|
John Price
The fourth explosion occurred in the Ferndale Colliery, belonging to Messrs. David Davis and Sons, on the 10th of June, resulting in the loss of 53 lives. The coroner's inquest in this case was a lengthened one, extending over more than three months. I was assisted in the investigation as to the cause of this explosion by my colleague Mr. Brough, whose evidence as well as my own, as given at the inquest, I append. Mr. Lionel Brough said:— I am the Government inspector of the coal and ironstone mines of the South-western division of the kingdom, and I have assisted Mr. T. E. Wales by order of the Right Honourable the Secretary of State for the Home Department. I have been twice in the Ferndale Colliery since the explosion. My first inspection took place on Wednesday, the 16th June, and the second underground visit was on Thursday, the 15th day of July. I have listened to most of the evidence given in this court since it was opened, and that which I did not hear has been supplied to me by my colleague. Ferndale is aired by furnace power, but Mr. Wales' description of it is more complete than mine, inasmuch as he is far more intimately acquainted with the colliery than I can possibly make myself by the mere inspection of a couple of days. Suffice it to say, then, that on the 15th July we made out that the various currents of air amounted to 102,047 cubic feet per minute, but then it must be borne in mind that on that day the water was nearly roofed on the top of the No. 7 dip steading, so that the normal quantity of wind was not then actually passing. Five days after the explosion, Mr. Wales informs me that he found a larger quantity than that which I have just recorded. My own opinion is, that when all was going well the average amount of fresh air passing down the winding pit would not be less than 110,000 cubic feet per minute. I do not see but what that would be sufficient to meet the exigencies of the Act of Parliament as far as "ordinary circumstances" are concerned; but as at times the Ferndale Colliery, and indeed most others, is liable to extraordinary and abnormal conditions, then I would very much like to be more on the side of safety, and for that reason it would be desirous to advocate that the words "under ordinary circumstances" should in any future legislative enactment be struck out of the first general rule. However, it is the existing statute that guides us in the present inquiry, and I must repeat that I am not here to state that 110,000 cubic feet of air was too little for the ventilation of the Ferndale Colliery. Nevertheless, if more wind could have saved all those lives on the 10th of June last, then the value of the expunging of those three words would be made manifest. I am conscientiously of opinion that the rule would have been better, because clearer, if those three words had never been inserted at all, and their expurgation will be the initial step towards the reduction of the number of deaths that take place by explosions of firedamp underground. If the present quantity of air should be found insufficient to keep this colliery safe, then the owners will be bound to supply the required increase, and certainly the application of more power is not difficult, nor will it be found to be very expensive. There is room enough for another furnace, and the ventilation may be rendered complete by raising a stack on the upcast, but it should be of the full size and shape of the pit. One advantage, at all events, would arise from this latter improvement — even if it did not increase the volume of air, it would certainly prevent the baffling to which it is liable in consequence of the peculiar configuration of hill and valley in the immediate neighbourhood, and also by reason of the mountain storms that often prevail there. With regard to the cause of the disaster which brings us together this day, I have formed an opinion which I think is reasonably founded, but in order to give the opinion greater weight I must premise that in all the evidence that has been tendered the allegation of accumulation of firedamp in the workings is but faintly supported. Indeed, it becomes questionable whether standing gas was really met with at all for some time previous to the explosion. This I hope to be true, for we cannot hide from ourselves that the deliberately allowing of gas to gather together in working faces and travelling roads, and then letting it remain there, would not only be a violation of the law, but also an outrage to humanity. Blowers are deposed to by various witnesses, and their frequent appearance is beyond all doubt, but that the gas remained for any length of time in the working places is without confirmation. Upon the whole, these sudden eruptions of gas seem to be promptly dealt with, and, so far, accumulations of firedamp were not permitted. On this subject nothing can be more clear than the ruling of the justices of the Court of Queen's Bench in the Tredegar case. The Lord Chief Justice said that the provision of the statute is to the effect that the whole mine must be kept ventilated, so as to prevent the working in places becoming dangerous by reason of gas accumulating in them. You must ventilate so much of it as that it will be safe for the working people. And Mr. Justice Blackburn said he "concurred in that interpretation of the rule as laid down by my Lord; the meaning is, that you shall ventilate the mine to such an extent that there will be no danger to the working places." In all that I have now said and quoted with regard to accumulations of gas and of sudden blowers I refer, of course, to the circumstances in existence previous to the explosion. What happened afterwards has nothing to do with the present inquiry. I have not been able in my own district to do away with the use of gunpowder. In this respect Ferndale is better off than any collieries I habitually inspect, because, through the intervention of Mr. Wales, the owners consented to the total abandonment of shot firing in the coal; but for all this advantage, and notwithstanding such a supply of fresh air as is seldom met with in the principality, the pit has fired a second time. It is true that the Rhondda Vach is a virgin magazine of firedamp which has never been tapped as far as I know anywhere, except at the Ferndale Colliery. This circumstance assists us in some degree in understanding the nature of those heavy falls of roof and frequently recorded occurrence of blowers, and so to a certain extent becomes a clue in seeking for the cause of explosion. I am, then, strongly inclined to believe that the leaving of the upper vein (the two-feet-nine) untouched has much to do with the disturbance of strata that appears so often in the journal or log book. On reference to that record many entries will be found of "blowers and heavy falls to-day," and occasionally will be seen "no blowers or falls to-day," which would almost admit the fact of blowers and falls being really the normal condition of the colliery. The "upper four," being worked on the outstroke, the measures above it get loosened, perhaps even up to the "two-feet-nine" itself, and I entirely believe that the concentrated gas in it and in its concomitant beds acts most energetically on the roof of the larger seams, and expends itself in such force as not only to bring down ponderous falls of top in the working faces and roadways of the "upper four," but also to fill them suddenly with floods of discharged firedamp, and then a bad lamp brings about explosion. That, indeed, may take place with perfect lamps, for the physical action of a heavy fall is displacement of air, which rushes in all directions where space can be found, carrying with it the eliminated hydrocarbon at such speed that it must be a remarkable lamp that will not pass the flame; in other words, the sudden expansion of the compressed gas and the heavy falls are but cause and effect. Do away with the action of the one, and the other will cease to appear. Mr. Wales and myself believe that the cessation of those phenomena, or a great mitigation thereof, will be arrived at by working the "two feet nine" simultaneously with the "upper four" and a little in advance of it, and that this process will greatly modify the difficulty of working and airing the colliery. In all extraction of coal, if it is found that one system is unsuitable, then by all manner of means alter that method of working. If the mode just described will not do, endeavour to arrive at some other. There are many ways of getting coal. Anyhow it will be far better to attempt some improved plan than to undergo another explosion at Ferndale. In my own opinion, in which I believe I am joined by Mr. Wales, the disaster we are now investigating was entirely brought about by one of those falls of roof. Its site might have been near No. 5, or No. 6, or No. 7, all north headings. In my map I have marked with the letter F a heavy fall in each of those places. The ignition of the gas brought down would be by a lamp, perfect or imperfect, as already described. I cannot take upon myself to say which of those falls caused the explosion, but I am strongly inclined to think it was the one between No. 7 south and No. 5 north, but either of the three would be sufficient to account for the terrible results that followed. Moreover, the direction of the doors and disturbed timbers is consistent with explosion at any one of those three points, unless, indeed, the evidence given by Richard Griffiths shakes that view. I think he said the two doors at No. 7 were blown northwards, but that is extremely doubtful. Such then is my opinion of the cause of the Ferndale fatality, namely, a heavy fall at top. I may add that I did not myself find any gas in my explorations, which to a certain extent is confirmatory of this view. I may here observe, as I did at the inquest of 1867, that as an explosion has followed, by partial vacuum it sometimes happens that timber which withstood the blast may fall in a contrary direction by the "suck of the pit," as it is called; therefore we should not always and invariably rely on the direction in which we may find materials prostrated. On the occasion of my first inspection on the 16th June, I rather inclined to the theory that in some portion of No. 7 dip workings was to be found the source of destruction, but subsequent examination and closer reasoning convince me that the cause of explosion was a great fall somewhere between Nos. 5 and 7 north, as already mentioned, Now where such a colliery as Ferndale is concerned, the strict sense of duty compels me to speak of safety lamps so called. The present requirement, then, is one that will not pass the flame through the gauze under a speed of 30 or 40 feet per second; and that class of lamp I think did not prevail in Ferndale prior to the explosion. Now, this desideratum is said to be found in the invention of Mr. Hann, of Mr. Lindsay Wood, and of Mr. Morrison; also our county member (Mr. Vivian) the other day spoke to me about another lamp at the Morfa, of a very promising kind indeed, but which as yet I have not seen. After ventilation, I need not say, that the next most important consideration is the lighting of coal mines. In experiments lately made by practical men in the north of England it was found that at the speed of eight feet per second, and in some instances even still lower, the gauze actually passed the flame. If this be so, it is incumbent on colliery owners to use only those lamps which are reputed to be the safest. Men's lives must not be endangered for the sake of sixpence or a shilling in the price of a lamp. In coming near the conclusion of this evidence, I may remark that in working the "two-feet-nine," and so preventing any falls, the prevalence of blowers will disappear also to a very considerable extent. But in this way of carrying on the colliery it will be absolutely necessary to find stuff to fill up all the hollows; and, moreover, in the working faces the top must be received on a strong gob. It will be remembered in evidence that Mr. David Rees informed Mr. Bedlington of the necessity of filling up the places. Another witness (R. Griffiths) had also spoken of the danger of leaving places unfilled. I also beg permission to add my testimony to the same effect. Stowing or filling up all hollows will add to the security of the top, and greatly assist in preventing the leakage of air. If there were no stuff in the pit it might be sought for elsewhere, but however, if the "two-feet-nine" and the "upper four" are both worked at the same time, there will then perhaps be plenty of stone and stuff for "gobbing" and filling up. I do not know that it is any part of my duty here to meddle with the alleged difficulty of procuring timber for the construction of cogs, but I must make one remark about the mode of supporting the top in the working places, and it is that nothing in the world can hold it up so well; but with the present mode of working the "upper four" feet vein the roof will come down somewhere. And who knows but that these strong and staunch cogs have something to do with the fall of these tremendously heavy superincumbent masses in the roadways and elsewhere? I grant that a cog will securely support the top in its own immediate neighbourhood, but as the colliery is now carried on, I repeat the vast and thick roof is sure to come down in some part or other of the roads or workings. Another point in the evidence I cannot refrain from remarking on is the strange plan to which workmen are obliged to resort in order to obtain rails and other materials, that is to say, by going into abandoned places to procure that which is essential to the getting of their bread. If the evidence about this extraordinary method of supply is to be relied on, I cannot help expressing a doubt in my own mind to which party it is most disadvantageous, the workmen or the owners. Perhaps the men are the worse off, because to their share falls the element of danger. During my second inspection I found a portion of the return air course, perhaps a couple of hundred yards or so, of magnificent sectional area, but I was told that such improvement had been stopped. This I regret, because if all the returns had been of that size, the very objectionable water gauge of 2.10 inches might have been reduced by at least half an inch. There is no truth-teller underground like the water gauge. Finally, I beg permission to bring under your notice a circumstance connected with this event that had obtained consideration years and years before either Ferndale explosion. I speak of panels in underground workings. The colliery we are now giving and hearing evidence about is so laid out, whether by design or by chance I know not, as in some respects to come under the category of panelling. The explosion of 1867 was unattended with death on the Duffryn side, and now the second explosion of June last, though frightful in fatality in the Duffryn, has not killed a single person in the Rhondda and the Glo-bach. Those two districts remained entirely undisturbed. There are many amongst us who think panelling is of little use; but the two explosions in Ferndale tell altogether a different story ; and what is remarkable is, that the separation of one district from the other is but imperfectly arrived at, and yet on the occasion of both explosions that faint and uncertain isolation appears to have been the means of saving life. This is worth remembering by those who in future may have to lay out new collieries in fiery neighbourhoods. The disasters which have occurred this year, both at home and abroad, have been so desolating as to urge us on to neglect no improvement, to overlook no prudential step within our means, to ward off and put a stop to these terrible explosions of firedamp. Copy of my own Report at the Inquest. As Inspector of Mines for the South Wales District, it has devolved upon me to inspect the Ferndale Colliery, to ascertain, if possible, the cause of the explosion which occurred there on the morning of Thursday, the 10th of June last. It will be remembered that it is not yet two years since the previous explosion occurred in this colliery, whereby no less than 178 lives were lost. This fact should stimulate all concerned in this important inquiry to make it one of a most searching nature. You have already had a very detailed account from the different witnesses as to the mode of working, and I shall not therefore trouble you with a repetition of that, but at once proceed to give a general outline of the colliery. The Ferndale Colliery is sunk in a district where large tracts of the celebrated Aberdare steam coals abound and are comparatively untouched, so that it is the only outlet for the large quantity of gas liberated, and occasionally under great pressure in working those coals. The coal worked at this colliery is known as the Aberdare upper four feet steam coal. It is a fiery coal, and is therefore worked entirely with locked safety lamps. In accordance with suggestions made by myself for the safer working of this colliery, shot firing is strictly prohibited during working hours. Long wall is for the most part the principle of working, but double stall is to some extent introduced. I believe the quantity of air travelling at the time of the explosion on the 10th of June would probably be about 110,000 feet per minute. After noticing the evidence of the several witnesses who had been called, Mr. Wales went on to give an account of his own examination of the Duffryn district immediately after the explosion. He said: I had business in the Aberdare district on the morning of the explosion, and I was enabled to search the colliery within six or seven hours after the explosion occurred. On reaching the pit I immediately descended and proceeded up the north and west level, where the explorers were engaged in recovering the bodies. I found the air-crossing had been blown away, and been again partially repaired, as well as the different doors. I also found that several falls had occurred, and between No. 6 and No. 7 headings north there was a very large fall. The roof was then in a very unsettled state there. This would go to show that at that point the roof had been subjected to some great disturbing cause, and that of recent origin. I have also from time to time since that been in the colliery, and made very careful examinations into such matters and things as I thought were calculated to enable me to form an opinion as to the cause of the explosion, where it occurred, and the probable condition of the workings immediately before it occurred. On Thursday, the 15th of July, Mr. Brough and myself examined the whole of the Duffryn district, excepting of course the No. 7 dip, which was then filled with water; and although the quantity of air passing was considerably reduced, we failed to find any accumulation of gas, even of the smallest extent. The quantity of air passing into the district at the time of the explosion would probably be about 30,000 feet per minute, so that it would require a discharge of from 2,500 to 3,000 feet of gas per minute to have rendered such a current explosive, and if such a discharge continued only for five minutes there would be from 120,000 to 150,000 cubic feet of highly explosive gas, quite sufficient in my opinion to have caused the terrible results which we all so much deplore. Experiments made by some of our ablest mining men of the day have proved beyond a doubt that the safety lamps now in general use — I mean the Davy, Stephenson, and Clanny — are unsafe, and will pass the flame when exposed to an explosive current having a velocity of eight or nine feet per second, which is only from five to six miles an hour; and at almost any point on the No. 1 west "intake" level the air would be travelling at a much higher velocity than eight or nine feet per second ; so that if that current of air was rendered explosive, it was not necessary that it should come in contact either with a naked light or a defective lamp to have caused the explosion. Since these startling facts were made known much attention has been given to the subject, and several lamps — Messrs. Lindsay Wood's, Hann's, Morrison's and others — have been discovered, which I am told are safe up to a velocity of 30 or 40 feet per second, but it is found that such lamps are easily put out on being moved, which is a great drawback to their general adoption, but I hope this defect may ultimately be overcome. From the absence of evidence to show that there was any accumulation of gas in any part of the district on the morning of the explosion ; from the frequent occurrence of blowers ; from the large quantity of air, about 30,000 feet per minute, passing into the district, and from my own personal observations made during several careful inspections of the district, one having been made on Saturday last, I am of opinion that the calamity is to be attributed to a large and sudden outburst of gas somewhere on the No. 1 west intake level, which may have come from the two-feet-nine vein, which lies only 10 or 12 yards above the four-feet coal, and that owing to the high velocity at which the air was travelling, it was exploded by one of the lamps; and from the position of the doors, &c, I think the explosion probably began somewhere near the beginning or top of No. 7 dip on the same No. 1 west level. If the two-feet-nine coal was worked in advance of or simultaneously with the four-feet coal, it might to some extent relieve the working of the latter from those sudden outbursts of gas; and I would also suggest that the principle of working by double stall be discontinued, and that the workings of the colliery generally should be more concentrated. The adoption of such would, I think, greatly reduce the distance the air has to travel, as well as the number of doors necessary to direct it through the workings. But in my opinion the great safeguard against these sudden outbursts of gas will have to be found in the discovery of a more perfect safety lamp; one that will either be quite safe in explosive currents travelling at high velocities, or one that would be immediately extinguished in coming in contact with explosive gas. The coroner then directed the jury upon the evidence. The jury, after deliberating for an hour and a quarter, brought in the following verdict: "We find that the deceased came to their death from an explosion of firedamp in the Ferndale Colliery, on the 10th of June last; but we have not sufficient evidence to satisfy us as to where it arose. We are of opinion that the air was not properly distributed over the whole of the pit, and that the wind-ways were not of sufficient size. We regret that we should have to investigate another explosion in this colliery so soon after the terrible catastrophe of 1867. We regret also that the suggestions of the jury on that occasion have not all been fully carried out by the manager and officials of the pit. The evidence shows a lamentable want of care on the part of the officers of the pit. We beg to offer the following suggestions: First, That a Government inspector should visit every pit once in three months, and that a sufficient number of sub-inspectors should be appointed with proper authority. Second, we think that all officers having the charge of collieries should undergo an examination and obtain a certificate of their qualifications before they are allowed to undertake their duties. Third, we recommend that all old workings be filled up immediately after they are abandoned. Fourth, we recommend that the resident manager should have the sole control and management of the workings of the mine."
If you are researching John Price (e.g. for family tree purposes) and you would like to hear from others with the same interest then please complete the details in the following form. We will show the information you provide on this page so that you can be contacted.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 31 Dec 2022
|
Search |
|
|||