|
Michael King
No. 4 (Lancashire) explosion of fire-damp occurred on the 7th June at the Wood Pit of the Haydock Colliery, the property of Messrs. Richard Evans & Co., and caused the death of 189 persons. It happened a few minutes after 11 o'clock a.m., barometer registering 30.05 inches, having commenced to fall at 9.0 a.m. the same day, and was still falling at 11 o'clock. Plans of this mine are annexed, and details of the circumstances have already been submitted to you, together with reports by Mr. Maule, Q.C., and myself, on the evidence adduced at the inquest, which was opened before Charles E. Driffield, Esq., county coroner, and occupied six days. Mr. Maule was present at this inquiry, and I acted in concert with him, and took care that every witness was produced who was likely to throw light on the causes of the accident, and endeavoured by cross-examination to bring the whole of the circumstances under the observation of the jury, and at their request I gave evidence as follows :— "July 1878. "I have made frequent inspections of this Wood Pit since the accident, and have assisted in the work of exploration, being accompanied on several occasions by Mr. Dickinson, the inspector for North-East Lancashire and Ireland, and also by Mr. Hedley, assisting inspector in this West Lancashire district. These inspections commenced on Sunday the 9th of June, and ended on July 3rd. The Wood Pit is one of a group of pits which form the Haydock Collieries. It is sunk to a depth of 243 yards, passing through four seams of coal, viz.: The Higher Florida, at 105 yards; Lower Florida, at 118 yards; Ravenhead Higher Delf, at 217 yards; and the Ravenhead Main Delf, at 243 yards. At a distance (78 yards) from the Wood Pit, which is 10 feet diameter, is a second or upcast shaft 9 feet diameter, from the surface to a depth of 118 yards, and below that it is widened out to 10 feet diameter. The Higher Florida mine, in which this explosion occurred, is reached by an incline tunnel 190 yards in length. This tunnel strikes the seam at the south side of a large down-throw fault called the Red Rock fault, which has cast the Higher Florida seam down to a lower level than that at which the Ravenhead Main Delf is found at the bottom of the shaft. From inquiry I find that on the day of this explosion, the 7th of June, there were 190 men and boys engaged in the Higher Florida workings beyond the fault, and 60 or thereabouts in the other seams at work near the shaft, inclusive of one or two engaged in the tunnel itself. From inquiries I find that the explosion occurred at a few minutes after eleven o'clock in the morning, smoke and dust issuing out of both shafts. The barometer at this time stood at 30 1-20 inches, having, according to Chadburn's self-registering barometer in Liverpool, commenced to fall slowly at nine o'clock the game morning, and was still falling at eleven. Mr. Turton, the certificated manager, who was on the pit bank at the time, at once descended the mine, and several men were rescued by him, with the assistance of others who were soon on the spot. Since that time explorations have been pushed forward with all speed, and up to to-day 189 bodies have been recovered. It is still thought that one person yet remains in the mine, and explorations still continue. The ventilation of the mine has been fairly described to you by Mr. Turton. He states the total quantity passing down this pit to have been 50,350 cubic feet per minute, distributed in the different seams as follows, viz. : Ravenhead Main Delf, 13,050 feet per minute ; Ravenhead Higher Delf, 11,800 feet per minute ; Lower Florida and Upper Florida mines, 20,500 cubic feet per minute. If you accept the corrected quantities as explained by Mr. Chadwick, they stand as follows, viz.:— Ravenhead Main Delf, 17,124 feet per minute ; Ravenhead Higher Delf, 16,117 feet per minute; and Upper and Lower Florida mines, 28,000 cubic feet per minute. The small scale of air passing through the Lower Florida mine does not materially affect the main current passing into the Upper Florida mine. It is a pity the anemometer was not kept in proper condition and daily records of ventilation entered in a book. The portion going to ventilate the Higher Florida mine passes down the main tunnel, which has an average area of about 75 square feet; it is then led into two intakes, each having an average area of 50 square feet, and travels up brow a distance of 500 yards, and first visiting Kay's place, being led to that point by brick stoppings, with the exception of the openings where coals are passing out, at which points either wooden doors or canvas are fixed. The air then passes along the edge of a small goaf or old working, which, with the small goaf below Kay's place, amounts to half a Cheshire acre. The same air then passes on and visits the men in the whole or fast workings, and afterwards round the slant broken workings and home to the bottom of the tunnel, passing up a ten-feet staple pit and into a main return, having an average area of 50 square feet, and then over an open furnace up the upcast shaft. This Higher Florida ventilation passes round the whole of the workings in one course, visiting in all 53 working-places, and travelling a distance of 4,300 yards. The whole of the persons employed in the Florida seam beyond the fault, the seat of the explosion, were using locked Davy lamps, with the exception of two or three locked clanny safety-lamps used in the main intake at special points. There were also some open gaslights at the bottom of the downcast, but in the main intake. Blasting with gunpowder was not practised in this seam, neither in coal or in stone work, and no shot has been fired there during the last 18 months. I have examined the mine as to signs of the blast, and find that the force of the explosion has extended from the neighbourhood of Pilkington's place in the up-brow workings downwards to the bottom of the incline tunnel, and from south to north in the neighbourhood of Baines's place, being very decided in and about Baines's place and the working-places below, the brattice-cloth being blown to pieces, and in some cases the trams are blown to pieces. The whole of the workmen in the up-brow workings have been killed instantly by the blast, all being found at their working-places, with the exception of six men in the neighbourhood of Holding's level. The slant-workings have escaped the blast, but the men engaged there have been suffocated by the after-damp, the product of the exploded fire-damp in the up-brow workings, most of whom had made an effort to escape, and were found some distance from their working-places as shown on the plan. It appears from the evidence that for some time previous to the explosion fire-damp had been noticed at the edge of the goaf or old work near Pilkington's place, and it was sometimes found in the working places themselves. It is not unusual to be able to detect fire-damp at the edge of a goaf even where the ventilation is brisk, but when this fire-damp extends back into the working roads it is a sign either that the means of ventilation are insufficient or that the airway along the edge of the goaf is too contracted, and so the air is driven to take the lower opening. It also appears from the evidence that fire-damp was seen for several days together in Baines's place, and also in the up-brow driven out of this. There were very long lengths of brattice in these two places, in one case 80 yards, and in the other about 76 yards. Under such conditions it would be more than likely that fire-damp would collect. This amount of bratticing would have been unnecessary had proper care been taken that the drivings should advance conjointly, so as to secure holeings at shorter distances. Fire-damp has also been mentioned as occurring down the slants, but the explosion has not originated there, nor does it appear even that it has extended to that part of the mine except as after-damp. The men who were found at A. on the plan, part-way down the slants, had brought their lamps with them, an evidence that the force exerted at this point had not even blown their lamps out. Judging from the evidence already referred to, and from what I have seen in the mine, I am of opinion — first, that this explosion originated at or near Evans's place, and that it came in contact with more fire-damp and had its force increased at or near Baines's place; second, that the fire-damp that ignited in the first instance was forced out of the goaf by falls (probably caused by drawing timber) into a too weak current of air, and locally fouling this current, came in contact in an explosive condition with some defective or injured lamp. Any fire-damp that may have been resting at this time at or about Pilkington's goaf would seriously increase the disastrous effects of the explosion. I consider the method of leading the ventilation in one continuous current over such a long distance and past the edge of a goaf giving off fire-damp, and in which falls of roof in the natural course of working frequently take place, and thence to workmen engaged in the new openings, showed a sad want of skill on the part of the management. The weakness of this system of ventilation was constantly made evident by the fire-damp frequently extending back into the working-places as spoken of by several witnesses. That knowing the goaf was charged with fire-damp it showed a want of precaution to allow timber to be drawn whilst the ordinary work of the mine was going on, because heavy falls of roof would occur, and would be likely to drive gas out into the roads. That 28,000 cubic feet of air per minute was an unusually small quantity of air to keep a mine safe in which 200 persons were at work, and where the seam was much broken up by faults, and it was likely to cause great difficulty to the under-officials in their attempts to keep the men's places clear of gas. This difficulty does appear actually to have arisen, judging from the evidence we have heard ; and this being so, prompt measures should have at once been taken to largely increase this quantity of air. The regulations of the colliery in other respects have been satisfactory, and there has been no want of discipline. A good deal has been said about a sudden outburst of gas. It is possible that this may have occurred; but keeping in view the evidence that has been given by workmen witnesses, I am strongly of opinion that the fire-damp draining from the upper goaf into a weak ventilation, and this issue of fire-damp being temporarily-increased by the roof falling where the coal had been got, was the real source of the accident. I should have expected Mr. Chadwick, the resident viewer, and who takes the general direction of the collieries, to have seen that the means and system of ventilation was such as would give the underofficials the opportunity of keeping the working-places of the mine in a satisfactory condition. The workmen witnesses who speak to having seen fire-damp in the mine, do not appear to have given information to any person of higher authority than a fireman. It was their duty, if the danger continued, to speak to the manager, and if he failed to apply a remedy they should have made it known to me." After a full and careful inquiry, the jury returned the following verdict :— "We believe there has been a fouling of air connected with an outburst of gas or fall of roof, but by whom the gas was ignited there is no evidence to show. The explosion was caused by a faulty ventilation, and by an accumulation of gas in goaves near Evan's place, which has been expelled from thence by a fall of roof, and assisted by other fouling which was known to exist, previous to the explosion, by firemen and others." The jury added the following recommendations :— "There should be two firemen's reports, one for each 'shift,' and that the ventilation should be in future carried out according to the wishes of the Government Inspectors. The jury think the lamp system good, but requires better supervision, especially that the machine to fasten the lead rivets should not be left carelessly in the mine." In consequence of the report of Queen's Counsel on the evidence adduced at the inquest, an inquiry was ordered under the 32nd section of the "Coal Mines Regulation Act, 1872," as to the conduct of Mr. John Turton, the certificated manager of this Wood Pit. This inquiry was held in Liverpool on the 24th September, and two following days, before Thomas Stamford Raffles, Esquire, stipendiary magistrate, assisted by G. C. Greenwell, Esquire, mining engineer, as assessor. Mr. Turton was charged as follows:— "1. On the 7th day of June 1878, the said John Turton was, and for many years previous to that date had been manager of the Wood Pits at the Haydock Collieries, situate at Haydock, near Wigan, in the county of Lancaster. "2. On the said 7th day of June 1878, at about eleven o'clock a.m., an explosion of gas occurred in a seam of the said Wood Pits, known by the name of the Higher Florida Mine South, by which explosion 189 men out of about 200 there employed in the said mine were killed. "3. The supply of air sent into the said mine was far below the amount required for the wants of the men (200 in number) and horses (11 in number) in it during the day shift, and for effectually clearing out the working-places, 53 in number. "4. Such supply of air had to travel too great a distance, by reason of which it encountered a resistance from friction when driving forward so long a column of atmosphere, whereby the ventilation was weakened. "5. The system in vogue in the said mine of sending the air in its early course along the skirts of the goaves on the rise side of the said mine, from whence it was carried to the men employed in straight workings, was calculated to convey gas to such men, and so was a faulty system of ventilation. "6. Too many working-places had previous to the said explosion been laid out and kept going, at one and the same time, for the thorough ventilation of them all, whilst some of them had been taken forward too far in advance of others. "7. On the date of the said explosion, from the causes mentioned in paragraphs 3, 4, 5, and 6 hereof, or from other causes, an adequate amount of ventilation was not constantly produced in the said mine to dilute and render harmless noxious gases to such an extent that the working-places of the shafts, levels, stables, and workings of the said mine, and the travellings roads to and from such working-places, should be in a fit state for working and passing therein as provided by the 1st general rule laid down in the 51st section of the said Act. "8. In consequence of the several allegations and reasons above appearing, or some of them, the said John Turton is, by reason of incompetency, unfit to discharge his duties as such manager. "9. In consequence of the several allegations and reasons above appearing, or some of them, the said John Turton is, by reason of gross negligence, unfit to discharge his duties as such manager." The result of this inquiry was that the magistrate handed back to Mr. Turton his certificate, on the ground that no evidence had been adduced to lead him to believe that it ought to be forfeited. It appeared from the evidence that Mr. Chadwick, the agent of the mine, and holding a superior position to the certificated manager, was to some extent responsible for the system upon which the mine was worked, Mr. Turton being in the habit of consulting him on all important matters, but to what extent such an arrangement would lessen the certificated manager's responsibility, or if at all, I am not able to say. It also appeared at this inquiry that an outburst of gas or fire-damp had taken place in the particular district of the mine which had been unanimously fixed upon by the witnesses at the coroner's inquest as the point where the explosion had originated. Between the coroner's inquiry and the Liverpool inquiry, excavations had been made in the mine which showed that an outburst had occurred and was still continuing in the district referred to. With the knowledge that an outburst of fire-damp did occur at or about the time of the explosion, it would be unreasonable to assume that it did not play the chief part in bringing about this explosion, but I am still of opinion, as expressed at the inquest, that the system of ventilation was bad, and the quantity of air (28,000 feet per minute) was an unusually small quantity of ventilation to keep a mine safe in which 200 persons were at work, and was likely to prove a fatal error in the case of any sudden increase of fire-damp, either from blowers or forced out of the goaf by falls of roof. I deem it to be my duty at every inquiry into the cause of mining accidents to point out as far as possible the whole of the circumstances which appear to have led up to such accidents and whether such circumstances point to a breach of the Act of Parliament or not, with the object of preventing similar accidents in the future, and I believe that the steps which have been taken in reference to this explosion will prove very beneficial throughout the district, and that they have not pressed unjustly on the officials connected with the management of the Wood Pit. The whole of the dependent relatives of the workmen who lost their lives in this sad catastrophe have been liberally provided for by public subscription. The sum raised for this purpose amounted to upwards of £26,000, and the number of recipients is 308. This handsome provision was secured by the efforts of the leading residents in the district of Newton-le-Willows. Messrs. Evans, the owners of the colliery, subscribing £3,000, and their workpeople £590.
If you are researching Michael King (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||