|
Henry Haynes
Explosions of Gas. The first explosion occurred on the 24th of February at the Pentre Colliery, Rhondda Valley, belonging to the Pentre and Church Merthyr Steam Coal Collieries Company, by which 38 persons were killed. Fortunately this explosion occurred during the night when only 36 persons were in the colliery, all of whom, with two others, who bravely went to rescue the unfortunate sufferers, were killed. I annex a copy of the evidence given by my colleague Mr. Brough and myself at the coroner's inquest, which was held near the colliery and extended over several days. Mr. Lionel Brough, of Clifton, said, — "I am Government Inspector of mines for the South-western District. I have made an examination of this colliery and have attended here by the order of the Secretary of State. I travelled portions of the pit on March 10th, accompanied by Mr. Wales and Mr. S. W. Kelly, and examined the faces in the North District going to the end of No. 3 heading. On coming back we met Mr. Burn and Mr. David Evans and went further into the matter. I have not examined the whole of the pit nor the extremity of Gay's (No. 3) heading, but have depended entirely for information about the place upon what I have heard during the evidence and which I have attentively listened to and recorded. I am of opinion that this extreme north point has supplied the bulk of the gas that brought about the calamity. I have no doubt that the gas has been in the habit of appearing in the other part of the works, but the extremity of No. 3 heading is the great and independent source. I allude to that portion of the north part which is the face of Elias Thomas's heading. The gas which came from the extreme northern point picked its way slowly to the furnace through Gravell's heading, down the incline, and so on to the furnace. It must have fired there and instantly produced an expansive heated atmosphere, commonly called a blast, which followed back these very footsteps which I have described to the northern end from which in its gaseous state it originally came, and then turned round the face portions of it, breaking away through into the main heading, wherever it could find an outlet, and showing by all its traces that it flew south. I believe one of its discharges or gun barrels, for every heading or aperture after an explosion is a gun barrel, flew away through Elias Thomas's north heading, expanded itself to the westward (I am now speaking with reference to that portion), and blew down the double doors in the main east heading. I have no doubt it all flew away in every open direction right away to the end. I am also of opinion that the blast in flying back to the northern end picked up more gas which was coming off, which kept that atmosphere alive in a state of flame and burnt men to the southward. It is evident it must be so if the explosion fired the blower at the end of Rosser's heading, as that fact is sworn to, and by the same means men were burnt in the other parts of the colliery." "A hurricane on the surface will travel at the rate of 100 miles per hour, but a hurricane has no chance with a blast underground. All the states and conditions of the circumambient air upon the surface have been carefully worked out and elaborated by philosophical men and they put down the rate of a hurricane's velocity at what I name ; and I maintain that that speed is nothing compared with that of a blast underground. In answer to the coroner, I think the bottom of the pit is not a good arrangement, but finer openings I think I have rarely seen, and the intakes and the returns are of very ample dimensions indeed. I consider that 45,000 cubic feet of air under ordinary circumstances would be enough to work this colliery, including the 4 feet, the other works, and the western abandoned portion. I decidedly do not approve of these small pits. It was sunk by a Staffordshire man, and in that county they will sink a pit a hundred or two hundred yards to work ten acres of coal, but in Wales, when we have a hundred times more fire we want big pits. All carriages ought to have bonnets, for a very small lump of coal falling down a shaft will knock a man's brains out, its like a bullet. I disapprove of the bottom arrangements. They want more winding power, but that has nothing to do with the explosion, but the winding engine is imperfect in its arrangement working two shafts at the same time. With regard to the ventilation, the arrangements for the distribution of the air are as fine as any I ever saw. I have now given you an entire history of what in my opinion the explosion must have been together with its cause and the course of the blast, but you must expect more explosions in this new valley. The ground is fresh, few pits have been sunk, the gas has never been tapped, the depths of the earth has never been perforated, and gas exists in the most awful state of pressure and in an intensely ignitable condition, and the only panacea, the only safeguard, for human life in pits sunk in a new valley is an abundance of wind, and that is not all, we must in addition look forward to some better invention in lamps." Mr. Thomas Errington Wales said, — "I am Government Inspector of Mines for the South Wales District, and have drawn up the following Report :— "I shall first notice the probable condition of the pit at the time of the explosion, the probable cause and where it originated, and then make a few suggestions, which if carried out would in my opinion conduce to the safer working of the colliery in future. From the several inspections I have make of the colliery since the explosion, together with the evidence given by the different witnesses who have been examined, it is clear that although small blowers had been frequently met with the quantity of air was sufficient to properly dilute them ; and only two witnesses (with the exception of the fireman, John Edwards,) have spoken to accumulations of gas ; one about five and the other about nine months ago. From the several measurements I made of the air currents, I believe the quantity passing at the time of the explosion would probably be about 45,000 cubic feet per minute. This quantity would, in my opinion, be quite sufficient to properly ventilate the colliery, which is not by any means an extensive one, under ordinary circumstances. The colliery as you already know, was worked with locked safety lamps, but shot firing, under the usual restrictions was permitted. I have always recommended that wherever safety lamps are used shot firing should be prohibited, and I do so on this occasion. It appears that all the safety lamps were properly examined and locked by the two firemen at the lamp cabin, near the bottom of the pit, every morning as the workmen proceeded to their work. According to No. 16 Special Rule, all lamps requiring to be relighted during the day should have been relocked by a properly appointed person. Instead of this, however, it appears a lamp key was kept chained at each of the two lamp stations, viz., in the 4 feet and 2 feet 9 in. veins, but no person was appointed to see that the lamps were again properly locked. This, in my opinion, was clearly a breach of that important rule. From the evidence of Edwards the fireman, he allowed the colliers to work where there was, what he considered, only a small quantity of gas. This was a violation of both Number 1 General and Number 24 Special Rule. The men ought to have been withdrawn at once, and the fireman's conduct, in allowing the men to work under such circumstances, was most reprehensible, and in my opinion totally unfits him to discharge the important duties of a fireman. As to the cause of the explosion I believe it was due to a large blower at the extreme north part of the colliery, which continued to give off gas for several days to such an extent as to render it too dangerous to pass the return air over the furnace. "I believe this discharge of gas rendered the return current of air explosive, which on reaching the furnace was ignited. All the traces and marks left show that the explosion originated there. Then as to the future working of the colliery, which appears to be liable to blowers, in my opinion it should be placed in the hands of a competent mining engineer or colliery manager. "I beg also to suggest that a new shaft of from 12 to 14 feet diameter be sunk for an upcast, and the present two shafts used as downcast shafts. That a fan capable of producing from 80,000 to 100,000 cubic feet of air per minute be placed on the top of the new shaft, in lieu of the present furnaces. This would prevent the possibility of another explosion at the furnace in case another large discharge of gas should unfortunately be met with. But until a more perfect safety lamp be discovered I despair of being able to cope successfully at all times with those sudden outbursts of gas, which have proved the great danger attending the working of these steam coals in this and the Aberdare valleys. "The Coroner. — But by saying what you consider necessary for the future do you wish to imply that something has been wanting in the past, or that the owners have been guilty of carelessness. "Mr. Wales. — Certainly not, but from what we have heard and seen it seems to me to be necessary to take further precautions. This is the first explosion that has taken place in the 2 feet 9-inch seam, either in this or in the Aberdare valley, and hitherto this seam has not by any means been considered a fiery one ; but after what we have now witnessed I think it may very well be regarded as not less fiery than the 4 feet seam. Copy of Verdict returned by the Jury. "The jury are unanimously of opinion that the explosion occurred through a sudden discharge of gas, and that it probably ignited at the furnace, and that there is no blame attached to any of the officials connected with the colliery. "The jury strongly recommend that the suggestions of Mr. Wales, the Government Inspector, should be carried out as soon as practicable, and they also recommend that a night bankman should be constantly employed." "The Coroner said, — I can only say that I concur most fully with your verdict. I may say it is a most just and proper one, and I thank you for the great attention you have paid to the matter." Both from my own inspections and from the evidence given at the inquest, it was evident that the colliery was very subject to "blowers" or sudden outbursts of gas, and that therefore it was of the greatest importance that my suggestions with reference to the future working of the colliery should be carried out, or a similar calamity might occur any day. I wrote the owners in accordance with section 17, 23 and 24 Victoria, chapter 151, and pointed out to them the great danger attending their continuing to work the colliery by furnace ventilation. I also reported the case to the Home Office, and I am glad to be able to state that the owners have now undertaken to carry out my recommendations as soon as practicable.
If you are researching Henry Haynes (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||