logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Donate to support the Museum
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious

  Individual Details   Individual Details  
 


William Whitehead

Age:   24
Died:   5th Jan 1875
Accident:   5th Jan 1875
Year Born:   abt. 1851
Colliery:   Aldwarke Main
Company:   John Brown and Co.
Occupation:  
Notes:  
Explosion of gas
Buried:   [not known]
Category:  

Description

The first loss of life in the district through explosion of firedamp in the year 1875 occurred at the Aldwarke Main Colliery, near Rotherham, the property of Messrs. John Brown and Co., on 5th January. In this case, I regret to say, seven persons were killed. The following extract from the newspaper report of the inquest held by D. Wightman, Esq., coroner, containing the chief points of the evidence, with the remarks made by myself (which I now submit to you), will furnish you with the best description of the facts of the case.

Before commencing the proceedings, the coroner said he wished to mention a matter to the jury. His attention had been called to an examination that had been made of the colliery, and he wanted to know at whose instigation that examination was made. Mr. Ford was then called into the room, and the coroner put that question to him. Mr. Ford replied that it was the men themselves who suggested and carried out that examination without any instigation by him. The coroner said that it was a most improper proceeding. They certainly had the right to make any examination they thought fit, but they had no right to publish the result of that report and place it before the jury. It was the only time, with one exception, that such a proceeding had taken place since he had been coroner. It would tend to have a most prejudicial effect on the minds of the jury, the majority of whom must have seen that report, but he could only tell them that they must dismiss it from their minds altogether. If Mr. Ford had not moved the blame from his shoulders, he (the coroner) would have felt it to be his duty to have severely reprimanded him. It was a most impudent thing to publish a report of an investigation and state that nobody was to blame before the jury had heard the evidence of one single person on oath. It was perfectly right and praiseworthy for men to go down the pit and make an examination, for by that means valuable information might be laid before the jury; but what he complained of was the publishing of that report exonerating everybody from blame. Such a course would tend to stultify the jury and lead them by the nose. He might state that the newspapers stated that the examination was made at the invitation of Mr. Ford, but then the newspapers did not always get the correct information, but they got the most correct they could, and such as was supplied to them. He had heard Mr. Ford's explanation, but the report which had been published at any rate threw a certain amount of suspicion on Mr. Ford, and he ought to know much better than to allow such a proceeding to take place. Mr. Rhodes presumed that after Mr. Ford's denial the coroner did not say that he had caused the examination to be made. The coroner said he did not, but he was bound to say that Mr. Ford appeared to be the most likely man to suggest it. Mr. C. E. Rhodes said that Mr. Ford told him on the Saturday that some men wanted to go down the pit. The coroner said he did not at all object to the men going down the pit, but he objected to them publishing their report of the investigation before the jury had arrived at a decision. The coroner was informed that the reporters had been present at that meeting, but he hoped they had more sense than to attend, for by stopping away they would show more sense than those who invited them to be present. — The coroner's statement was entirely concurred in by the jury.

Charles Edward Rhodes said he was the certified manager at the Aldwarke Main Colliery. The owners of the colliery are Messrs. J. Brown and Co., Limited. They purchased Aldwarke Main and Carr House Collieries about 18 months ago. Both collieries are now worked together. He produced a plan of the colliery when the explosion took place. He explained the plan, and showed that the bodies were found in the pack road going into the Carr House Colliery. He was not at the colliery when the explosion took place. He was at Stockport. Naked lights exclusively were used in the pit. It is the Barnsley seam which is worked. — By Mr. Parker-Rhodes : He last saw the workings on the Saturday previously. — By Mr. Wardell: He had only been three weeks certified manager of the pit. He became so on the 20th December. At present the pit was being worked by lamps. They are not working in all parts of the pit. When they do, lamps will be used in all parts of the pit. It is the determination of the owners of the pit and himself. A resolution had been come to not to allow anything but locked safety lamps in any of the workings.

Robert Copley said he resided at Mangham Quarry, Parkgate. He was a fire-trier at Aldwarke Main Colliery. He was on duty on the 15th inst. from 10 o'clock on Monday night until 6 o'clock on Tuesday morning. His duties were to inspect the south part of the pit, to see that there was no gas and nothing wrong with the roadways. It included the roof and everything. He went along that pack road shortly after one o'clock on Tuesday morning, and looked at the roof and everything seemed right. There was no gas anywhere in the pit, except what was in the deep part of the workings, and there is always some there. It is so diluted that it is harmless. It was about 1,500 yards from where the accident occurred. He made a report of the condition of the pit in a book kept for that purpose, a few minutes before five o'clock. The book is called "The Ventilation Record Book." It is a general record book. If the roof fell he should record it in the pit. He reported that everything was "good and safe." He had been deputy since last September. He had been engaged in pits over 20 years. There was nothing unusual at the time he went off work on the morning of the explosion.

He had never seen the slightest symptom of gas in that district of the pit before. He was in bed when he first heard of the explosion, and he went to the pit. He went down, and was rendered helpless by the chokedamp, and had to be taken out helpless. As a matter of opinion, he thought there had been a fall of roof in the Carr House goaf, and the stoppings had been blown out; the gas had escaped into the roadway, and met the naked lights of the men. — By Mr. Wardell: He had the whole of the south side of the pit to examine. He went to the third south ending shortly after he went in the pit. He was not told that the men, the previous evening, had been sent out of the pack road. He did not know anything about it until after. If a place is "on the weight" he would not allow the men to go to the work if he considered it dangerous. He would consider it dangerous in the goaf when the roof had fallen in. He did not hear it was "on the weight." — By the Foreman: It is usual to let the men go in after he had examined. — By a juryman: He examined the pit with a safety lamp. He allowed the men to go into the pit with candles although he had examined it with a safety lamp. — By another juryman: The men had never complained to him about there being danger. He had heard since that the men had heard it "thumping" the day before. — By Mr. Rhodes : It is against the rules for a fire-trier to try the pit with a candle; if he did he would commit a breach of the rules.

Thomas Speight, deputy at the Aldwarke Main fit, was on duty on tne morning ot the accident, having succeeded previous witness at six o'clock. He saw him, and a report waa made to him to the effect that the Carr House workings, where the explosion occurred, were "all right and safe." Copley then left the pit. When the explosion took place, about twenty minutes past six o'clock, witness was in the pit bottom, but he did not hear the explosion. He would be about a thousand yards from the explosion. He first heard that there had been an explosion by a young man bringing him a report that his father thought there was gas in his place, which was in the south level, but witness replied that it was impossible for gas to rest in that level, because the ventilation was so good. He told the young man to go back to work, and sent Holroyd, one of the deputies, to see if there was any danger, and witness followed up and found that there had been an explosion. He went to the top of the first south ending, but the after-damp was so strong that he would not face it and returned. He then got to know that there had been an explosion, and made his way to the scene, and found the body of Usherwood in the third south ending. There was also a stopping blown out at the top of the first south ending, and he and Ford repaired it. He saw one man's body found, and then had to leave, but on his return the whole of the bodies had been recovered. They found a slight fall of roof on the top of the ending. He went into Griffiths' working place, where he found the stopping dividing Aldwarke from Carr House had been blown down, and the place was as full of gas and after-damp as it very well could be. His opinion as to the cause of the explosion was the same as that formed by Copley. — By Mr. Wardell: The reason he did not sign the book on the day of the explosion was because he was completely "muddled," he had worked so long, and was so full of after-damp that he could not have signed it. It was his practice to travel with a horn lantern, but if he were called upon to examine a goaf he should go to the pit bottom for his "Davy." From ten in the morning until two in the afternoon there was only one deputy in the pit. There are about 300 men and boys in the pit at one time, and during the four hours from ten to two o'clock there was only one deputy in the pit, but Mr. Ford used to go into the pit and travel it with a horn lantern. — By the jury: It was a brick stopping that had been blown down. — By Mr. Rhodes : He did not "try" for fire with a horn lantern, but only used it on the main roads where the men used naked lights. He did not think there was a large quantity of gas that was fired. He saw traces of fire on the pack wall, but only small traces. — Mr. Wardell thought it was absolutely necessary for a deputy to carry round with him a Davy lamp, and every time he goes round to look for gas. He should imagine that it was an oversight for the goafs not to be examined except from morning to morning. — By Mr. Rhodes: Witness had seen gas in the goaf, but not for a twelve-month. — Mr. Wardell: I certainly do not approve of a deputy going round with a naked light. It was an opinion held very strongly.

Thomas Ainsworth, who found the last six bodies in the pit, deposed that he was a deputy at Aldwarke Main Colliery. He saw all the men found. They were all buried within the goaf wall in the third south ending or level of the Old Carr House Colliery. There was no doubt that they had all been killed by the explosion.

Mr. Wardell, Government Inspector, reported as follows:

Aldwarke Main Colliery is in the district over which I am the chief inspector. On arriving at the colliery on the morning of the explosion I found steps were being taken to recover the bodies of those who had been killed, and in order to attain this the very greatest care was requisite, the Aldwarke Main and Carr House pits both being ventilated by means of furnaces, and in the latter the return air passes immediately over the flames. Trustworthy and competent men were stationed in the returns at each pit, in order that, were the critical moment to arrive rendering necessary such a course of action, the separation doors might be at once opened, and the return air cut off from the fires. By carrying the air gradually through the district affected by the explosion, and proceeding with proper caution, the bodies were all recovered during the same afternoon. Nothing was done without due and mature deliberation, and I am happy to record that, taking part throughout the day in the consultations rendered necessary, I thoroughly concurred in all that was decided upon, and am of opinion that the re-opening of the pit was conducted in a careful and creditable manner. The Barnsley seam is being worked at this colliery, and both here and at Carr House, which forms part of the same mine, there are very large areas of goaf standing in many parts, (owing to the hard and rocky nature of the roof,) apparently as when the coal was first removed. The up-cast shaft at Carr House acts also partly for Aldwarke Main, a stopping having a regulator in it being built between the workings at each pit, and a portion of the air from the district where the explosion occurred passing through. To a great extent in this neighbourhood the coal has been got, a few pillars only, at the extremity of what are termed the Carr House levels, being left, and it is here from whence, in my opinion, the gas came. The district in which this coal is being worked is called the Third South, and the distance from the levels to which I have alluded, to the shaft is 1,100 yards. The appearance of the roof and sides, and of the debris generally, together with the positions in which the stoppings and sheets were blown, all clearly indicated to my mind the fact that the explosion occurred at the point where the bodies were found, or at least six of them, the seventh having apparently lagged behind, he being found some little distance from the rest. In making this inspection of the pit, which I did so soon as the ventilation had been sufficiently restored, I was accompanied by my assistant, Mr. Gerrard, by Mr. Rhodes, the manager; and by Mr. Jacob Higson, and others. It was evident the men had never reached the "face" where they were to work, but had encountered the gas at the point where they were found, and as they were carrying simply a naked light an explosion took place. All the bodies were more or less burned ; yet beyond the stoppings and sheets in the immediate locality being blown down, some only partially, no damage was done to other parts of the pit. On either side of the pack road where the gas was ignited there exists a considerable goaf, in which the force of the explosion would naturally to a very great extent expend itself, the resistance being comparatively slight; and this in a measure accounts for the trifling amount of damage, and the localisation of the effects of the explosion. It is my opinion that the gas which existed at the point I have mentioned, and which may never have shown itself at the time of the examination by the deputy (one o'clock that morning), was forced by a fall, somewhere in the goaf along the levels and down the road to the light which the men were carrying; and as in a goaf of this magnitude, some 50 acres, there are acres together where the roof has never fallen, it is impossible to say how large the fall may have been. Some of the stoppings must have been blown down by this fall, and I judge this from their position, the explosion itself forcing out the remainder. No traces whatever exist in the direction of the shaft nearer to it than the west end of the third south ending. In this colliery, as at Rawmarsh, naked lights were used throughout the pit, and, further, the ventilation here also seemed to me very good and the air roads of sufficient size. The amount of air ascending the up-cast at Aldwarke is 150,000 cubic feet per minute, and the amount passing into the third south 50,000 cubic feet, of which 11,000 cubic feet scaled through the goaf, leaving 9,000 cubic feet passing to the face of the Carr House levels. And yet our inquiry here to-day is another proof of the liability of an admittedly well ventilated colliery to explosions of gas in this seam so long as naked lights are used. In my opinion, however unnecessary the use of safety lamps may have been thought generally in the mine, yet here in these Carr House levels, whilst working off this isolated piece of coal, in the midst of an enormous extent of goaf, and when the pressure must have been very considerable, naked lights should have been carefully prohibited. From the evidence, and from my examination there seems to me to have existed a laxity with regard to the keeping of the books which are required by the Act. The sixth general rule requires that a record shall be entered in a book whenever men are withdrawn from any part of a mine, by reason of any danger whatever. A further record must be made that the place is safe before the men are re-admitted. This seems to me to have been entirely neglected. So long as owners and managers continue to allow the use of, and workmen are so recklessly bent on using, naked lights in these fiery seams, repetitions of such calamities as this will inevitably arise. Whatever it be, whether a question of cost, or one of inferior light, so long as this risk is run, the best management in the world, coupled with the most perfect system of ventilation and the present efficient inspection, will never secure a mine from danger whilst working seams of the fiery character of the Barnsley seam, and subject to sudden eruptions of gas. I speak plainly and emphatically, because I think it of the utmost importance I should do so. We have hardly recovered from the shock caused by the dreadful explosion at Rawmarsh, before we are again involved in another, similar in many points, and chiefly in having the same cause. Year after year I have advised locked safety lamps generally in these seams, and advocated their adoption in every way. It is a very great mistake, and one which many have fallen into, to imagine that the use of safety lamps in a colliery means diminished ventilation or less watchful care, and consequently greater danger. If this were the case, I should be the last to advocate such a measure. At the collieries in my district, where safety lamps are used exclusively, I find the ventilation to be just as good and the discipline just as efficient as at those mines were naked lights are used, and I maintain that as the use of the lamp is a higher state of perfection in the working of these collieries, so the adjuncts, such as adequate ventilation, and skilful management increase in proportion, and all working together support each other, and render the mode of working safer and more secure. I have certain recommendations and suggestions to make to the owners, which I think will tend, if carried out, to increased safety. And these are — To use Stephenson's locked safety lamps exclusively ; to remove the lamp cabin to the surface; to adopt mechanical ventilation ; to abandon altogether the small amount of coal left in these Carr House workings ; to enforce better discipline with regard to the keeping of the books required under the Act; to arrange that there may be no such lengthy interval of time elapse between the examination of a working place by the fire-trier or deputy, and the arrival of the men, as was the case on the day of this explosion in the third south level; and I have only to hope further that the introduction of lamps may ultimately lead to the gradual disuse of gunpowder. Every facility has been afforded me by the owners and manager for completing my inspection of the pit, and I have therefore to render them my thanks, and I am most thankful to add that the Carr House Pit is already at work with safety lamps, and that naked lights will not again be introduced at Aldwarke Main.

In summing up, the coroner said that after the very elaborate report just read by Mr. Wardell, it would be unnecessary for him to say much to them. He was glad to find that Mr. Wardell was of opinion that nobody was to blame, for that freed them from the unpleasant duty of imputing blame to anyone. With regard to Mr. Wardell's suggestions, they must be concurred in by everyone. He had the honour to be coroner over a very large district, and he could say that there was no profession, trade, or calling in that district which was so dangerous as the use of the naked lights in the Barnsley seam. In the Aldwarke Pit, as in the one at Rawmarsh, the ventilation was excellent, yet the result was two fearful explosions, 23 lives being lost at Rawmarsh, and seven at Aldwarke. That convinced him, as it must convince the jury, that the use of naked lights in the Barnsley seam was dangerous in the extreme, and if he had the power he would prohibit their use. If these two terrible acccidents did not convince the authorities of the necessity of using lamps, he did not know what would. The only verdict the jury could find was one of accidental death, and if they thought that the circumstances of the case required any recommendation they must say what it should be, and it would be his duty to add it. The room was then cleared, and after a short consultation,

The jury found a verdict of "Accidental death," and appended to their verdict the recommendation "That a larger number of efficient deputies should be employed, that the use of naked lamps should be discontinued, and that safety lamps only should be used." The jury also referred to the manner in which the "danger record books" had been kept, and Mr. C. S. Rhodes, the certified manager, assured the jury that in future their recommendations should be strictly carried out


Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
05 Jan 1875  Dreadful Colliery Explosion (Annual Register for 1875)

Further Reading

  • South Yorkshire Mining Disasters, Vol. 1, 19th century by Brian Elliott, Published by Wharncliffe Books, 2012, ISBN 1-903425-64-6

Sources
  • 1875 Mines Inspectors Report (C. 1499), Yorkshire District by Frank N. Wardell, H.M. Inspector of Mines, Page: 277 Where to find this report
  • 1875 Mines Inspectors Report (C. 1499), Yorkshire District by Frank N. Wardell, H.M. Inspector of Mines, Page: 301, Accident Number: 2 Where to find this report

Researchers

If you are researching William Whitehead (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.

What is your name?
What is your contact email address?
What is your research interest?

 

Return Return   Return Return to Top

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print