|
T. Peats
The Bunker's Hill Colliery Explosion The reports of Mr. T. Wynne, Inspector of coal mines, and Mr. G. W. Dowdeswell, Q.C., respecting the inquiry into the fatal explosion, on the 30th April last, at Bunker's Hill Colliery, by which 43 lives were lost, have been laid before Parliament. Mr. Wynne, Her Majesty's Inspector, says: "I have the honour to transmit to you a full report of what took place at the inquest on the 43 poor fellows who were killed by the explosion at Bunker's Hill Colliery on the 30th ult. I am much indebted to Mr. Dowdeswell for his able assistance in so clearly bringing out the facts of the case, and I believe he will report to you what in his opinion, is the only mode of avoiding such calamities. For more than 20 years I have been pointing out what a 'farce' it is, to prohibit the use of naked lights in mines, and yet allow powder to be used; and have indulged in the hope that self-preservation would prevail over the more idle method of getting coal by blasting, but 1 am now satisfied that the only safe course to take, is to prohibit the use of all explosives in coal mines, and in a few years the coal owners would wonder how they could have allowed their coals to be blown to atoms and the roofs shaken as they have been for so many years, and the colliers would find that, having got rid of the impure fumes of powder smoke and the dangers of explosions, together with the comparative safety from falls of roof, they were amply repaid for any extra labour the wedging process entailed. Nothing could more clearly show the advantage of wedging, over the use of powder than the state of the two downbrows of 600 yards each, which effectually withstood the enormous strain which must have been put upon them, by the force with which the air was driven from the seat of the explosion, to the top of the upcast shaft, for not so much as a hundredweight of coal was blown down in them, or the dips in the slightest degree injured, or indeed was that portion of the levels, which was driven without blasting. The only reason assigned for the change from wedging to blasting was, that Mr. Rigby could not compete with his neighbours, if he wedged his coal and they blasted theirs, so that to meet competition he was obliged to increase production and lessen cost. Mr. Hall, Mr. S. B. Gilroy, and myself, are of opinion, that the explosion was caused by the use of gunpowder; nor indeed could there be two opinions on the subject; and we are of opinion, that the use of powder or other explosives, should be entirely discontinued in fiery mines. Suggestions have been made that all shots should be fired during the night, but to me, it seems a hard case for the firemen, to be turned into a 'forlorn hope,' for the fatal explosion at Ince Hall Colliery last year, shows that even that system, is not a sufficient precaution, for the safety of human life. I think it only proper to instance Bunker's Hill Colliery, as a case forcibly illustrating the superiority of the fan, over other means of ventilating mines, as the engine, with a slight increase of speed (the fan being uninjured), restored the air current almost immediately after the explosion, enabling a party of explorers to enter the workings, to refix the stoppings, recover the bodies, and ascertain the extent of the disaster with the least possible delay. You will see that I do not attribute any blame to anyone connected with the management of the colliery, powder being at present in general use in the district, as are also the small air pipes or tubes for the purpose of conducting the air into the extremities of the workings. Mr. Dowdeswell in his report says : "My attention was principally directed to three points. First, to ascertain the cause of the explosion; secondly, to see whether the requirements of the Mines Regulation Act had been strictly observed; thirdly, whether any feasible precautions could be adopted to avoid such a catastrophe hereafter. Every person who was in the mine at the time of the exposion having perished, the cause of the explosion could only be gleaned from the subsequent examination. The conclusion is irresistible, that the explosion was caused by the firing of a shot in the thirling marked X on the plan, on the east side of the Engine-brow. I cross-examined the witnesses, in order to ascertain whether the rules had been strictly observed, and I am satisfied there had been no infraction of them. The fireman whose duty it was to fire the shot, and who had evidently fired it, was an experienced, steady man, and some of the witnesses proved, that before firing shots, he used to take the proper precautions of carefully testing the neighbourhood with his lamp. But I elicited from them, that the customary mode of igniting the touch-paper of the shot was most dangerous. The fireman, having tested the spot, withdrew to what he considered a place of safety, and there he opened his lamp, some touch-paper was lighted at it, and this was borne alight to the fuze, which was then kindled, and the fireman retired to some spot where the shot could not reach him. In this instance, evidently, the fuze had been kindled, and the man had so retired, and the explosion was caused by the flame of the blast. A common notion prevails among the miners that there is no danger of an explosion from a shot if it fires inwards, and does not blow out, but this case shows the idea to be erroneous, a large portion of coal having been dislodged by the shot. The source of the gas which exploded must remain to some extent matter of conjecture ; but there had evidently been a disengagement of gas from the floor of the mine, in the immediate neighbourhood of this thirling, and Mr. Gilroy was of opinion, that so rapid is its action, that it may have been developed and filled this thirling, which is on the rise, in the short interval between the examination of it by the fireman and the firing of the shot, and in this opinion Mr. Wynne seemed to concur. If this be correct, I can suggest no precautions which will be effectual, should blasting be practised; but whether this be the case or no, the lesson this catastrophe teaches, is, that either the use of gunpowder in gaseous mines should be altogether prohibited, or, if its use be allowed, the shots should be fired only between the shifts, when the firemen alone are in the mine. If this course were adopted, such a terrible calamity as the present, could not occur from this cause. I believe it would also tend to security against explosions from other causes. The firing of the shots produces a severe shock, and tends to the sudden development of gas. If the shots were fired, as they would be, immediately the men left the pits, time would be allowed for this development, which would be detected on the examination just before the next shift came down, whereas now it may and doubtless is, sometimes developed, while the men are at work. In the course of the inquiry, it appeared that this colliery was ventilated by means of pipes. This is certainly, as the jury thought, a defective mode of ventilation; it seems to be largely on the increase, and it certainly should be discouraged. Unless it be checked, I fear a danger of explosion will arise which a better system by means of brattice, would prevent."
If you are researching T. Peats (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||