain small quantity is excavated; there in fact, and in the furnace heading at the top of the said "staple," were to be found the coal getting places in the Newbury Colliery, and about a couple of hundred yards would embrace the entire site of their exploitations; it is evident, enough, therefore, that there was not much going on, indeed it may be fairly said that the actual working places were really insignificant in extent. But the worst of it was that those very working places were in an anomalous condition as regards locality, being positively situated in the last of the "returns." Those returns themselves, and all the other wind ways of the pit, were not, in my opinion, large enough for the free passage of air. It would appear then that the dilemma of the viewer was one of two most serious alternatives ; the coal was fiery, and if he sent the air in at a low rate of speed, he would not get enough of it to "dilute and render harmless the noxious gas;" on the contrary, if by the application of considerable furnace power he produced a rapid travel of the air, he would incur the liability of passing flame through the reticulated lamp cylinders, and we have every reason to believe that this contingency actually occurred.

A condensed statement of what I said at the inquest when under examination and cross-examination will possibly be clearer than any description I can give from recollection alone:—

"I went down the Mackintosh pit on Sunday, and remained below until midnight; and I again went down on Monday. In my opinion it is not far from where Gunning was employed, and about there alone that we must look for the site of the explosion. When examining that place on Sunday night, I found a coal face of about seven feet in width and 18 feet in beyond the brattice. But the next day when I was in the same place I was informed by Hamblin (the under bailiff), that before the disaster this brattice cloth was only 13 feet back, and that the explosion had stripped off the other 5 feet. But there was even then space enough for many cubic feet of carburetted hydrogen. I myself found a certain amount of gas there on both occasions ; quite enough to have brought about very grave results indeed, if we had fired it. Some of the witnesses have sworn that they discovered it previous to the explosion, and this accumulation would then be in contravention of the law. On the morning of the explosion it is probable that there was a quantity which when mixed with certain well known volumes of atmospheric air would amount to a very imposing force indeed ; and the mischief would be greater by being fired in a narrow and confined place like the furnace level. Had there been ample room for expansion, the poor sufferers might possibly have escaped with their lives, though many of them would certainly have been very badly burned. After-damp also is more fatal to life in contracted spaces than in wide openings. With the very restricted sectional area in the level in question the results of the explosion became disastrous. Besides Gunning's place, there was another excavation lower down, where Curtis worked; this coal face was also 9 or 10 feet beyond its windway, and there again I detected fire-damp. This opening likewise was sufficiently spacious to contain a considerable quantity of gas; indeed it had been observed by witnesses before the explosion. This also establishes the fact of illegal accumulation of fire-damp. Again, in a coal face near the bottom of the "staple," firedamp was found on Monday when we were all exploring together, but we have no evidence that it was met with in that particular place before the explosion. However, it all tends to show that gas is continually oozing out from the coal, and that they should never neglect to brattice the working places as close to the face as even to be inconvenient to the workmen.

I will now point out how the pit could have been fired in the absence of unprotected flame, premising that it was mainly the gas from Gunning's stall that perpetrated the disaster. I find by calculation that in order to pass 9,000 cubic feet of air per minute (the stated usual quantity) through the narrow furnace level, it must actually travel at the rate of 7½ feet per second, which is rather a trying velocity for a Davy lamp. And if workmen were walking down the said level with lamps in their hands against this sharp ascending current at such a speed as to raise the aggregate velocity to nine feet per second, then if the current were foul there would be imminent danger of passing the flame through the gauze.

"Several of the witnesses testified to seeing gas in different places before the explosion, but one of them 'did not think it of much account.' It really requires long experience and no small amount of scientific knowledge, to say what is the limit between 'not of much account' and positive danger and death ; a small quantity of gas will bring about a large amount of destruction, especially in places of insignificant dimensions.

"The first general rule was not obeyed, in my opinion, inasmuch as there was not a sufficient steady volume of air to prevent an accumulation of gas firing in a working place or in a travelling road; in fact there was not sufficient dilution to comply with the word and spirit of the law, or, which comes to the same thing, that air was not directed close enough to the faces to render harmless a noxious gas, by diluting and constantly sweeping it away.

"The question (asked) is an important one. If the gas had been seen by a fireman or any person deputed to act in that capacity, the men would have been prevented from descending the pit until it was cleared away by fresh air.

"The sixth special rule at first sight appears obscure, whereas it is really not so ; and even if it were, the 7th, 8th, and 9th rules are imperative. But none of them have been obeyed, and no person has carried into effect those operations which would realize the requirements of the 8th rule, 'that the overmen shall see the deputies every morning after they have been around the workings, and receive their report before the workmen commence to go down.'

"The circumstance that the coal workings are situated in the last of the air is remarkable ; the coal is worked at the very end of a long travel of the wind, wind that has had to pass through narrow roads for very many hundreds of yards.

"The gas comes off freely from the seam at present in work, and it is exceedingly quick to ignite. It ought therefore to have been so closely bratticed as to sweep all that was generated right into the main returns, and so up the dumb drift.

"Certain rules have been violated, those regulating examination. If they had been obeyed, then most likely all those lives that are lost would have been saved. If the evidence is to be relied upon as to the curtain (canvass door) being tucked up (that is, left open), then it is not difficult to account for the explosion. This shows what a dreadful result has attended disobedience of the law. There ought to have been a second curtain or door. It will be replied, that there was no room for another; that between the entrance to Gunning's stall and its windway outlet there were not many feet; but I insist upon it that there was space sufficient, especially as no horses work in that level. A second door should have been put up, whether it was inconvenient to the workmen or not. The use of a second door is, that in passing through one it is shut before the second is opened. This is a well-known and constantly practiced operation in collieries. If in travelling along a level a man finds one of these doors open, it excites his suspicion; if he finds both open, he then knows that something is dangerously wrong, and that an unlawful act has been committed. We have it in evidence that the curtain (the door) was rendered absolutely inefficient by being tucked up (left open) on the morning of the explosion, in such manner indeed that the air was diverted from its proper channel, and moreover it is fully proved that there was no examination as required by law. This greatly simplifies the whole inquiry, and justifies my remark at the last meeting, that all those rules (of examination) had been broken. There was actually a monstrous proposition carried into effect for two or three weeks, that the pit should only be examined on a Monday. If there had been a common examination on the morning of October the 22nd, before the men went down, the explosion would have been in all probability prevented. A speed of 7½ feet per second is not better in this pit for ventilation than six feet, because, in supplying a condition of safety, it, supplies also a condition of danger, that of passing the flame through the lamp gauze. A velocity of 7½ feet per second would clear the pit of gas quicker than six feet, but it might fire it. The curtain, if a good one, was properly devised. The old Act of Parliament, which provided that a copy of the rules should be given to every man and boy, has been repealed, and I cannot help regretting that this useful proviso was not introduced into the present measure; it was clear, simple, and effective." (Such was my evidence).

The result of the inquiry was that a verdict of manslaughter was returned against William Baker, Abraham Hamblin, and John Bainton. The Somersetshire spring assize will this year be held at Taunton.

The above evidence was necessarily desultory, it could not be otherwise, but it established the facts, and that was all that was required.

The mode in which the gas got all at once out from Gunning's stall into the furnace level was, that as the men were streaming down under the curtain that was so fatally rolled up, their very bodies became as it were an intercepting substance or door, and so turned the wind up into that working place, and puffed the gas out into the main road, where the next man coming down met it, and fired it with his lamp; that was the conclusion I arrived at, for the slightest undulation of air would be sufficient to move it (the gas), and it would be done in a few moments, in consequence of the doorway being so small and so easily filled up by persons passing through.

If now the discipline had been thorough, the door shut as it ought to have been, and Gunning's working place closely bratticed, that is to say, if everything was in its proper and normal condition, the gas would still have got into the furnace level; that in fact was its natural route; but then it would simply have got there in imperceptible quantities, just in fact as it eliminated itself from the coal, and so would have mixed up with the air in the level, and have passed away up the dumb drift. The true reason of the disaster was a considerable accumulation of gas suddenly dislodged in the manner above described, and not the mere harmless passing away of fire-damp as it was formed.

It will be seen from all that has been said that the leading defect of the colliery was, that the air passages were of a size much too limited for free ventilation.

With regard to sectional areas generally, and other circumstances connected with the transmission of air underground, really the natural laws that relate to them are by no means difficult of comprehension. But we are all apt to guide ourselves by local conditions, such as height of seam, the sort of roof we possess, the resistible strength of the thill or floor, and so on, indeed to a certain extent we are bound to be so guided, nevertheless it is an absolute condition that fiery mines shall positively and actually be provided with ample and roomy passages. I am occasionally invited to look at road and airways that are stated to be quite sufficient, but which on inspection I do not by any manner of means find to be equal to my own idea of requisite size. Unless underground roads correspond in dimensions with the duty the wind is expected to perform, disasters will never cease. An abundant supply of fresh air judiciously distributed is the sine qna non for dangerous seams of coal, and that is pretty well all we know on the subject; but without great sectional area we cannot get this "abundant supply" into the far end or back of our works, and in that case our knowledge, whatever it may amount to, is all in vain. Scant ventilation affects not only the people, but the poor animals also, in hot badly aired collieries the horses suffer positive torture. In such ill-conditioned mines every possible cubic foot of wind that can be produced is wanted in the working faces, and then the stables are not supplied with a sufficient scale of fresh air, and the horses, after leaving their labour, undergo in what should be their places of rest, quite as much misery as they did when they were dragging the trams after them in the ill-driven and badly ventilated roadways and stalls.

If the means could be provided in universities to impart scientific information to those who are intended for mining pursuits, then I think we should not so often meet with these narrow and tortuous passages underground; amplitude would become the rule, and not contraction. It is quite true that nothing can be done without practice and experience, but still with a higher order of education added we might expect great things indeed. Not to be familiar with the important physical laws that govern ventilation is a condition of ignorance that ought not to exist in this country.


Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
30 Oct 1869  Another Fatal Colliery Explosion (The Penny Illustrated Paper)

Sources
  • 1869 Mines Inspectors Report (C 124), South Western District by Lionel Brough, H.M. Inspector of Mines, Page: 74, Accident Number: 40 Where to find this report
  • 1869 Mines Inspectors Report (C 124), South Western District by Lionel Brough, H.M. Inspector of Mines, Page: 82, Accident Number: 40 Where to find this report

Researchers

If you are researching John Button (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.

What is your name?
What is your contact email address?
What is your research interest?

 

Return Return   Return Return to Top

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Jul 2023

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print