|
Edward Williams
Explosions of Fire-damp. Accident No. 31 on Schedule. This explosion took place in the New Coal seam at the Wynnstay Colliery, Ruabon, Denbighshire, belonging to the New British Iron Co., on the 24th April 1873, causing the deaths of seven persons, the mine, which lies at an angle of one in three, was worked with locked safety lamps, the colliers being allowed to use gunpowder for the purpose of bringing the coal down after being holed, and a fireman was appointed to light the shots after they had been charged by the workmen, and his instructions were to examine the places before doing so, to ascertain if they were free from gas. Two levels were being driven, and it appears that the colliers in both places were ready to have their shots fired when Griffith Hughes, the fireman, since deceased, went into the lower level and fired a shot, which went off all right as spoken to by the witness John Hughes, shortly after, another shot was heard by him to go off, as he thought, in the higher level immediately followed by an explosion. The accompanying section shows the position of the shots as placed in the coal in the upper level where the explosion took place, the shot A. on the lower side of the place, appears to have blown only a small piece of coal off from a slip at the front, the higher side shot B. has been badly planted, the hole being drilled into a hard "brass" lying above the portion of coal seam worked, and probably insufficiently stemmed, which would account for the charge being blown out, and the two reports being heard so closely following each other shows that both shots had been lighted together instead of separately, if the shot A. exploded first, gas might have been liberated from the slip in the coal and the second shot B. would ignite it, neither of the shot holes had been drilled deep enough. At the adjourned inquest held at Rhos-y-Medre on the 16th May before B. H. Thelwall, Esq. coroner for Denbighshire, the following evidence was taken :— Mr. Ralph Darlington sworn said "he was the certificated manager of the Wynnstay Colliery and personally knew all the deceased. He produced a plan of the workings of the colliery, Nos. 1 and 2 pits were downcasts and No. 3 was the upcast for all the colliery, the ventilation being produced by a furnace placed at the bottom, the men were working in No. 1 pit in the New Coal seam, which is 308 yards deep, and were 820 yards from the "Pit-eye" in a S.W. direction, the explosion took place at 12.15 p.m. on the 24th April, he had not been down the pit that day, had been down the day previous but did not go to the very point of the accident, no man could examine the whole of the pit himself, and they had three certificated managers, the fireman had seen the place in the morning, it being his duty to inspect it, and he now produced his report which stated "I have duly examined the above district and find all the working places free from gas and dirt and in good working order" his opinion was that a shot had been overcharged and badly planted in the top level, he saw the place three-quarters of an hour after the explosion, and did not believe there was any gas in the place. It was the duty of George Edwards to bore the hole, he (witness) believed the explosion was from powder and that the men were burnt by the powder inconsequence of the shot blowing out, there were two shots in the place and the first appeared to have been overcharged and had only blown a little coal off at a slip, the hole ought to have been at least 12 inches deeper. The fireman had been appointed 18 months and he considered him a competent man, did not think him in any way to blame, but thought the colliers had made a mistake in planting the shots badly, the second shot did not break any coal the hole being driven into the brass above, but it was not customary for that to be done. They had no rule to the effect that the fireman was to inspect the holes before charging, he was of opinion that if the hole had been properly drilled the accident would not have happened. The men nearest to the shot when it went off were about 47 yards from the face, the others about 180 yards from it, he thought the B, or second shot did the mischief, it exploding two minutes after the A. shot, the shots were 12 to 13 inches long and 1½ inches diameter, he believed the second shot going off so soon after would set fire to the dust caused by the first, which would account for the flame as spoken to by some of the workmen, he believed the man Thomas who was found 180 yards off had been burnt by the heated air and not by the flame, had known a bag of powder fired 50 yards from a blown out shot, he had never seen gas in this place, although the ventilation had been cut off for 15 days nothing had been perceived, if there had been an explosion of gas, a vacuum would have been caused which would have drawn out gas, but in the present case there was no such vacuum nor was there any after damp, which is always left after an explosion. There is a workmen's committee appointed who examine all the places weekly and report the result in a book (book produced) and all reports appear satisfactory, he considers such reports valuable. The total amount of ventilation is 201,800 cubic feet per minute, of which 31,400 cubic feet goes into the New Coal workings, since the explosion a set of rules has been drawn up for the shot lighters, one of which is that no hole is to be charged until it has been examined by the fireman, he has already had to condemn four badly bored holes as being like those blown out on the 24th April, the lighting of two shots in one place at one time is contrary to orders and the fireman ought not to have done so." Mr. Joseph Darlington sworn, said "he was the certificated manager of No. 1 pit at Wynnstay Colliery, in which the explosion took place; he knew all the deceased who worked under him; he was down the pit on the morning in question, and examined the working places about 6 a.m., but there was no gas to be seen; it was the colliers' duty to drill the holes and charge them, then send for the fireman. His opinion was that the men were burnt from the effects of two blown out shots; the holes were not deep enough, and the powder was put in the "fast"; the ramming was too weak, and would be forced out of the hole without breaking down the coal; he thought the collier had not been sufficiently cautious, judging from the position of the holes, and that if the shots had been properly planted the accident would not have occurred; the two shots had been lighted together against orders, and the lower side one going off first would raise the dust, and the second shot blowing out would set fire to it, and, in his opinion, the flame would continue so long as it had any support, and this is what burnt the men; when he last saw the men they were waiting to have the shots fired, he looked at the place and found it all right; the men told him they had never seen any gas in the place. He was about 600 yards from the place when the explosion took place, and distinctly felt the shock and rush of wind; he thought no shot ought to be charged before the fireman had examined the hole, and orders had since then been given to that effect." John Hughes, collier, said "he worked in the New Coal in No. 1 pit, and was acquainted with all the deceased. On the day of the accident he was down about 6 a.m.; he worked in a deep place off the low level; he heard a shot fired shortly after noon, as he thought, in the lower level, which went off all right; about 10 minutes after, he heard another shot go off in what he believes to be the higher level, closely followed by a great rush of wind and flash of fire which threw him down in his working place; as soon as possible he got up and saw some sparks on the level; on getting to the top of his place, he fell again and could get no further than the main road, where he found Richard Thomas had been killed; he was nearly smothered with dust before getting out. Thomas was a greater distance from the shots than any of the others." Thomas Phillips, aged 14, horse driver, said "he was in the pit on the day of the explosion, and was near to where Richard Thomas was killed; about a minute before it. happened he had spoken to Thomas, who was taking a tub to be filled when he met the blast, which threw the tub over to the other side of him, and he did not see him alive after that; witness was sitting down at the time, and was burnt a little on the hands and face ; he saw flame come along the level and close to his head, and then he was blown over by a great rush of wind." David Roberts, collier, said "he was working at the Wynnstay Colliery and was one of the workmen's committee for inspecting the mine, which he believed was authorised by the New Mines Regulation Act. He knew the place where the explosion took place, and last visited it on the 18th April; there was no gas present; he never saw gas in that place, he had been in it frequently ; did not think the deceased were burnt with gas, but by powder from a blown out shot; the coal dust had, he thought, caught fire, though he had never known such a thing to happen before; he was one of 24 workmen who examined the working places and return air-roads every week, and made their report in a book kept for that purpose." Mr. Thomas Bell was sworn, and said "I am the Assistant Inspector of Mines for the West Lancashire and North Wales District, and am now acting in charge during Mr. Higson's illness. I examined the workings of the Wynnstay Colliery four days after the explosion ; on the low level I found a shot had been fired in the coal, which was blown and still lying, it appeared to have done its work properly ; in the upper level a shot had been fired at A. doing very little work, simply blowing a small piece of coal off at a slip in the front in wedge shape; the hole was not drilled deep enough, having apparently got against the brass at top and been stopped; a charge of powder 12 or 13 inches put in would not leave much room for stemming, the shot B. on the rise side of the place had been started near the top and bored at an angle of 1 in 3, going right through the hard or "brass," and not more than half the depth of the holing; the first shot was in a better position although it did touch the "brass"; powder placed in such a position could not break down the coal, as it would be held by the seam of "brass," and, as the stemming would be too light to resist the force, is sufficient to account for the shot being blown out; the effect of a large charge of powder like this being blown out with such force would be sufficient to account for the burning of the four men who were only 47 yards off on the upper level, but not to follow on its course to lower level, and burn the boy Phillips who was about 180 yards off, the flame having to go round two turns at right angles to the level before reaching the latter place; that two shots had been lighted at one time in the upper level seems to admit of little doubt; I am of opinion that one of two things must have occurred to cause the explosion and to do the damage to the mine which the shot of itself could not do : first, a shot was fired on the lower level about 10 minutes before the explosion, and any gas that might be liberated at that point would be carried by the current of air to the upper level, where it would just have about time to reach, when the shot A. went off, when it would probably be augmented by gas coming from the slip or break in the coal, and the two might be sufficient to foul a portion of the place, and would be ignited by the shot B.; second, the effect of shot B. being blown out with sufficient force would be to create a partial vacuum in the place, which would be immediately filled with gas from the cavities in the coal, and would at once become mixed with sufficient atmospheric air to make it explosive, and would be ignited by the burning embers left by the shot. The suggestion of Mr. Darlington to have all the holes examined by a competent person before the powder is put in is a very good one, and will lead to the prevention of a great number of accidents which are daily taking place in this district, and I should be glad to see it generally adopted by the colliery managers. The coroner then addressed the jury, after which the room was cleared. After a few minutes deliberation, the foreman (Mr. Joshua Roberts) stated that the jury had decided upon the following verdict: "That from the evidence before us, the accident occurred from an explosion of powder arising from the drill holes not being sufficiently bored, and the ramming being improperly secured, and we attach to our verdict a recommendation to the company to carry out the suggestion that has been made, as to having the holes examined before the powder is put in."
If you are researching Edward Williams (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 30 Apr 2023
|
Search |
|
|||